Opinions Please

[piano_ant]

Composition i did with sibelius. Nothing original abot it really, just basically writing down stuff that comes to mind. kind of messes up a little but you'll get the idea.  Actually i wrote it for a girl. but whatever... tell me what you guys think.

[lostinidlewonder]

The piano sounds ok, the violin sounds really poo.

[pianistimo]

that's because it's really a clarinet.

you're a really good composer.  very haunting and very beautiful.  sort of beethoven moonlightish - and yet the melodic parts winding above.  i kind of wish they'd be even 'freer' in melodic rubato now that we've had threads on this.  but, i realize with computer, you can't always do that.  my impression of your composition is that you are talented.

[piano_ant]

thank you very much. yeah i feel the same way... the sound quality is not good in some parts and i need to rewrite some of the rythms... i'll work on that... thanks for the comments!!!

-tony-