Piano Forum

Piano Board => Miscellaneous => Topic started by: schumaniac on August 20, 2015, 02:25:54 AM

Title: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on August 20, 2015, 02:25:54 AM
What are some of the competitions coming up? I can think of:

- The Busoni
- The Chopin

Which candidates do you think are promising in both competitions? For the Chopin, I think the younger crop- Tiffany Poon, Annie Zhou, etc. - are exceptional, and so are some of the pianists on the other side of the "age spectrum," e.g. Charles-Richard Hamelin.
For the Busoni: Cao Bolai is a GREAT, consistent, and hard-working pianist, and Kausikan Rajeshkumar plays incredibly cleanly, though some people may find his tone too brittle in quality...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 20, 2015, 05:33:35 PM
I don't know any contestants, because all of them are new to me, but these are some more competitions coming up:
2015:
Hamamatsu Competition (I don't know if I spelled that right, though)
Leeds Competition
Telekom Beethoven Competition
2016:
Cleveland International Piano Competition
New Orleans Piano Competition
Queen Elisabeth Competition


Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 23, 2015, 03:55:17 AM
2015:
Liszt Competition in Weimar
2016: Grieg Competition
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on August 23, 2015, 04:49:07 AM
Did you go to Italy and see the busoni up close and personal(and if you did then I hope you had a nice trip)or did you see videos of this year performances and where could I find these videos.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on August 23, 2015, 05:44:22 PM
Did you go to Italy and see the busoni up close and personal(and if you did then I hope you had a nice trip)or did you see videos of this year performances and where could I find these videos.
No; the competition actually doesn't start until the 26th I believe :P
I knew of Cao's playing and Rajeshkumar's playing from other competitions that I had followed on the Internet (the Ettlingen and the Chopin qualifier, respectively)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on August 23, 2015, 08:03:46 PM
I'm think the preliminaries for the busoni passed and the semi final rounds are on 26th I could be wrong though and I've seen Rajeshkumar's playing and he has a good technique and tone.
Also I think we should get the Leeds competition into this discussion the Liszt competition winner Vitaly Pisarenko is gonna compete at Leeds and I think it will be interesting to see if he still has the skill to win and so is the 2014 Busoni 2nd place winner(first place wasn't awarded) Rhodolfo leone but I don't think leone will even place.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: irrational on August 24, 2015, 01:41:11 PM
The 13th UNISA International Competition in January/February 2016.

This time they are combining Jazz and Classical.
The National competition was similar. Since I enjoy both, it was interesting and enjoyable to hear them mixed.
It required a few mindshifts though!

I am looking forward to the International one. Jazz piano is certainly entertaining and can be very interesting too. Previous competitions had some really excellent pianists.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: thrstn on August 24, 2015, 04:58:06 PM
There's also the Long Thibaud Crespin in Paris, end of October, one of the top 5 competitions:
https://www.long-thibaud-crespin.org/en-gb/le-programme-piano.html (https://www.long-thibaud-crespin.org/en-gb/le-programme-piano.html)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on August 25, 2015, 12:28:30 AM
I'm think the preliminaries for the busoni passed and the semi final rounds are on 26th I could be wrong though and I've seen Rajeshkumar's playing and he has a good technique and tone.
Also I think we should get the Leeds competition into this discussion the Liszt competition winner Vitaly Pisarenko is gonna compete at Leeds and I think it will be interesting to see if he still has the skill to win and so is the 2014 Busoni 2nd place winner(first place wasn't awarded) Rhodolfo leone but I don't think leone will even place.

Hmm depends on how you define "preliminary" and "semi-finals."

I would say the huge, sweeping "elimination" (or "qualifier" to use sports terms :P) of the Busoni passed already (last year), and the 26th is going to be the "first round" with 30 competitors.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 25, 2015, 03:51:56 AM
Also, from a different aspect: junior competitions! :) (You[Schumaniac} probably already know all of these, and you may be planning to compete in them!)

2016: Gina Bachuaer Junior/Young Artist Competition
Cooper Piano Competition
San Jose Piano Competition (which is held every year anyway lol)

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on August 25, 2015, 05:26:16 AM
Also, from a different aspect: junior competitions! :) (You[Schumaniac} probably already know all of these, and you may be planning to compete in them!)

2016: Gina Bachuaer Junior/Young Artist Competition
Cooper Piano Competition
San Jose Piano Competition (which is held every year anyway lol)


Yes I saw the San jose international competition and saw the first place winner for the 15-18 division Misha Galant and he was by far my favorite
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 25, 2015, 05:32:06 PM
2016: Hong Kong Interntional Piano Competition
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 26, 2015, 08:34:26 PM
Is it just me or is the livestream of the Busoni competition a pitch/several pitches lower than it should be?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on August 29, 2015, 01:16:10 AM
And the finalists of the Busoni international piano Competition is (DRUM ROLL) wait for it...

Bolai Cao 1997(China)                           Minsoo Hong 1997(South Korea)

Luigi Carroccia 1991(Italy)                     Jong Yun Kim 1990(South Korea)

Leonardo Colafelice 1995(Italy)              Ji-Yeong Mun 1995(South Korea)

Roman Lopatynskyi 1993(Ukraine)         Mark Taratushkin 1990(Russia)

Alexander Gadjiev 1994(Italy-Slovenia   Yannick Van De Velde 1990 (Belgium)

Saskia Giordini 1985 (Italy-Holland)       Alberto Ferro 1996(Italy)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 30, 2015, 02:53:49 AM
Wow!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on August 30, 2015, 06:45:09 AM
we should all vote on who we think will win the Busoni and see who will pick the winner correctly see who has the ear of a "judge".
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on August 30, 2015, 04:23:59 PM
But to listen to all of them takes a while....
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 30, 2015, 07:33:34 PM
Competitors selectd for the 2nd stage of the Leeds:
1.Jamie Bergin
2.Jun Hwi Cho
3.Kiveli Dörken
4.Ashley Fripp
5.Giuseppe Guarerra
6.Ji-Hwan Hong
7.Jae-Weon Huh
8.Daiki Kato
9.Heejae Kim
10.Tomoki Kitamura
11.Daniel Lebhardt
12.Taek Gi Lee
13.Rodolfo Leone
14.Zhenni Li
15.Yuka Morishige
16.Alexander Panfilov
17.Joo Hyeon Park
18.Drew Petersen
19.Vitaly Pisarenko
20.Costanza Principe
21.Chang Yong Shin
22.Szuyu Su
23.Jun Sun
24.Arseny Tarasevich-Nikolaev
25.Anna Tcybuleva
26.Yun Wei
27.Jaeyeon Won
28.Yuanfan Yang
29.Masaru Yoshitake
30.Yunqing Zhou
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 30, 2015, 07:38:17 PM
The 6 Concerto (semi) Finalists of the Busoni Competition are:
Bolai Cao
Leonardo Colafelice
Roman Lopatynskyi
Minsoo Hong
Ji-Yeong Mun
Alberto Ferro

@schumaniac:
You were right about Bolai Cao! OMG And he's EIGHTEEN! Also, for the solo finals, he played LISZT DON JUAN. OH EM GEE
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on August 30, 2015, 11:56:09 PM
Honens Competition is going on right now.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 03, 2015, 04:38:49 AM
3 Busoni Finalists:

Roman Lopatynskyi
Ji-Yeong Mun
Alberto Ferro
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 04, 2015, 07:51:51 PM
The 12 Leeds Semi-finalists:

Ashley Fripp
Ji-Hwan Hong
Heejae Kim
Tomoki Kitamura
Alexander Panfilov
Drew Petersen
Vitaly Pisarenko
Szuyu Su
Jun Sun
Anna Tcybuleva
Yun Wei
Yunqing Zhou
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 04, 2015, 09:39:34 PM
The results of the Busoni (I think, it may be the opposite way around [I got this from the Italian livestream, but I don't speak Italian ;D)

1st Ji-yeong Mun
2nd Alberto Ferro
3rd Roman Lopatyinsky
4th Minsoo Hong (again ;D)
5th Bolai Cao
6th Leonardo Colafelice

They announced some other prizes, but I can't understand them 'cuz they were speaking Italian ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 04, 2015, 10:31:38 PM
"WHAT"S HAPPEING WITH COMPETITIONS THESE DAYS? Ji-yeong Mun's playing is.. is.. PLAIN, BLAND< and LIFELESS."
     -my ex at the conservatory ;D I kinda agree ;) I mean, I couldn't play that well, but there sure were competitors far better than her. I was listening live to her Round 1 live the other day, and I was like, "she'll definitely be written off". I was TERRIBLY wrong. But I guess people have different tastes, cause she won the Geneva Concours as well.

    OK, so yeah Kyle ;D, you were right, Minsoo Hong got 4th, AGAIN ;D
    Facebook followers of the Competition said that the true winner was Alberto Ferro, with his stunning Bartok concerto. Some said that Roman should've won. I find it ASTOUNDING that Colafelice only won 6th. To me, he and Alexander Gadgiev had some of the most un-plain performances in the whole competition!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on September 05, 2015, 01:17:23 AM
Also, from a different aspect: junior competitions! :) (You[Schumaniac} probably already know all of these, and you may be planning to compete in them!)

2016: Gina Bachuaer Junior/Young Artist Competition
Cooper Piano Competition
San Jose Piano Competition (which is held every year anyway lol)



Lol haven't been active on this forum actually.

I've COMPETED in the San Jose! For the sake of privacy I'm not gonna say what year or prize :p

And yes I do know these competitions and Cooper is one of my goals ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 05, 2015, 01:47:09 AM
 :)
Lol haven't been active on this forum actually.

I've COMPETED in the San Jose! For the sake of privacy I'm not gonna say what year or prize :p

And yes I do know these competitions and Cooper is one of my goals ;D

Oh, I went to the Cooper Piano Festival this year :) It was an eye-opening experience. :)
Hmm.. you must have went to San Jose recently, because your a (pre?)teen pianist  ;)

I'm planning to go to Cooper next year, but I probably am not good enough to even get in >:( Good luck to you, though!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on September 06, 2015, 07:06:23 AM
Damn George li droped out of the chopin competition that's sad he would of at least made it to the second round. :'(
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 09, 2015, 12:39:31 AM
I'm think the preliminaries for the busoni passed and the semi final rounds are on 26th I could be wrong though and I've seen Rajeshkumar's playing and he has a good technique and tone.
Also I think we should get the Leeds competition into this discussion the Liszt competition winner Vitaly Pisarenko is gonna compete at Leeds and I think it will be interesting to see if he still has the skill to win and so is the 2014 Busoni 2nd place winner(first place wasn't awarded) Rhodolfo leone but I don't think leone will even place.

The finalists of the Leeds:
Heejae Kim
Tomoki Kitamura
Drew Petersen
Vitaly Pisarenko
Anna Tcybuleva
Yun Wei

Hmm. the Busoni must relly be...? ;D JK But I agree with Emily. Ji-yeong Mun probably did not win 1st and all those prizes for a COMPLETELY musical reason ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on September 09, 2015, 05:14:14 AM
The finalists of the Leeds:
Heejae Kim
Tomoki Kitamura
Drew Petersen
Vitaly Pisarenko
Anna Tcybuleva
Yun Wei
As I suspected piserenko is gonna win by a long shot
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 10, 2015, 08:02:29 PM
Good taste? Or not good taste?

