Tchaikovsky piano concerto - your opinion please

[franz_]

Hi,

Does anyone played this concerto here?
I have the impression that it is difficult, but technically not SO difficult, for sure if you compare it to other great romantic concertos. Am I right or wrong?

Any suggestions, ideas, difficulties,... on this concerto?

[franz_]

No one??

[schartmanovich]

I played this concerto a few years ago and still keep it up for performance (even though I haven't performed it in ages). Technically speaking, you're right, the concerto is not that difficult. In Russia, for example, it is considered an intermediate-level work.

The first movement is quite easy although the cadenzas pose some difficulties. The second movement is probably the most difficult (the middle section can get away from you very easily). The third movement (provided your thirds are up to par) is not that difficult at all (especially since the nerves are gone by this point). Just a caution: don't try to pull a Horowitz on the octaves unless you honestly do have the technique...they'll sound muddy, unvoiced, and, quite simply, bad.

This is only my opinion, but I sincerely feel that the difficulty level of this concerto is often exaggerated.

[thierry13]

The hardest part of this concerto is the work of sound.