The only performance ive ever heard of this that is actually crotchet =144 sounded a mess. but if its taken too slow it defeats the object of the piece.
what would people say is an acceptable tempo range?
also, how generous (or not) are people with the soft pedal considering 80% of the piece is 'pp'?
Logged
"Several persons have vigorously either criticized or praised me, and always wrongly and for things I had not done." - Olivier Messiaen
Go to your local library and listen to recordings. Your best bet is to make a list of tempos by different artists. I am sure you will find all sorts of tempos.
Also, be careful when using the una corda pedal. Variety of colour and sound are wonderful but the last thing that you would want to do is "ride" the soft pedal.
I agree! Listen to many recordings. Everybody has their own ideas, sounds and tempo for the Toccata. You will finds yours. Also look at editions and see the tempo markings and how they compare. Good luck!
The only performance ive ever heard of this that is actually crotchet =144 sounded a mess. but if its taken too slow it defeats the object of the piece.
what would people say is an acceptable tempo range?
also, how generous (or not) are people with the soft pedal considering 80% of the piece is 'pp'?
Ravel recorded this himself - check it out.
Logged
Asked if he had ever conducted any Stockhausen,Sir Thomas Beecham replied, "No, but I once trod in some."
Una Corda is cheating and sounds wrong to produce pp unless you are asked to do so. Una Corda has a particular sound to it, so you have to know when its application is "tasteful". It is not to simply make your playing quieter.
Logged
"The biggest risk in life is to take no risk at all."