From the Leeds:

Quote
TOMOKI KITAMURA- Schumann Concerto
HEEJAE KIM- Beethoven Concerto 4
YUN WEI- Rach 3
DREW PETERSEN- Rach 1
VITALY PISARENKO- Rach 3
ANNA TCYBULEVA- Brahms 2

Not even half of the finalists (or whoever chose the concerti for them) have "good taste". Well, that's not what I think, but I'm sure TONS of people here will agree.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 11, 2015, 03:26:44 AM
The 3 Honens Finalists:
 Luca Buratto ITALY Age 22
Henry Kramer UNITED STATES Age 28
Artem Yasynskyy UKRAINE Age 27
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on September 12, 2015, 03:01:52 AM
As I suspected piserenko is gonna win by a long shot
Or Drew Peterson
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 12, 2015, 08:45:30 PM
"Competitions are for trolls."- Bela Bartok
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 12, 2015, 09:26:32 PM
"Competitions are for trolls."- Bela Bartok


Actually, it's "horses".
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 13, 2015, 01:34:49 AM

At the Leeds:

1st place: Anna Tcybuleva
2nd place: Heejae Kim
3rd: Vitaly Pisarenko
4th: Drew Peterson
5th Tomoki KItamura
6th Yun Wai
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 13, 2015, 05:15:29 PM
At the Leeds:

1st place: Anna Tcybuleva
2nd place: Heejae Kim
3rd: Vitaly Pisarenko
4th: Drew Peterson
5th Tomoki KItamura
6th Yun Wai

1st Brahms 2
2nd Beethoven 4
3rd Rach 3
4th Rach 1
5tth Schumann
6th Rach 3

***Insert Brahms joke here***
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on September 13, 2015, 09:45:26 PM
deleted
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 13, 2015, 09:46:37 PM
there are Brahms jokes?

anyway, I haven't paid much attention to the Leeds. The Leeds did bring out great piano players e.g. Perahia, Uchida, Schiff (as controversial as he may be)... But as for the Leeds winners after the 2000s or so, "where are they now??"
I. e. Clara Schumann jokes
Welcome Back! I got kypiano KICKED OUT!!!!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 13, 2015, 09:48:21 PM
Oh, did you know Brahms was not such a heavy man when he wrote his Paganni Variations? He was in his late 20s/early 30s. You can basically tell his growth rate by looking at his music.

Op. 35 Very clean music
Op. 79 Less clean
Op. 117-119 VERY HEAVY MUSIC
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on September 14, 2015, 07:40:07 PM
h
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 14, 2015, 07:42:13 PM
I've said... he seemed chill... what happened?
And you refuse to laff at my wonderful jokes. K den
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on September 14, 2015, 07:50:19 PM
deleted
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kypiano on September 15, 2015, 03:17:08 AM
I've said... he seemed chill... what happened?

He was assaulted.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on September 28, 2015, 08:49:12 PM
OMG Ji-yeong Mun changed her name to Chloe ;D I'm going to change my name to Chloe, too.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 03:07:07 PM
The next live broadcast of the Chopin Competition is at 4:50 PM.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 06:51:56 PM
Olof Hansen is AMAZING
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 03, 2015, 07:35:07 PM
Olof Hansen is AMAZING

I missed him... I need to watch him now.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 03, 2015, 08:05:20 PM
Olaf Hansen and Chi Ho Han were my favorites. Han played a virtually note perfect round. You don't see that often. Ivett Gyongyosi was the most beautiful contestant haha.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 03, 2015, 08:20:23 PM
Ivett Gyongyosi was the most beautiful contestant haha.

That witch looking person? Creepy i m o
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 08:35:07 PM
She looked like Niki Chow
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 03, 2015, 08:36:05 PM
@pencilart3 - Heck no! She's gorgeous!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 03, 2015, 09:23:11 PM
@pencilart3 - Heck no! She's gorgeous!

*they settle it over several pm's*
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 03, 2015, 09:24:24 PM
Haha we sure did..
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 09:47:31 PM
Hmmm. I thought that Chi Ho Han and Olof Hansen were pretty beautiful, too :-*

Oh, and we musnt forgot Julian ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 09:49:58 PM
It's weird how being female can make you sound so good

 I mean, if you listen to that Julian person's 2010 Competition (when he was still a man), its so much worse than the 2015 Competition (when he turned himself into a woman).

Also, I don't think ANYONE is as good as Yeoul Eum Son on the Mozart 21st- simply becahse she has that charm that you males don't have  ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 03, 2015, 09:58:13 PM
(when he turned himself into a woman).

Oh my GOODNESS do not even talk about that.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 03, 2015, 10:06:11 PM
Oh my GOODNESS do not even talk about that.

lol That was so wierd
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 03, 2015, 10:58:22 PM
lets just appreciate how awesome the chopin competition is
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: dogperson on October 03, 2015, 11:04:26 PM
Olaf Hansen and Chi Ho Han were my favorites. Han played a virtually note perfect round. You don't see that often. Ivett Gyongyosi was the most beautiful contestant haha.

AJ, is there a reason you did not care for Julian? 
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 03, 2015, 11:48:30 PM
Great playing for sure! It just didn't really stick out to me, its all subjective of course! Julian is a wonderful pianist with a lot to offer.
- AJ
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 04, 2015, 06:46:32 PM
I only started watching the competition today! What's happened?

First thoughts:
- go Cho! go Eric Lu!
- Luigi Carrocia is a bit of a wild card, but he could pass...
- the Russian sisters (forgot their name) are "nice" but paled in comparison to everyone else

by the way, @AJ and @dogperson I found both Chi Ho Han and Julian to be very "cold" and therefore not particularly appealing... :/
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 04, 2015, 06:47:30 PM
By the way, maybe we could discuss the Chopin at the other forum topic dedicated to it (by outin)... this is a much more general topic. -OP
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 07:57:33 PM
I only started watching the competition today! What's happened?

First thoughts:
- go Cho! go Eric Lu!
- Luigi Carrocia is a bit of a wild card, but he could pass...
- the Russian sisters (forgot their name) are "nice" but paled in comparison to everyone else

by the way, @AJ and @dogperson I found both Chi Ho Han and Julian to be very "cold" and therefore not particularly appealing... :/


Who's Cho? Seong-jin Cho?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 08:21:23 PM
Oh, and another upcoming competition:
IX Tchakovsky COmpetition for Young Musicians

Haochen ZHang won once, and Yeoul Eum SOn won 2nd one year.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 04, 2015, 08:55:50 PM
AJ, is there a reason you did not care for Julian? 

That posts looks like it was intended to open a new can of worms. Good thing AJ closed it. ;D

IX Tchakovsky Competition for Young Musicians

What are the ages for that? There's an I in Tchaikovsky b t w.


Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 08:58:42 PM
That posts looks like it was intended to open a new can of worms. Good thing AJ closed it. ;D

What are the ages for that? There's an I in Tchaikovsky b t w.




born on or after Dec 5 1998.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 08:59:33 PM
Here's their website:
https://tchaikovsky-competition.net/?lang=en

hehehe lelele
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 04, 2015, 09:07:07 PM
born on or after Dec 5 1998.

Cool thanks.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 09:12:30 PM
And you'd better apply soon because the application is due Oct 14.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 09:17:11 PM
Aotehr competition is the Schubert in Dortmund, 2016. Oh, and the Padarweski COmpetition in Poland.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: dogperson on October 04, 2015, 09:18:23 PM
That posts looks like it was intended to open a new can of worms. Good thing AJ closed it. ;D

What are the ages for that? There's an I in Tchaikovsky b t w.




No, the question about Julian was not intended to open up a can of worms, that's why it was directed at A.J., whom I knew would keep the response to the music, rather than to those on the forum that would take the straight-forward question in a whole different, immature, direction. .  I found Julian's performance personally inspiring, and was curious.  
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 04, 2015, 10:35:46 PM
that's why it was directed at A.J., whom I knew would keep the response to the music, rather than to those on the forum that would take the straight-forward question in a whole different, immature, direction.

That one sounded like a barb.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 04, 2015, 10:44:59 PM
That one sounded like a barb.
Yes, and uncalled for... But, I have to say, the discussion would most definitely be about his hair if it weren't specifically directed at AJ...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 04, 2015, 10:51:24 PM
Who was your favorite performer of today? Mine were Eric Lu and Kate Liu.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 04, 2015, 10:52:14 PM
Who was your favorite performer of today? Mine were Eric Lu and Kate Liu.

Yeah definitely Eric Lu. He's my favorite performer so far. I could hardly believe the coda on that ballade!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 04, 2015, 10:55:52 PM
Yeah he's amazing, his playing reminds me a bit of Zimerman, but more delicate. He'll go to the next round for sure.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 11:23:02 PM
I didn't hear Session 1, but for Session 2, my votes go for everyone I actually listened to (Qi Kong, the Marek, the Eric Lu, and the Lucas)

BTW, who are the most attractive competitors?
Mine so far are:
the Witch Lady; Chi Ho Han; Olof Hansen
Out of all the people I actually listened to.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 04, 2015, 11:27:51 PM
Ivett Gyongyosi by far. Rachel Kudo is beautiful too.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 11:29:54 PM
Ivett Gyongyosi by far. Rachel Kudo is beautiful too.
Yes, shes the witch lady. Rumor has it though, that she's average in Hungary ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 11:33:37 PM
OMG the Sendai is coming yp in 2016.

That competition requires you to play a whole opus of CHopin Etudes for the Preliminary Round ???
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 04, 2015, 11:46:32 PM
Rumor has it though, that she's average in Hungary ;D

Yeah there's no way lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 04, 2015, 11:53:35 PM
Thai peps are known for their beauty
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 12:13:06 AM
How did Aimi Kobayashi play? I didn't see her performance
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 12:27:07 AM
How did Aimi Kobayashi play? I didn't see her performance
Me neither
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 12:28:24 AM
I don't know why everyone loves her so much. She's a great pianist for sure, but I don't see what's different from her and the other pianists in the competition.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 12:39:49 AM
I don't know why everyone loves her so much. She's a great pianist for sure, but I don't see what's different from her and the other pianists in the competition.

Yeah, she's very good, but there are many pianists I like better, such as Eric Lu, George Li, and Charles Richard Hamelin, to name a few.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 12:43:04 AM
Yeah, she's very good, but there are many pianists I like better, such as Eric Lu, George Li, and Charles Richard Hamelin, to name a few.

OMG George Li improved so much from when he was 14. :P
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 12:43:40 AM
OMG George Li improved so much from when he was 14. :P

For some reason, that seems to happen quite often. ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 12:48:05 AM
Hamelin is such a beast. He just released an album on iTunes
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 12:55:26 AM
Hamelin is such a beast. He just released an album on iTunes

Once he gets into the finals, he will be THE Hamelin. Marc-Andre will only be listed as "disambiguation"  8)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 12:56:40 AM
Hahahahahaha.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 12:57:33 AM
For some reason, that seems to happen quite often. ::)
But Seong-jin Cho didn't improve nearly as much.
Seong-jin  Cho was WAY too good at age 14, he didn't have much room for improvement. George Li, on the other hand... he was just a j*ke
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: david456103 on October 05, 2015, 03:11:53 AM
my favorites so far are (in order) eric lu, julian jia/kate liu, rachel kudo/chi ho han/qi kong. hoping i can be part of this competition in 2020 haha
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 03:23:41 AM
my favorites so far are (in order) eric lu, julian jia/kate liu, rachel kudo/chi ho han/qi kong. hoping i can be part of this competition in 2020 haha

I heard you play the Ballade 4 live and it was really inspiring. Good luck in 2020!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 03:53:17 AM
BTW, the Ballade 4 is really getting ahead! Pretty soon there will be someone who plays it better than Zimmerman!!!

 Here are the Ballade 4 performances uploaded so far:


[ Invalid YouTube link ]





Which are your favorites?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: david456103 on October 05, 2015, 04:15:45 AM
@rubinsteinmad: thanks :)) jc when did u hear me play it live?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 04:20:34 AM
Hey David, both AJ Long and I are going to try to make it in 2020, maybe we could have a club or something like that. Any other piano street members preparing for 2020?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 05, 2015, 05:44:31 AM
Hey David, both AJ Long and I are going to try to make it in 2020, maybe we could have a club or something like that. Any other piano street members preparing for 2020?
2020? Man, I hope :P

I agree with most everyone here by the way: Eric Lu & Kate Liu were amazing by far. Excited for Hamelin as well...!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 01:07:54 PM
2020? Man, I hope :P

I agree with most everyone here by the way: Eric Lu & Kate Liu were amazing by far. Excited for Hamelin as well...!
If u refuse to appreciate the genius of Hansen, fine. He is like another Pogorelich. Except, Hansen's eccentricities help the music, while Pogorelich's destroy the music.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 01:09:02 PM
@rubinsteinmad: thanks :)) jc when did u hear me play it live?

Somewhere under the rainbow, before Dorothy gets picked up by the cyclone.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 01:21:39 PM
Hansen is right up my alley for sure. I love pianists like him. Reminds me of Cortot, who you all know I virtually worship haha.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 07:39:36 PM
Hansen is right up my alley for sure. I love pianists like him. Reminds me of Cortot, who you all know I virtually worship haha.

It's unhealthy to worship Cortot. Hehe lelele

But just LOOK at his hands near 0:40! They're HUGE! An octave for him is like a fifth for many people! :-[



This performance is AMAZING, by the way.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 07:43:50 PM

OMG the Belle of the Hall is amazing too! No one else I've heard makes as much sense as her for this piece! However, this is the first performance at this competition that I heard, so maybe someone else may be better/ But still, playing this Etude like Ivett is no small feat.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 07:52:45 PM
Here is Julian playing in the 2010 Competition and in the 2015 COmpetition.




I like how in the 2010 Competition, starting from 0:14, he brings up something which makes it sound like he has 3 hands! He didn't do that in the 2015 Competition, though.

In the 2015 Competition, however, it was MUCH more graceful and the technique was flawless. It was much less turbulent.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 08:03:07 PM
Ivett's performance of the etude is marvelous (and she's gorgeous so she gets extra points from me haha) But no one plays it like Eric Lu
=3h29m50s
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 08:59:58 PM
Ivett's performance of the etude is marvelous (and she's gorgeous so she gets extra points from me haha) But no one plays it like Eric Lu
=3h29m50s

Oh wow, you're right !
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 09:17:15 PM
OMG I just heard Eric Lu's Ballade 4 and it was MARVELLOUS!

BTW I'll start another "sub-thread":
What is your dream repertoire for the Chopin Competition?

Here's mine:
Stage I:
Nocturne Op. 27 #1
Etudes Op. 10 #1, Op. 25 #5
Fantasy in f minor

Stage II:
Ballade 1,2, or 4, or the Scherzo #1 or 3, or the Polonaise-Fantasie.
Any of the Waltz Choices (I like all of them)
ASGP OR Heroic Polonaise
Waltzes Op. 64
Prelude Op. 45
Nocturne Op. 27 #2

Stage III:                                                    
Preludes Op. 28  or Sonata #2 or 3
Mazurkas Op. 30  
Rondo a Mazur                                  

Stage IV: I JUST CANT DECIDE




Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 09:28:38 PM
The program I'm going to run with/prepare is

Round 1: Ballade 1, Nocturne Op.27 No.2, Etude Op.10 No.8, Etude Op.10 No.11

Round 2: Scherzo 4, Waltz Op.42, Andante Spianato and Grande Polonaise Op.22, Mazurka Op.67 No.4, Mazurka Op.68 No.4

Round 3: Piano Sonata No.3, Mazurkas Op.59, Nocturne Op.62 No.1, Impromptu Op.29

Finals: Concerto 2
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 09:55:20 PM
Nice rep AJ! I'll post mine in a few minutes...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: david456103 on October 05, 2015, 09:58:54 PM
im not sure about each round, but some pieces i will definitely include if i make it in are:
op 25 no 5
op 25 no 11
nocturne op 48 no 1
scherzo #2
ballade #4
fantaisie in f minor
heroic polonaise
andante spianato et grand polonaise
sonata #2
concerto #1
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 10:20:17 PM
im not sure about each round, but some pieces i will definitely include if i make it in are:
op 25 no 5
op 25 no 11
nocturne op 48 no 1
scherzo #2
ballade #4
fantaisie in f minor
heroic polonaise
andante spianato et grand polonaise
sonata #2
concerto #1

We are going to have VERY different programs. ;)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 10:43:08 PM
The program I'm going to run with/prepare is

Round 1: Ballade 1, Nocturne Op.27 No.2, Etude Op.10 No.8, Etude Op.10 No.11

Round 2: Scherzo 4, Waltz Op.42, Andante Spianato and Grande Polonaise Op.22, Mazurka Op.67 No.4, Mazurka Op.68 No.4

Round 3: Piano Sonata No.3, Mazurkas Op.59, Nocturne Op.62 No.1, Impromptu Op.29

Finals: Concerto 2
Great Taste!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 10:44:48 PM
im not sure about each round, but some pieces i will definitely include if i make it in are:
op 25 no 5
op 25 no 11
nocturne op 48 no 1
scherzo #2
ballade #4
fantaisie in f minor
heroic polonaise
andante spianato et grand polonaise
sonata #2
concerto #1
OMG AWESOME AWESOME TASTE
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 10:57:36 PM
We are going to have VERY different programs. ;)

OK, let's see.... You are NOT going to do Sonata #2 ;)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 05, 2015, 11:23:15 PM
OK, let's see.... You are NOT going to do Sonata #2 ;)

Correct! Here's mine...

I: Barcarolle, Etude 10/10, Etude 25/5, Nocturne 62/1
II: Ballade 1, Waltz 34/3, Polonaises Op. 26,  Nocturne 72/2, 3 Nouvelle Etudes
III: 24 Preludes, Mazurkas Op. 50, Nocturne 15/2
Final (yeah right): F minor

Not sure about stage 2 but I feel that 34/3, 72/2, and the nouvelles need some love.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 11:28:52 PM
Awesome rep Noah! The nocturne is 72 1, not 2 ;). Looking forward to seeing you there in five years and having you kick my butt!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:31:25 PM

Not sure about stage 2 but I feel that 34/3, 72/2, and the nouvelles need some love.

OMG My (not-b!tch [I. e. 1st])  teacher gave me that nocturne. I was like "No!! It's not pretty!". Now, I'm older, and I can finally appreciate its beauty.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:32:33 PM
kick my butt

The last thing we need is someone visualizing it
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:34:24 PM
Correct! Here's mine...

I: Barcarolle, Etude 10/10, Etude 25/5, Nocturne 62/1
II: Ballade 1, Waltz 34/3, Polonaises Op. 26,  Nocturne 72/2, 3 Nouvelle Etudes
III: 24 Preludes, Mazurkas Op. 50, Nocturne 15/2
Final (yeah right): F minor

Not sure about stage 2 but I feel that 34/3, 72/2, and the nouvelles need some love.

OMG Etude 25/5! AWESOME WICKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Ballade 1! AWESOME WICKED!!!!!
THE PRELUDES!!!!!!!!!! AWESOME WICKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Chopin's 2nd!!!!!!!!!!!!! AWESOME WICKED OMG THAT 2nd MOVEMENT IS BEAST!!!!!! (And so is part of the 1st movement).
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:36:30 PM
So nobody is gonna do the 4 Ballades? I mean, if you speed up your Sonata and your Mazurkas in Stage III, you might be able to fit all of them in there ;D

(just so you know, it takes 30-40 minutes to play the complete Ballades)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:38:19 PM
I think the 1st Sonata is underappreciated. Especially the slow movement and the finale.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 05, 2015, 11:41:43 PM
I'd rather be more diverse in my programming than doing all the ballades. I might do 4 in 3rd round, if i get there of course ;)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:50:14 PM
I'd rather be more diverse in my programming than doing all the ballades. I might do 4 in 3rd round, if i get there of course ;)

I know, 4 Ballades in a row is a bit boring and overwhelming. But it would be a HUGE project, and you might get extra points if you are able to make it interesting.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 05, 2015, 11:52:40 PM
The program I'm going to run with/prepare is

Round 1: Ballade 1, Nocturne Op.27 No.2, Etude Op.10 No.8, Etude Op.10 No.11

Round 2: Scherzo 4, Waltz Op.42, Andante Spianato and Grande Polonaise Op.22, Mazurka Op.67 No.4, Mazurka Op.68 No.4

Round 3: Piano Sonata No.3, Mazurkas Op.59, Nocturne Op.62 No.1, Impromptu Op.29

Finals: Concerto 2

Whenever I see "Op. 29", I think of Lowell Liebermann, or I think of the Gargoyles. WHAT IS WRONG WITH SOCEITY
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 12:09:12 AM
Awesome rep Noah! The nocturne is 72 1, not 2 ;). Looking forward to seeing you there in five years and having you kick my butt!

Sorry, yeah I meant 72/1, and I might change that seeing as I would be playing 3 nocturnes, but I don't really need to worry about that, do I? :D Nah, I'll just buy my ticket to watch AJ play the f minor concerto. ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 06, 2015, 12:12:20 AM
Dude we'll have to go to all the best cafe's in warsaw and do a bunch of fun stuff together if we go!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 12:13:59 AM
Dude we'll have to go to all the best cafe's in warsaw and do a bunch of fun stuff together if we go!

Have you 2 met in person?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 06, 2015, 12:15:10 AM
No but we're like best online piano buds because we have so much in common haha
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 12:27:19 AM
No but we're like best online piano buds because we have so much in common haha

OMG You know what? When ur in that Warsaw Café with Ivett and Pencilart3............

 (Just so you know, people's tastes change...)



BTW I just came back from doing something harder than the Prokofiev 2nd Concerto  ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 06, 2015, 12:32:26 AM
Post it in the audition room!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 12:46:07 AM
Post it in the audition room!

Actually, I'll post it here:
https://cdn.kutasoftware.com/Worksheets/Geo/1-Simplifying%20Square%20Roots.pdf (https://cdn.kutasoftware.com/Worksheets/Geo/1-Simplifying%20Square%20Roots.pdf) ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 12:47:23 AM
Dude we'll have to go to all the best cafe's in warsaw and do a bunch of fun stuff together if we go!

Yes totally! If you aren't there with Ivett instead... LOL!!!! ;D

Actually, I'll post it here:
https://cdn.kutasoftware.com/Worksheets/Geo/1-Simplifying%20Square%20Roots.pdf (https://cdn.kutasoftware.com/Worksheets/Geo/1-Simplifying%20Square%20Roots.pdf) ;D

Oh that's so difficult. NOT! Compared to my pre calc anyway.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 06, 2015, 01:02:55 AM
If u refuse to appreciate the genius of Hansen, fine. He is like another Pogorelich. Except, Hansen's eccentricities help the music, while Pogorelich's destroy the music.
Uh, I would disagree... Pogorelich was great before 2000 (haven't we been over this??). And as for Hansen, quoting my long-ass comment on his qualifier performance
Quote
I don't know what to make of his playing. It's certainly good- he has really good command of his technique and musical ideas (both of which set him apart from many of the other competitors). But his ideas come off as somewhat eccentric. They are "interesting" - dynamic changes, inner voices, etc.- but after a while the "interesting" seems to become an end to itself or over-the-top (beginning of Ballade 4- !!). Whether or not he gets in depends on what the judges think of such playing- perhaps they prefer more "conventional" performances...

In my opinion, the beginning of his Ballade 4 was waaaay overwrought. He chooses to "swell" passionately and accelerate the tempo. This seems like a "natural," "emotional" approach to the music. But it doesn't seem like one that took mature deliberation to decide and formulate...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 01:13:06 AM
Uh, I would disagree... Pogorelich was great before 2000 (haven't we been over this??). And as for Hansen, quoting my long-ass comment on his qualifier performance
In my opinion, the beginning of his Ballade 4 was waaaay overwrought. He chooses to "swell" passionately and accelerate the tempo. This seems like a "natural," "emotional" approach to the music. But it doesn't seem like one that took mature deliberation to decide and formulate...


Sometimes swelling can be a good thing. At least it's better than being a metronomic ass like my b!tch teacher.

I thought that Hansen's swelling was natural, I. e. instinct. However, I forgot what the beginning sounded like, so I'm not sure. Usually I start paying attention at the Exposition, which is where all the musicality tests start.

His swelling wasn't like Lang Lang's. Lang Lang's swelling doesn't sound like instinct, and it CERTAINLY doesn't improve the music.

As for Pogorelich, I think that his Ballade 2 performance from the Chopin Competition is really dull, and so is his Prelude Op. 28 #11. Those are the only Chopin pieces I heard him play before he became a wierdo.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 01:14:59 AM
Yes totally! If you aren't there with Ivett instead... LOL!!!! ;D
AJ would TOTALLY want to go with you instead of Ivett. ::) It's such a no-brainer ::)

Quote
Oh that's so difficult. NOT! Compared to my pre calc anyway.
>talking like a male< bruh, your pre calc is like Bartok 3. ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 06, 2015, 01:17:48 AM
Sometimes swelling can be a good thing. At least it's better than being a metronomic ass like my b!tch teacher.

I thought that Hansen's swelling was natural, I. e. instinct. However, I forgot what the beginning sounded like, so I'm not sure. Usually I start paying attention at the Exposition, which is where all the musicality tests start.

His swelling wasn't like Lang Lang's. Lang Lang's swelling doesn't sound like instinct, and it CERTAINLY doesn't improve the music.

As for Pogorelich, I think that his Ballade 2 performance from the Chopin Competition is really dull, and so is his Prelude Op. 28 #11. Those are the only Chopin pieces I heard him play before he became a wierdo.
What about his Second Sonata?? Third?
And from other composers: His Gaspard?? You should also listen to his Scarlatti :P

It's interesting what you say about "swelling" - "it can be good y'know!" But I feel it's almost always more bad than good. Maybe I'll have to listen to Hansen's playing again. (By the way, I didn't say I didn't like it- I think he's one of the most distinctive competitors in here; he'll probably advance.)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 01:21:33 AM
What about his Second Sonata?? Third?
And from other composers: His Gaspard?? You should also listen to his Scarlatti :P

It's interesting what you say about "swelling" - "it can be good y'know!" But I feel it's almost always more bad than good. Maybe I'll have to listen to Hansen's playing again. (By the way, I didn't say I didn't like it- I think he's one of the most distinctive competitors in here; he'll probably advance.)

I guess we have a different interperatian of "swelling", then. When you said "swelling", I thought you ment subtle accelerandos/ritardandos/rubatos, etc. That's what that b!tch teacher refers to as "swelling". However, now that I think about it, I guess you must have meant EXTREME accelerandos/ritards.

Yes, Ive heard the Ravel, its brilliant. However, many people are great at contemporary music, even when they suck at Chopin (hint Argerich)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 01:44:25 AM
AJ would TOTALLY want to go with you instead of Ivett. ::) It's such a no-brainer ::)

I don't know... there were a LOT of hearts on her picture on that attractive pianists thread ;)


>talking like a male< bruh, your pre calc is like Chopin Sonata 3. ::)

Exactly. Sonata 3.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 01:49:29 AM
I don't know... there were a LOT of hearts on her picture on that attractive pianists thread ;)


 
Quote
Exactly. Sonata 3.



I wrote Bartok 3, dumbass. If I wanted a Sonata in b minor, I could've wrote "Liszt's Sonata".
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: chopinlover01 on October 06, 2015, 01:54:12 AM
My ideal repertoire:
Stage I:
Nocturne Op. 48/1
Etude Op. 10/4
Etude Op. 10/2
Scherzo #3, Op. 39
Stage II:
Grande Valse Brilliante, Op. 18
Ballade #3, Op. 47
Polonaises Op. 26 (So hard to choose between this and Op. 22!)
Stage III:
Mazurkas Op. 17
Sonata #3, Op. 58
Allegro de Concert, Op. 47 as my extra piece
Stage IV:
Concerto #2, Op. 21
F minor concerto all the way.
plus the first movement of the e minor is too damn long
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 01:57:41 AM
plus the first movement of the e minor is too damn long

Amen. 1st movement of f minor is completely beast.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 02:22:54 AM
OMG, guess what I found today?


It's not nearly my favorite interpretation, but still, it's worth listening to
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 06, 2015, 02:24:11 AM

 
I wrote Bartok 3, dumbass. If I wanted a Sonata in b minor, I could've wrote "Liszt's Sonata".
I'm learning that!

Also- YouTube's partnerships with CD companies mean that a LOT of albums are available on YouTube
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 02:27:51 AM
I'm learning that!

Also- YouTube's partnerships with CD companies mean that a LOT of albums are available on YouTube
Sarcasms, Bartok 3, or Liszt Sonata?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 02:37:26 AM
Man, because of the Chopin COmeptition, Zimerman's 4th Ballade is no longer my favorite! :o :o :o :o
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 06, 2015, 02:44:44 AM
Man, because of the Chopin COmeptition, Zimerman's 4th Ballade is no longer my favorite! :o :o :o :o
whose is it now then?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 02:47:09 AM
whose is it now then?

idk but I'm listening to Zimerman right now, and I'm like "bruh theres someone better than him!" :o :o :o
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 02:53:00 AM
Man, because of the Chopin COmeptition, Zimerman's 4th Ballade is no longer my favorite! :o :o :o :o

no
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 02:54:35 AM
no

You don't believe me?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 03:01:16 AM


Not as good as Zimerman, but still worth a listen.



I like the beginning played by Dang Thai Son the best, but I think for the Exposition, he plays to much like a waltz.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 06, 2015, 03:02:27 AM
NO ONE IS BETTER THAN ZIMERMAN


except for cortot
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 03:02:46 AM
Well, Zimerman's still the best, but by 2025, I think it could be a different story ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 03:03:47 AM
No, not 2025. I had a typo. I meant 2052 ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 06, 2015, 03:05:39 AM
I think its kind of funny how I start virtually every new page haha
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: chopinlover01 on October 06, 2015, 03:58:18 AM
You're the starter of new ideas, I suppose?
In other news I just had the greatest practice session of my life. I worked on the Pathetique for about 75 minutes, then my Bach Prelude and Fugue, then relaxed with some Chopin (the Nocturne in g minor, op 37/1 if anyone cares).
The Chopin, although the really long chromatic run starting on the high "A" (so specific I know) needs some work, went amazingly well, especially the choral.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 06, 2015, 04:31:39 AM
I think its kind of funny how I start virtually every new page haha

HEY! that's my job! :D

In other news I just had the greatest practice session of my life. I worked on the Pathetique for about 75 minutes, then my Bach Prelude and Fugue, then relaxed with some Chopin (the Nocturne in g minor, op 37/1 if anyone cares).
The Chopin, although the really long chromatic run starting on the high "A" (so specific I know) needs some work, went amazingly well, especially the choral.


Cool :)

except for cortot

HOW DARE YOU!!!!

And Blechacz is second
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 10:57:00 PM
BTW, I cant find Blechacz's playing of that Ballade anywhere. It's not on YT, nor is it in his discography.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 11:12:58 PM
OMG TAMILA SALIMDJANOVA was AMAZING. In the exposition of her Ballade (I didn't like her intro), she was able to play metronomic, yet without making it sound like a waltz!

OMG I HATE THAT B!TCH TEACHER SO MUCH NOW. I WILL NOT BE JOINING YOU GUYS, PENCILART AND IVETT AND AJLONGSPIANO AND DAVID123456
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 06, 2015, 11:14:22 PM
And the sounds the Hamelin was able to make on that Yamaha were WONDERFUL
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 12:32:30 AM
Ivett <3
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 12:36:03 AM
Ivett <3

Shut up. Ur causing me:
1. To become jealous 2. Release poisonous things into my bloodstream (that's what happens when you have negative feelings) 3. have an earlier death.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 12:37:45 AM
Why are you jealous?!?!? hahahaha
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 01:25:08 AM
Why are you jealous?!?!? hahahaha
I'm jealous of Ivett, not you hahahaha


hehehe
lelelele
I'm not really da bomb
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 07, 2015, 04:48:02 AM
(https://36.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m7bjr0xDHj1rbsctpo1_500.jpg)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 12:17:04 PM
Perfect meme, Noah. haha
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 08:45:47 PM
(https://36.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m7bjr0xDHj1rbsctpo1_500.jpg)


Well, I CANT find Blechacz's interperataion. Instead of mocking me with your meme, please send me a link where I can find it. The End,
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 09:39:21 PM
IVETT MADE IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <333333333
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:41:08 PM
Ms Soo Jung Ann (South Korea)
Ms Miyako Arishima (Japan)
Mr Łukasz Piotr Byrdy (Poland)
Ms Michelle Candotti (Italy)
Mr Luigi Carroccia (Italy)
Ms Galina Chistiakova (Russia)
Mr Seong-Jin Cho (South Korea)
Ms Ivett Gyӧngyӧsi (Hungary)
Mr Chi Ho Han (South Korea)
Mr Olof Hansen (France)
Mr Zhi Chao Julian Jia (China)
Mr Aljoša Jurinić (Croatia)
Ms Su Yeon Kim (South Korea)
Ms Dinara Klinton (Ukraine)
Ms Aimi Kobayashi (Japan)
Mr Qi Kong (China)
Mr Marek Kozák (Czech Republic)
Mr Łukasz Krupiński (Poland)
Mr Krzysztof Książek (Poland)
Ms Rachel Naomi Kudo (United States)
Ms Kate Liu (United States)
Mr Eric Lu (United States)
Mr Łukasz Mikołajczyk (Poland)
Ms Alexia Mouza (Greece)
Ms Mayaka Nakagawa (Japan)
Mr Szymon Nehring (Poland)
Mr Piotr Nowak (Poland)
Ms Arisa Onoda (Japan)
Mr Georgijs Osokins (Latvia)
Mr Jinhyung Park (South Korea)
Mr Charles Richard-Hamelin (Canada)
Mr Dmitry Shishkin (Russia)
Ms Rina Sudo (Japan)
Mr Michał Szymanowski (Poland)
Mr Arseny Tarasevich-Nikolaev (Russia)
Mr Alexei Tartakovsky (United States)
Mr Alexander Ullman (United Kingdom)
Mr Chao Wang (China)
Mr Andrzej Wierciński (Poland)
Mr Zi Xu (China)
Mr Yike (Tony) Yang (Canada)
Mr Cheng Zhang (China)
Ms Annie Zhou (Canada)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:45:11 PM
Wait- Tony Yike Yang got in? :o

Oh, and that...  um.... pencilart doesn't let me talk about him/her...... he got in. But he deserved it!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 07, 2015, 09:46:02 PM
Wait- Tony Yike Yang got in? :o

Oh, and that...  um.... pencilart doesn't let me talk about him/her...... he got in. But he deserved it!

Julian did a great job.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 09:47:40 PM
Ms Soo Jung Ann (South Korea)
Ms Miyako Arishima (Japan)
Mr Łukasz Piotr Byrdy (Poland)
Ms Michelle Candotti (Italy)
Mr Luigi Carroccia (Italy)
Ms Galina Chistiakova (Russia)
Mr Seong-Jin Cho (South Korea)
Ms Ivett Gyӧngyӧsi (Hungary) <3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333
Mr Chi Ho Han (South Korea)
Mr Olof Hansen (France)
Mr Zhi Chao Julian Jia (China)
Mr Aljoša Jurinić (Croatia)
Ms Su Yeon Kim (South Korea)
Ms Dinara Klinton (Ukraine)
Ms Aimi Kobayashi (Japan)
Mr Qi Kong (China)
Mr Marek Kozák (Czech Republic)
Mr Łukasz Krupiński (Poland)
Mr Krzysztof Książek (Poland)
Ms Rachel Naomi Kudo (United States)
Ms Kate Liu (United States)
Mr Eric Lu (United States)
Mr Łukasz Mikołajczyk (Poland)
Ms Alexia Mouza (Greece)
Ms Mayaka Nakagawa (Japan)
Mr Szymon Nehring (Poland)
Mr Piotr Nowak (Poland)
Ms Arisa Onoda (Japan)
Mr Georgijs Osokins (Latvia)
Mr Jinhyung Park (South Korea)
Mr Charles Richard-Hamelin (Canada)
Mr Dmitry Shishkin (Russia)
Ms Rina Sudo (Japan)
Mr Michał Szymanowski (Poland)
Mr Arseny Tarasevich-Nikolaev (Russia)
Mr Alexei Tartakovsky (United States)
Mr Alexander Ullman (United Kingdom)
Mr Chao Wang (China)
Mr Andrzej Wierciński (Poland)
Mr Zi Xu (China)
Mr Yike (Tony) Yang (Canada)
Mr Cheng Zhang (China)
Ms Annie Zhou (Canada)

Fixed
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:48:38 PM
Fixed
Rubinsteinmad <3333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:49:26 PM
Julian did a great job.
Not as good as Zimerman.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:51:39 PM
OMG Some people online are COMPLAINING about the results, saying "all their favorite pianists were knocked out", and that the Chopin Comeptition "was a scandal, and has been since 1980". what. They must be some stupid *insert b!tch teacher's names* students who have no taste.

Oh, and by calling the Chopin Competition a scandal only makes people write you off.

All my favorite pianists got in <33333333333 (I only heard a few people though, so that doesn't count ;D )
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 09:55:45 PM
BTW, I think Yeoul Eum Son is prettier than Ivvet.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 09:56:21 PM
nope nope nope. People are mad because Tiffany Poon got cut lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 10:09:27 PM
nope nope nope. People are mad because Tiffany Poon got cut lol

Well, after hearing Hansen, Poon can't stand A CHANCE.

Besides, tomorrow most people are playing the ASGP lol lol.
BUT NOT YOUR STUPID IVETT
....
xx
 o


Julians playing... FANTASIE IMPROMPTU lol
Seong-jin Cho's playing SONATA #2. what is he going to play 2 sonatas?



Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: david456103 on October 07, 2015, 10:13:24 PM
i'm pretty pissed that tiffany poon got out, she was one of the best
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 10:15:15 PM
She had great technique but was pretty straight forward in my opinion. She's immensely talented but there are too many special players this year
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 10:21:11 PM
She had great technique but was pretty straight forward in my opinion. She's immensely talented but there are too many special players this year
ikr there are many great people

I agree, shes really straight forward and usually doesn't really spend time to enhance the music.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 10:27:12 PM
i'm pretty pissed that tiffany poon got out, she was one of the best
Psh Olof "Olaf" Hansen > Tiffany "Elsa" Poon > 1000 "Hans"> 100 "Kristoff"> 0 > Me "Ana"
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 10:28:44 PM
If you ever call her stupid again crap is gonna go down
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: chopinlover01 on October 07, 2015, 10:41:20 PM
With all due respect, you sound not menacing at all when you explicitly use the word "crap", lol.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 07, 2015, 11:07:05 PM
Exactly my point hahahaha. It was a joke pulled off quite convincingly I suppose!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 07, 2015, 11:38:51 PM
?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 11:52:47 PM
what is this??? The 2nd round got announced??? holy sh-t
yes, despite the efforts of people like you
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 07, 2015, 11:53:44 PM
yes, despite the efforts of people like you
what do you mean........
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 07, 2015, 11:55:59 PM
what do you mean........
HAnsen got in despite the efforts of people like you who imply you think Poon is better.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 08, 2015, 12:00:52 AM
HAnsen got in despite the efforts of people like you who imply you think Poon is better.
yeah I wasn't making an "effort" to keep someone from getting in -_-
I'm disappointed she didn't get in though
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 08, 2015, 12:02:41 AM
additional comment:
Ji-yeong Mun won the 2015 Busoni... and also the 2014 Geneva (it's not nearly as big as it used to be though)... how will she fare in the Chopin? :o in any case... that's pretty aggressive, trying to garner all these competition wins...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 08, 2015, 12:06:01 AM
additional comment:
Ji-yeong Mun won the 2015 Busoni... and also the 2014 Geneva (it's not nearly as big as it used to be though)... how will she fare in the Chopin? :o in any case... that's pretty aggressive, trying to garner all these competition wins...

I think she got kicked out.

I found her playing at the Busoni solo rounds (I didn't listen to the final round) even plainer than Youlan Ji's. (By far, actually).
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 08, 2015, 12:10:31 AM
I think she got kicked out.

I found her playing at the Busoni solo rounds (I didn't listen to the final round) even plainer than Youlan Ji's. (By far, actually).
Oh did she?

That's not good... of course, she has a lot to brag about on her bio already :P but losing a huge competition after winning a bunch of other ones... :/
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 08, 2015, 12:14:30 AM
Oh did she?

That's not good... of course, she has a lot to brag about on her bio already :P but losing a huge competition after winning a bunch of other ones... :/

None of those are the same as the Chopin.

For the Chopin, even ONE prize can cause an uproar that lasts for years. (I. e. Avdeeda vs Bozhanov vs Wunder vs Trifonov, Pogorelich vs Dang Thai Son, etc.)
For the Busoni, several misplaced prizes only leads to some skepticallism for a few weeks at most.

BTW, her name is Chloe now, not Ji-Yeong. Look it up on the Busoni FB page. It calls her "Chloe (Ji-yeong) Mun".
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on October 10, 2015, 03:19:40 AM
In my opinion I think That Richard Hamelin, Dmitry Shishkin, Eric Lu, Lucasz Krupinski, Zi qu will be among the finalists.

And I am still confused on how Yike Tony Yang got past stage 1 I found his playing sorta timid and stuff.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 10, 2015, 03:22:35 AM

And I am still confused on how Yike Tony Yang got past stage 1 I found his playing sorta timid and stuff.

Me too. I thought Tiffany Poon was far better.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 10, 2015, 03:29:44 AM
1. Eric Lu 2. Krzysztof Książek 3. Richard-Hamelin 4. Aimi Kobayashi
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 10, 2015, 03:38:10 AM
1. Eric Lu 2. Krzysztof Książek 3. Richard-Hamelin 4. Aimi Kobayashi

Why is Eric Lu at first? The judges aren't ready to give the prize to an American.  :'(

Besides, there are other great people, too.

i.e. Seong-jin Cho, and I didn't hear the other people, but apparently Ivett is pretty good according to PS's unofficial boss ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: evryali on October 10, 2015, 03:41:43 AM
Why is Eric Lu at first? The judges aren't ready to give the prize to an American.  :'(

Besides, there are other great people, too.

i.e. Seong-jin Cho, and I didn't hear the other people, but apparently Ivett is pretty good according to PS's unofficial boss ;D
If were doing it by country then Lucasz Krupinski already won
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 10, 2015, 03:46:30 AM
apparently Ivett is pretty good according to PS's unofficial boss ;D

*slight bias*
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 10, 2015, 05:22:40 AM
Me too. I thought Tiffany Poon was far better.
didn't hear Tony yang but Tiffany Poon was omgmgmgmgmg
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 10, 2015, 05:24:01 AM
If were doing it by country then Lucasz Krupinski already won
^

I'M SO ROOTING FOR SEONG-JIN CHO OMG and Hamelin too and Eric Lu
Aimi Kobayashi? didn't actually listen to her lol
everyone else pales in comparison

btw Rubinsteinmad
you were right about Julian sounding better "as a woman"
I feel this too in my own playing... if I play w bare arms, I feel like a better player
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 10, 2015, 05:32:31 AM
Wow I just got done listening to Cho he was FANTASTIC! I was surprised to hear a sonata in the second stage but that's all right. He play it epicly. Same with the waltz and polonaise. I wouldn't be surprised if Lu, Kobayashi, Cho, Hamelin, and Ksiazek are all in finals.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 10, 2015, 05:37:31 AM
someone can prove me wrong... but it seems as though all those who played op. 10 no. 11 Etude were eliminated from the 2nd round. (e.g. Tiffany Poon, Kausikan Rajeshkumar)... why...! And Tiffany's performance, despite being blurry, was quite beautiful.... maybe it was blurrier live?

holy sh-t though she got pretty lost in her 10-4 + the end was like  :o but the way she "recovered" was really amazing... plus her Barcarolle...

I'm not as mad now and the jury probably took a loooong time to make this decision but still, this is quite sad... I feel the same way as AJ probably would were Ivett not in the 2nd round...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 10, 2015, 05:38:46 AM
Wow I just got done listening to Cho he was FANTASTIC! I was surprised to hear a sonata in the second stage but that's all right. He play it epicly. Same with the waltz and polonaise. I wouldn't be surprised if Lu, Kobayashi, Cho, Hamelin, and Ksiazek are all in finals.
yes Cho's playing is amazing... I remember his Sonata 2 in the Rubinstein Competition... most of the other contestants were p flaky. Then I listened to his sonata, and I was like "damnnn!!!"

He is a master of playing with emotional intensity... even better than 2 years ago!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 10, 2015, 05:42:17 AM
BTW here is why I think kobayashi is excellent...



Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: theholygideons on October 10, 2015, 05:58:38 AM
Kate liu! please marry me, O' your fantasie in f minor touches me deeply.   



Jokes, she got nothing on Yuja Wang.



Although, I don't think Yuja Wang would get far in any competition. Far too unpolished, her playing is.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 10, 2015, 08:16:00 PM
yes Cho's playing is amazing... I remember his Sonata 2 in the Rubinstein Competition... most of the other contestants were p flaky. Then I listened to his sonata, and I was like "damnnn!!!"

He is a master of playing with emotional intensity... even better than 2 years ago!
OMG Ikr?

You should hear his playing at the Hammamatsu, if you haven't already. He was 15 when he won. My favorite performances of his from that competition are:
Transcendental Etude no. 10 (Liszt)
Mozart K332 (Mozart)
Scherzo #2  (Chopin)

AND HE WAS ONLY FIFTEEN!! Back then, he had the maturity and a HUGE understanding of music. He still does.  ;D'

OMG, also listen to his Dumka at the Tchaikovsky Competition. OMG
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 10, 2015, 08:23:49 PM

Although, I don't think Yuja Wang would get far in any competition. Far too unpolished, her playing is.

I think her playing was very polished at the Verbier Festival. I mean, at her Scarlatti, Scriabin, Schubert-Liszt, and Brahms Paganini Variations. However, I agree with you, she has a lot of videos of her that are not as professional as people would expect.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 10, 2015, 11:06:31 PM
hbilu
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 10, 2015, 11:34:51 PM
Oh also his Appssionata! And Schumann Des Abends!!

Riiiiiight y'all here hate Schumann's works

No, I LOVE Op. 12. (And Op. 17.)
 




Oh, and here's THIS:

Cho-Seong Jin

Starting from 16:00 is the Scherzo No. 2. He is BEAST! (Plus, he was 15.)



Starting from 26:12 is the Scherzo no. 4 (So, he did 2 Scherzos in one round!)

And afte rthat Scerzo, he does Jeux d'eau.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 11, 2015, 12:20:01 AM
DID ANYBODY SEE KATE LIU TODAY??!!!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 12:21:55 AM
DID ANYBODY SEE KATE LIU TODAY??!!!
I'm listening to her now.
Will she be the American Zimerman?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 12:28:43 AM
OMG Eric Lu's Mazurka was AMAZING
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 12:36:17 AM
I haven't heard everyone's Grande Polonaise yet, but for the ones I heard (Julian Jia, Eric Lu, Kate Liu), none of them surpass Trifonov. They all sound too serious compared to Trifonov's. Trifonov's sounds so haapy and full of life.

The Andante Spianato is a different story, though. People this year play it so well!

The pressure must be huge, because most of the people either play Op. 22 or Op. 53 :P
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 11, 2015, 12:43:59 AM
The pressure must be huge, because most of the people either play Op. 22 or Op. 53 :P

I know! What about op 26?!?!!?!?!?!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 12:46:58 AM
I know! What about op 26?!?!!?!?!?!

Op. 26 is AMAZING, too. It just isn't as catchy as Op. 22 and 53, and it takes up more time.

I guess the competitors' psychology must be like this: "I don't want to be left out by playing Op. 26, so Ill stay with the group, because then I wont have a disadvantage."

My psychology would be this: "The Op. 22 is WAAYYYY to competitive, and I'm not even good. Gotta stick with Op. 26, then!" ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 12:50:54 AM
OMG I think Dang Thai Son's Mazurka Op. 17 #4 is even better than Rafal Blechacz's!!



I'm not usually a fan of Dang Thai Son's, but this is an exception.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 11, 2015, 01:02:50 AM
OMG I think Dang Thai Son's Mazurka Op. 17 #4 is even better than Rafal Blechacz's!!

Key words are... I think
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 01:08:58 AM
 I think Fou T'song is underrated. I've no idea how this relates to upcoming competitions, but still.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: theholygideons on October 11, 2015, 02:01:10 AM
Ai ya.. kate liu, so good, give me boner! just listened to her second round performance. Sometimes I feel like she could play her fortissimos a bit louder, but then again.. Chopin never played as loud.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 02:08:01 AM
Ai ya..

WTEF Are u Chineze?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: theholygideons on October 11, 2015, 02:57:28 AM
WTEF Are u Chineze?
Haha, I eat dogs, with my cup of tea and scotch fingers.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 03:15:17 AM
Haha, I eat dogs, with my cup of tea and scotch fingers.
Actually, Chinese people don't eat dogs, but Koreans do. Just saying :P
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 11, 2015, 04:09:26 PM
Watching Chopin Competition right now.

Getting my "music critic" juices flowing:
Shishkin is playing right now; he is doing fabulously. In general, his playing is clear-cut as ever. His op. 1 Rondo was incredibly organized and sometimes dance-like. The op. 9 no. 2 that came after struck everyone as a strange choice; Argerich was apparently caught dozing off by the camera! But h he played it admirably, and the "Cat Waltz" was one of the best I'd heard; unlike the many performances of it before him, Shishkin didn't carelessly play through the grace notes, but played them as artistically as the rest of the piece. Right now he is playing the Heroic Polonaise. The only concern for him is a lack of depth in his program- especially since Hamelin, who played before him, had op. 61, op. 16 and op. 44 in one program...! Hamelin's playing today was hard to listen to though, being quite heavy in the polonaises, and in great contrast to Shishkin when it comes to everything; Shishkin is much more refreshing in comparison.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 11, 2015, 06:24:26 PM
The YouTube stream thinks I send too many comments at a time!! ugh
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 11, 2015, 06:28:05 PM
Schumaniac, your barcarolle is wonderful! Keep up the good work :)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 11, 2015, 07:18:32 PM
^ Thank you!

and
YAS
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 11, 2015, 11:44:35 PM
^ Thank you!

and
YAS

What?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 11, 2015, 11:56:07 PM
What?
Lol it's pretty awesome how classical music is everywhere in Warsaw

Why can't the rest of the world be like that??
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 12:30:55 AM
Lol it's pretty awesome how classical music is everywhere in Warsaw

Why can't the rest of the world be like that??


Because everywhere else is infested with crap such as K-Pop and C-Pop.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 12, 2015, 01:19:15 AM

Because everywhere else is infested with crap such as K-Pop and C-Pop.


that still doesn't explain it...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: swagmaster420x on October 12, 2015, 09:33:35 AM
OMG I think Dang Thai Son's Mazurka Op. 17 #4 is even better than Rafal Blechacz's!!



I'm not usually a fan of Dang Thai Son's, but this is an exception.
w t   f, this makes me think Chopin actually composed good songs
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 07:31:34 PM
w t   f, this makes me think Chopin actually composed good songs

lol ikr!

When I first heard this piece/"song", I was like, "Whoa that sounds like it should be in a movie!" 8)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: visitor on October 12, 2015, 08:07:13 PM
OMG I think Dang Thai Son's Mazurka Op. 17 #4 is even better than Rafal Blechacz's!!



I'm not usually a fan of Dang Thai Son's, but this is an exception.
attended his performances and a masterclass (sat first row right behind the pianos and his bench), he is an incredible performer and pedagogue. The insights he shared on a Chopin Ballade and the Sam Barber sonata were pretty profound and the students that study with him (i think he's artist in resi at a school in Canada) are pretty fortunate.

like i've said before, the Mazurkas are about the only Chopin solos i can stand to listen to/read through these days.  Good post.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:17:45 PM
Here are the people for Semi-final:

Mr Luigi Carroccia (Italy)
Ms Galina Chistiakova (Russia)
Mr Seong-Jin Cho (South Korea)
Mr Chi Ho Han (South Korea)
Mr Aljoša Jurinić (Croatia)
Ms Su Yeon Kim (South Korea)
Ms Dinara Klinton (Ukraine)
Ms Aimi Kobayashi (Japan)
Mr Marek Kozák (Czech Republic)
Mr Łukasz Krupiński (Poland)
Mr Krzysztof Książek (Poland)
Ms Kate Liu (United States)
Mr Eric Lu (United States)
Mr Szymon Nehring (Poland)
Mr Georgijs Osokins (Latvia)
Mr Charles Richard-Hamelin (Canada)
Mr Dmitry Shishkin (Russia)
Mr Alexei Tartakovsky (United States)
Mr Zi Xu (China)
Mr Yike (Tony) Yang (Canada)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 12, 2015, 08:22:06 PM
Ivett didnt advance my heart has been impaled...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:24:32 PM
Ivett didnt advance my heart has been impaled...

Actually, those ......? means I can't spell their names.

BTW, Ivett is amazing.

BTW, Tony Yike Yang is not amazing.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 12, 2015, 08:28:10 PM
Tony Yang was more technically consistent. Ivett's playing is special but I feel like she needs to refine her technique. If she can get her level of virtuosity to the same level as these other bombastic contestants I think she could win because she really has a lot of beautiful things in her playing, more so than most of the other contestants. Same thing with Hansen, he didn't pass because of his lack of virtuosity.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:29:10 PM
Those judges hate Chinese people. Qi Kong is WAY better than Chi Ho Han.

Those judges love South Koreans/North Koreans.

Those judges hate Scandinavians who immigrated to France. Olof Hansen is FAR > Most of the semi-finalists that were announced.

Those judges hate ..... wait....... I WONDER IF MARTHA ARGERICH IS GONNA QUIT THIS TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!! BECAUSE HANSEN IS EVEN MORE SPECIAL THAN POGORELICH!!!! (BUT IN A GOOD WAY!!!!!)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:31:21 PM
Tony Yang was more technically consistent. Ivett's playing is special but I feel like she needs to refine her technique. If she can get her level of virtuosity to the same level as these other bombastic contestants I think she could win because she really has a lot of beautiful things in her playing, more so than most of the other contestants. Same thing with Hansen, he didn't pass because of his lack of virtuosity.

Tony Yike Yang's soul was destroyed by that Juillard teacher. Now, his technique has remained (and possibly improved), but his soul is gone...................  :'(

WHY CANT JUILLARD BE GOOD AT PIANO? I MEAN, ITS VIOLIN/CELLO SECTION IS SO FREAKIN AWESOME, BUT ITS PIANO IS FUKC!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:33:41 PM
Well, at least Seong Jin Cho, Eric Lu, and Dmitri Shishkin got in. They were GREAT!

Cho Seong Jin was probably one of my favorite competitors  :-*
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:44:17 PM

Here's the list of competitors in the Quarterfinals:


1. Ms Soo Jung Ann (South Korea)
2. Ms Miyako Arishima (Japan)
3. Mr Łukasz Piotr Byrdy (Poland)
4. Ms Michelle Candotti (Italy)
5. Mr Luigi Carroccia (Italy)
6. Ms Galina Chistiakova (Russia)
7. Mr Seong-Jin Cho (South Korea)
8. Ms Ivett Gyӧngyӧsi (Hungary)
9.  Chi Ho Han (South Korea)
10. Olof Hansen (France)
11. Zhi Chao Julian Jia (China)
12. Aljoša Jurinić (Croatia)
13. Su Yeon Kim (South Korea)
14 Dinara Klinton (Ukraine)
15 Aimi Kobayashi (Japan)
16 Mr Qi Kong (China)
17 Mr Marek Kozák (Czech Republic)
18 Mr Łukasz Krupiński (Poland)
19 Mr Krzysztof Książek (Poland)
20 Ms Rachel Naomi Kudo (United States)
21 Ms Kate Liu (United States)
22 Mr Eric Lu (United States)
23 Mr Łukasz Mikołajczyk (Poland)
24 Ms Alexia Mouza (Greece)
25 Ms Mayaka Nakagawa (Japan)
26 Mr Szymon Nehring (Poland)
27Mr Piotr Nowak (Poland)
28 Ms Arisa Onoda (Japan)
29 Mr Georgijs Osokins (Latvia)
30 Mr Jinhyung Park (South Korea)
31 Mr Charles Richard-Hamelin (Canada)
32 Mr Dmitry Shishkin (Russia)
33 Ms Rina Sudo (Japan)
34 Mr Michał Szymanowski (Poland)
35 Mr Arseny Tarasevich-Nikolaev (Russia)
36 Mr Alexei Tartakovsky (United States)
37 Mr Alexander Ullman (United Kingdom)
38Mr Chao Wang (China)
39 Mr Andrzej Wierciński (Poland)
40 Mr Zi Xu (China)
41 Mr Yike (Tony) Yang (Canada)
42 Mr Cheng Zhang (China)
43 Ms Annie Zhou (Canada)


Here's the list of those who were dropped:

Ms Soo Jung Ann (South Korea)
Ms Miyako Arishima (Japan)
Mr Łukasz Piotr Byrdy (Poland)
Ms Michelle Candotti (Italy)
Ms Ivett Gyӧngyӧsi (Hungary)
Mr Olof Hansen (France)
Mr Zhi Chao Julian Jia (China)
Mr Qi Kong (China)
Ms Rachel Naomi Kudo (United States)
Mr Łukasz Mikołajczyk (Poland)
Ms Alexia Mouza (Greece)
Ms Mayaka Nakagawa (Japan)
Mr Piotr Nowak (Poland)
Ms Arisa Onoda (Japan)
Mr Jinhyung Park (South Korea)
Ms Rina Sudo (Japan)
Mr Michał Szymanowski (Poland)
Mr Arseny Tarasevich-Nikolaev (Russia)
Mr Alexander Ullman (United Kingdom)
Mr Chao Wang (China)
Mr Andrzej Wierciński (Poland)
Mr Cheng Zhang (China)
Ms Annie Zhou (Canada)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 08:46:57 PM
Seems like the judges had a good day from

Mr. Aljosa Jurinic
Ms Su Yeon Kim (South Korea)
Ms Dinara Klinton (Ukraine)
Ms Aimi Kobayashi (Japan)
Mr Marek Kozák (Czech Republic)
Mr Łukasz Krupiński (Poland)
Mr Krzysztof Książek (Poland)
Ms Kate Liu (United States)
Mr Eric Lu (United States)

They kicked out basically like 5% of the contestants that day, and probably just for the sake of kicking someone out. I mean, Kobayashi is beautiful, but can she beat Qi Kong at the piano>
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 12, 2015, 10:05:46 PM
Tony Yike Yang's soul was destroyed by that Juillard teacher. Now, his technique has remained (and possibly improved), but his soul is gone...................  :'(

WHY CANT JUILLARD BE GOOD AT PIANO? I MEAN, ITS VIOLIN/CELLO SECTION IS SO FREAKIN AWESOME, BUT ITS PIANO IS FUKC!
Stop hating on Juilliard!! Did you get rejected from their pre-college or something??
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 10:08:26 PM
Stop hating on Juilliard!! Did you get rejected from their pre-college or something??

No, I didn't even bother to apply ::)

(BTW, I had a private lesson with Kalichstein once and it cost $250 USD/hour :P )
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 12, 2015, 10:11:07 PM
Kobayashi is beautiful,

Yes she is.

but can she beat Qi Kong at the piano

Yes she can.

She just did.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 10:14:13 PM
Yes she is.

Yes she can.

She just did.

But Qi Kong was better. Don't quote me though.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 12, 2015, 10:55:03 PM
Don't quote me though.

oops
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 11:16:14 PM
oops

oops
Well, maybe Aimi is pretty good ;D But I still think that Tony Yike Yang should have been replaced by someone else. (Qi Kong? Olof Hansen?)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 12, 2015, 11:20:45 PM
Yeah aimi is really really good when she's on. She wasn't on this past stage but she still got through. Hopefully she will do her best on S3! But I HATE THAT STUPID B FLAT MINOR SONATA.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 12, 2015, 11:51:52 PM
Yeah aimi is really really good when she's on. She wasn't on this past stage but she still got through. Hopefully she will do her best on S3! But I HATE THAT STUPID B FLAT MINOR SONATA.

I like it better than the 3rd Sonata. I think the 3rd Sonata has very little musical value to it. The 4th movement is a little bit better than the rest of the Sonata, though. The 3rd Sonata has no "pretty parts". I think it is like one of Beethoven's late Sonatas, but more shallow.

The 2nd Sonata is a little bit better. I see how music critics hate the 2nd Sonata but love the 3rd, but who cares about them? There's a reason they become music critics, not musicians.
Music is for beauty. It is not for being "perfect". Music critics like perfect, they don't appreciate natural beauty as much.

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 13, 2015, 12:31:23 AM
I like it better than the 3rd Sonata. I think the 3rd Sonata has very little musical value to it. The 4th movement is a little bit better than the rest of the Sonata, though. The 3rd Sonata has no "pretty parts". I think it is like one of Beethoven's late Sonatas, but more shallow.

The 2nd Sonata is a little bit better. I see how music critics hate the 2nd Sonata but love the 3rd, but who cares about them? There's a reason they become music critics, not musicians.
Music is for beauty. It is not for being "perfect". Music critics like perfect, they don't appreciate natural beauty as much.


Bruh... you're like... 12. Sit down. How does the 3rd "have very little musical value?" It's one of the best examples of Chopin's later works; a rich, contrapuntal, yet thoroughly "Chopinesque" idiom. It comes from the period of Chopin's Barcarolle, Polonaise-Fantasie, the 4th Ballade... Personally I think both Sonatas are of great value; I've been familiar with both for a while I'd say... (especially the second, which I'd listen to on long car rides e.g. to some really good Chinese restaurant 100 miles away; those trips to restaurants and sh-t were how I got to know a lot of good pieces)

Being a music critic is also a great position. e.g. Harold C. Schonberg; look at how he portrays composers and pianists in such a lively way.

Don't make comments if you don't know what you're talking about and are bullshitting stuff ::)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 13, 2015, 12:56:26 AM
Yes she is.
Meh tbh
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 13, 2015, 01:10:22 AM
Bruh... you're like... 12. Sit down. How does the 3rd "have very little musical value?" It's one of the best examples of Chopin's later works; a rich, contrapuntal, yet thoroughly "Chopinesque" idiom. It comes from the period of Chopin's Barcarolle, Polonaise-Fantasie, the 4th Ballade... Personally I think both Sonatas are of great value; I've been familiar with both for a while I'd say... (especially the second, which I'd listen to on long car rides e.g. to some really good Chinese restaurant 100 miles away; those trips to restaurants and sh-t were how I got to know a lot of good pieces)

Being a music critic is also a great position. e.g. Harold C. Schonberg; look at how he portrays composers and pianists in such a lively way.

Don't make comments if you don't know what you're talking about and are bullshitting stuff ::)

Still, being a musician/a USEFUL music teacher is much more honorable than being a music critic, even if music critics make more money.

However, sometimes if a music critic is a professional musician himself/herself, that's fine.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 13, 2015, 01:13:18 AM
Come on, Martha Argerich! Stand up for the injustice and eat, shoot, and leave!
   
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 13, 2015, 01:14:30 AM
Still, being a musician/a USEFUL music teacher is much more honorable than being a music critic, even if music critics make more money.

However, sometimes if a music critic is a professional musician himself/herself, that's fine.

You remind me of myself when I was a 7th grader. Don't be so... judging... or "judgemental" like ohmigosh. [sips Starbucks Caramel Frappucino from a straw]

and yes Argerich should just leave the jury in disgust. But now she'd be seen as doing that for the sake of doing it.
Maybe she'll be like Pascal Roge and nicely, quietly, write a letter stating her resignation.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 13, 2015, 01:16:08 AM
You remind me of myself when I was a 7th grader. Don't be so... judging... or "judgemental" like ohmigosh. [sips Starbucks Caramel Frappucino from a straw]

and yes Argerich should just leave the jury in disgust. But now she'd be seen as doing that for the sake of doing it.
Maybe she'll be like Pascal Roge and nicely, quietly, write a letter stating her resignation.


Pascal Roge is a judge? And he resigned ALREADY? And he wrote a letter ALREADY? And got it read ALREADY???? :o
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 13, 2015, 02:50:08 AM

Pascal Roge is a judge? And he resigned ALREADY? And he wrote a letter ALREADY? And got it read ALREADY???? :o
NO HAHA in another competition omg facepalm
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 13, 2015, 10:44:56 PM
NO HAHA in another competition omg facepalm

NO HAHA in another competition omg facepalm

What competition? Queen Elisabeth?

I mean, I'm not very up to date on competitions.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 13, 2015, 10:48:45 PM
What competition? Queen Elisabeth?

I mean, I'm not very up to date on competitions.
no some random competition in Italy HAHA
but still, I read about on social media
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 13, 2015, 11:15:40 PM
no some random competition in Italy HAHA
but still, I read about on social media

Busoni?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 14, 2015, 04:24:31 AM
Busoni?
Wow you are smart

I should've written "'not Busoni"
It's this random, small competition. I don't even remember the name
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 15, 2015, 12:02:00 AM
SO who played today?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 15, 2015, 12:03:50 AM
SO who played today? I was at school all day (duh) so..

In This Order,, but Luigi broke his hand so he's going last (on October 16th.)
Kobayashi was the last to play today.

Luigi Carrocia- Claudio Monteverdi Conservatory
Galina Christakova- Moscow Conservatory 1993-2005; Incontri col Maestro Academy (current)
Seong-jin Cho- Paris Conservatory
Chi Ho Han- School of Performing Arts (Seoul);Folkwang University of Arts (Essen); Lake Como Academy; Hannover Conservatory/Hoschule(current)
Aljosa Jurinc-  Scuolo di Musica (Fresola, 2011-14); Hochschule fur Musik Franz Liszt (Weimar, current)
Su Yeon Kim- Institute for Artistically Talented Pupils (2007-10); Korea National University of the Arts; Mozarteum(Salzburg, current)
Dinara Klinton- Moscow Conservatory; Royal School of Music
Aimi Kobayashi- Curtis Institute of Music
Marek Kozak- Leo Janacek Conservatory; Prague Academy of Performinc Arts (current);
Lukasz Krupinski- Zenon Brzewski Secondary School of Music (Warsaw); Frederick Chopin University of Music (Warsaw, current)
Krzysztof Ksiazek- Bydgoszcz Music Academy
Kate Liu- Chicago Institute of Music; Curtis Institute of Music (current)
Eric Lu- New England Conservatory- Prepatory School; Curtis Institute of Music;
Szymon Nehrig- Bydgoszcz Music Academy
Georgis Osokins- Juillard School (he's a freshman)
Charles Richard-Hamelin- McGill University; Yale School of Music;
Dmitry Shishkin- Pyotr Tchaikovsky School (Chelyabinsk); Gressin School (Moscow); Moscow Conservaotry (current);
Alexei- Tartakovsky- Eleanor Sokoloff & Marcantonio Barone; Matti Raekallio(Juillard School?))Nina Lelchuk(Queen's College?); Boris Slutsky (Peabody Conservaotry) Boris Berman (Yale University?, current)
Zi Xu- Bydgoszcz School of Music;Bydgoszcz Music Academy (current);
Tony Yike Yang- Royal School in Toronto (I think?); Juillard School Pre-College(current)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 15, 2015, 12:39:07 AM
ENOUGH!!!! We've been using 3 pages exclusively for the Chopin Competition. Poor schumaniac ::)


Here's the contestants for the LISZT COMPETITION IN WEIMAR.
Heard of any?





1 Sergey Belyavskiy Russia/Russia
2 León Bernsdorf Germany/Germany
3 Gaidar Beskembirov Germany/Russia
4 Maria Bobrina Russia/Russia
5 Eka Bokuchavas Georgia/Georgia
6 Yaroslav Bykh Ukraine/Ukraine
7 Başar Can Kıvrak Turkey/Turkey
8 Albert Kuan-Yi Chen Taiwan/Taiwan
9 Shih - Wei Chen Taiwan/Taiwan
10 Jongyeol Choi Germany/South Korea
11 Gesualdo Coggi Italia/Italia
12 Imre Dani Hungary/Hungary
13 Vasco Dantas Portugal/Portugal
14 Dimitris Daskalakis Greece/Greece
15 Antoine de Grolée France/France
16 Christian De Luca Italia/Italia
17 Tanguy De Williencourt France/France
18 Ingvar Egorov Russia/Russia
19 Ernst Erlanson Sweden/Sweden
20 Kateryna Garanich Germany/Ukraine
21 Florian Glemser Germany/Germany
22 Liangxiao Guo China/China
23 Jianhong Hu China/China
24 Manami Iida France/Japan
25 Grigoris Ioannou Greece/Greece
26 Daria Ionkina Russia/Russia
27 Kana Ito France/Japan
28 Martin Ivanov Austria/Bulgaria
29 Dina Ivanova Russia/Russia
30 Aleksandr Kalinin Russia/Russia
31 Anna Kavalerova Russia/Russia
32 Sungpil Kim USA/USA
33 SooJung Kim USA/South Korea
34 Sunghyun Kim Germany/South Korea
35 Roman Kosyakov Russia/Russia
36 Daria Kovaleva Austria/Russia
37 Michael Krivoruchko Poland/Ukraine, Poland
38 Maria Kustas UK/Russia
39 Ho Yel Lee Austria/South Korea
40 Sumi Lee Germany/South Korea
41 Rudin Lengo Canada/Canada
42 Adela Liculescu Austria/Romania
43 Lifeng Liu Germany/China
44 Darío Llanos Javierre Spain/Spain
45 Yuma Matsuoka Germany/Japan
46 Michał Mędzkiewicz Poland/Poland
47 Mayuko Motoyama Japan/Japan
48 Emi Munakata Germany/Japan
49 Petro Naryshkin Germany/Ukraine, Czech Republic
50 Sugawara Nozomu Japan/Japan
51 Anna Pavlova Austria/Russia
52 Ivan Penkov Netherlands/Bulgaria
53 Valeriya Prokhorova Russia/Russia
54 Danor Quinteros Austria/Chile
55 Feng Ran China/China
56 Théo Ranganathan Poland/France
57 Dmitry Rodionov Germany/Russia
58 Arseni Sadykov Germany/Belarus
59 Tsu Tham Tommy Seah Australia/Singapur
60 Ketevan Sharumashvili Netherlands/Georgia
61 Jiuming Shen China/China
62 Raymond Shon Finland/South Korea
63 Tatiana Sidorova Switzerland/Russia
64 Albertina Eunju Song Germany/South Korea
65 Vitaly Starikov Russia/Russia
66 Alexey Sychev Austria/Russia
67 Maksim Timofeev Russia/Russia
68 Nikita Tonkonogov Switzerland/Russia
69 Alexander Trukhin Ukraine/Russia, Ukraine
70 Nicolae Vezure Germany/Romania
71 Guillaume Vincent France/France
72 Naru Wakamatsu Germany/Japan
73 Deren Wang Japan/China
74 Han Wang USA/China
75 Bocheng Wang UK/China
76 Gehui Xu Germany/China
77 Seo-Jin Yoon Germany/South Korea
   
   
   
   

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 15, 2015, 12:56:54 AM
The candidates for the Long-Thibaud-Crespin:

 

- Miss Abe Maria (Japan), 27
- Mr Cavion Pierre (France), 25
- Mr Clef Julian (India), 25
- Mr Crespeau Giancarlo (France), 30
- Miss Du Inge (Germany), 22
- Miss Fukami Madoka (Japan), 27
- Mr Gasparian Jean-Paul (France), 20
- Mr Genchev Evgeny (Bulgaria), 26
- Miss Gentet Maroussia (France), 23
- Miss Gumenyuk Ekaterina (Russia), 26
- Miss Ham Soo-Yeon (South Korea), 30
- Miss Hsieh Wei Ting (Taiwan), 19
- Miss Ishimaru Yuki (Japan), 24
- Mr Jitsukwawa Kaoru (Japan), 26
- Miss Kaihara Yukino (Japan), 23
- Miss Karpliuk Daria (Russia), 27
- Miss Kaszo Syuzanna (Hungary), 28
- Miss Katada Airi (Japan), 23
- Mr Kim Euchan Christian (South Korea), 30
- Miss Kiseleva Daria (Russia), 26
- Mr Laurent Grandpré Franck (France), 24
- Mr Lee Jin-Hyeon (South Korea), 25
- Miss Leroux Justine (France), 28
- Miss Liu Yang (China), 24
- Mr McLaurin Micah (United States), 21
- Mr Nicoletta Federico (Italia), 28
- Mr Numasawa Yoshito (Japan), 28
- Miss Okada Kana (Japan), 24
- Mr Park Joo Hyeon (South Korea), 27
- Mr Pascalucci Fiorenzo (Italia), 28
- Miss Pisareva Nadezda (Russia), 28
- Mr Ritivoiu Mihai (Rumania), 26
- Mr Saito Kazuya (Japan), 25
- Mr Sohn Jeungbeum (South Korea), 24
- Mr Tan Xiao (China), 26
- Miss Tang Shih-Yu (Taiwan), 20
- Mr Trevelyan Julian (United Kingdom), 17
- Miss Umemura Tomoyo (Japan), 27
- Miss Wang Yijia (China), 20
- Mr Won Jae Yeon (South Korea), 27
- Mr Yoon Joon (South Korea), 22


I've only heard of Micah McLaurin
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 15, 2015, 12:59:20 AM
Micah McLaurin is a wonderful pianist. Wish him the best
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 15, 2015, 01:30:19 AM
Micah McLaurin is a wonderful pianist. Wish him the best

Who gave you, sir, the rights to order me?

Tu es..... let's not even go there
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 15, 2015, 01:34:33 AM
"Aimi can't match my MUSCLE!!!!"


That's what she seems to be saying on this video's cover photo lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 15, 2015, 04:20:00 AM
Long-Thibaud and Liszt are not what they used to be.

Same with Geneva and Leeds

Liszt I know 2 people who just hover around first rounds of competitions.
Long I haven't heard of any of them. Except one person whose name is ONE LETTER AWAY from "Yujia"
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 15, 2015, 02:33:22 PM
Yeah, she's very good, but there are many pianists I like better, such as Eric Lu, George Li, and Charles Richard Hamelin, to name a few.

Oh how the tables have turned... lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 15, 2015, 02:49:32 PM
Oh how the tables have turned... lol

I still think Eric and Charles are better. What makes you think I didn't?

oh...the youtube chat. ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 16, 2015, 12:38:58 AM
I still think Eric and Charles are better. What makes you think I didn't?

oh...the youtube chat. ;D
I wasn't on the YouTube chat today...

PencilArt, you go to regular school, right?
How do you have time go on YouTube chats?!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 16, 2015, 01:10:10 AM
PencilArt, you go to regular school, right?

Yup, I go to regular school. Wait what do you mean by that?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 16, 2015, 01:10:36 AM
Me and Noah are homeschooled peeps
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 08:07:26 PM
Seong-jin Cho
Aljosa Jurinic
Aimi Kobayashi
Kate Liu
Eric Lu
Szymon Nehrig
Georges Osokins
Charles Richard-Hamelin
Dmitry Shishkin
TonyYike Yang
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 16, 2015, 08:10:22 PM
I was surprised that Ksiazek didn't make it but other than that, great results!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 16, 2015, 08:23:22 PM
Seong-jin Cho
Aljosa Jurinic
Aimi Kobayashi
Kate Liu
Eric Lu
Szymon Nehrig
Georges Osokins
Charles Richard-Hamelin
Dmitry Shishkin
TonyYike Yang
Damn
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 16, 2015, 08:36:10 PM
AIMI MADE IT!!!! YES YES YES YES <3 <3 <3
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 09:33:05 PM
I was surprised that Ksiazek didn't make it but other than that, great results!

OMG did you see the scene after they announced the results where Tony Yike Yang was basically almost crying?

OMG I have nothing againsty him anymore. Why does it have to take so much to make me like someone? I'm so evl :P

The expression was basically like, "Finally!"(As you may know, he didn't manage to get in the Semi-finals of neither the CIPC Young Artists or neither the Cliburn Junior ??? . Some of the people who beat him were clearly inferior to him, i.e. Chaeyoung Park and Youlan Ji.

Even though that probably isn't why he was crying, it would probably be the reason I'd cry if I was him.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 16, 2015, 09:40:12 PM
Yeah he seems like such a kind kid.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 16, 2015, 09:42:34 PM
NO KRZYSZTOF KSAIZEK?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 09:42:43 PM
Yeah he seems like such a kind kid.

Yeah he seems like such a kind kid.

ikr I have to listen to his playing again with less bias.

OMG how can just one kid change your feelings so much about 1 conservatory?

I no longer have "pro-Curtis anti-Juillard" feelings.


This makes me reaslize just how biased I am.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 09:44:09 PM
NO KRZYSZTOF KSAIZEK?

NO KRZYSZTOF KSAIZEK?

Dude this is a COMPETITION. Don't take 1 result so seriously. Besides he is ALREADY FROM POLAND. So he doesn't have much to lose anyways. His home is only like at most a 5 hour drive away.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 09:56:34 PM


The Finalists:


Seong-jin Cho- Paris Conservatory
Aljosa Jurinic- Scuolo di Musica(Fresola); Hoschule for Musik Franz Liszt (Weimar)
Aimi Kobayashi- Curtis
Kate Liu- Chicago Institute; Curtis
Eric Lu- New England Conservatory (Prep School); Curtis
Szymon Nehrig -Bydgoszcz Music Academy
Georges Osokins _ Juillard freshman
Charles Richard-Hamelin- McGill; Yale
Dmitry Shishkin- Tchaikovsky School (Chelyabinski); Gressin School (Moscow); Moscow Conservatory
Yang- Toronot Royal Conservatory; Juilklard Pre-College


The Ones who were Dropped:
Luigi Carrocia- Claudio Monteverdi Conservatory
Galina Christakova- Moscow Conservatory 1993-2005; Incontri col Maestro Academy (current)
Chi Ho Han- School of Performing Arts (Seoul);Folkwang University of Arts (Essen); Lake Como Academy; Hannover Conservatory/Hoschule(current)
Su Yeon Kim- Institute for Artistically Talented Pupils (2007-10); Korea National University of the Arts; Mozarteum(Salzburg, current)
Dinara Klinton- Moscow Conservatory; Royal School of Music
Marek Kozak- Leo Janacek Conservatory; Prague Academy of Performinc Arts (current);
Lukasz Krupinski- Zenon Brzewski Secondary School of Music (Warsaw); Frederick Chopin University of Music (Warsaw, current)
Krzysztof Ksiazek- Bydgoszcz Music Academy
Alexei- Tartakovsky- Eleanor Sokoloff & Marcantonio Barone; Matti Raekallio(Juillard School?))Nina Lelchuk(Queen's College?); Boris Slutsky (Peabody Conservaotry) Boris Berman (Yale University?, current)
Zi Xu- Bydgoszcz School of Music;Bydgoszcz Music Academy (current);
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 09:58:40 PM
So Now, its a Battle between Curtis, Juillard, and Charles Richard-Hamelin and Dmitri Shishkin  8)

Curtis- 3 contestants lol
Juillard- 2 contestants
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 16, 2015, 09:59:34 PM
Hamelin is at Yale lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 10:01:57 PM
Hamelin is at Yale lol

Hamelin is at Yale lol

Yeah, but he's the only one at Yale in the Grand Finals. Shishkin is the only Moscower.

BTW, Only Hamelin is doing the 2nd Concerto. So Intense lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 16, 2015, 10:04:17 PM
I just voted for Eric Lu and Seong-jin Cho for the audience prize. Too bad I'm pretty sure most people will vote for Soeng-jin Cho just cause he's Korean.

I actually think Eric Lu plays more inspring.

I liked Seong-jin Cho's Hamamatsu (age 15) perofrmances, though.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 17, 2015, 01:16:06 AM
I just voted for Eric Lu and Seong-jin Cho for the audience prize. Too bad I'm pretty sure most people will vote for Soeng-jin Cho just cause he's Korean.

I actually think Eric Lu plays more inspring.

I liked Seong-jin Cho's Hamamatsu (age 15) perofrmances, though.
Honestly, stop bringing up race when talking about competitions. I used to be like you; I brought up ethnicity and politics a lot. But thinking about it, what's in it for competitions to be like that? I regard most statements like "the jury of X competition is rigged" or "they didn't want a guy from X country to win" as bordering on conspiracy theories; you might as well also wear tinfoil hats and believe in chemtrails.

Cho plays with a unique style; his playing at 15 was great, but he is also evolving and maturing as an artist. In his playing, I hear the same attention to detail, but now I think he wants to play in a more organized and rigid way. At age 15, he was much more "emotionally driven."

Of course, maybe you think Cho has "devolved" his style the way many child prodigies (supposedly?) become average later on in life... and you wish he played the way he used to be :/
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 17, 2015, 03:22:34 AM
Honestly, stop bringing up race and sh-t when talking about competitions. I used to be like you; I brought up ethnicity and politics a lot. But thinking about it, what's in it for competitions to be like that? I regard most statements like "the jury of X competition is rigged" or "they didn't want a guy from X country to win" as bordering on conspiracy theories; you might as well also wear tinfoil hats and believe in chemtrails.

Cho plays with a unique style; his playing at 15 was great, but he is also evolving and maturing as an artist. In his playing, I hear the same attention to detail, but now I think he wants to play in a more organized and rigid way. At age 15, he was much more "emotionally driven."

Of course, maybe you think Cho has "devolved" his style the way many child prodigies (supposedly?) become average later on in life... and you wish he played the way he used to be :/

No no u misunderstand!

I was not talking about the JURY, I was talking about the PUBLIC! :D (The public will like Cho cause he's Korean and Koreans [the females] are awesome)

BTW, I don't think you should call Cho a "prodigy" at age 15. He was WAYYYYY too good to be called a prodigy. But yeah, I thought his playing was very good back then, and it still is, but I don't feel the same inspiration. :/

Not for other "prodigies" though. I think George Li sucked as a child, but now hes awesome.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 17, 2015, 03:31:28 AM
No no u misunderstand!

I was not talking about the JURY, I was talking about the PUBLIC! :D (The public will like Cho cause he's Korean and Koreans [the females] are awesome)

BTW, I don't think you should call Cho a "prodigy" at age 15. He was WAYYYYY too good to be called a prodigy. But yeah, I thought his playing was very good back then, and it still is, but I don't feel the same inspiration. :/

Not for other "prodigies" though. I think George Li sucked as a child, but now hes awesome.
yeah, that's what I was saying; I think Cho is "maturing" in terms of tastes, but it seems like you're interpreting the same thing as "losing inspiration." But everything is relative I guess.

you know who really wasn't great as a child? Eric Lu tbh.
I really thought nothing of him when he was younger i.e. in middle/high school. He played everything with so much tension during "those years," and wasn't particularly professional-sounding or anything... to me, he was just another piano playing kid on YouTube.
When he won E-piano though, I was like WHOA! Is this the same Eric Lu?

And listening to his Ettlingen performance right now from when he was 12- I'm pretty sure there were lots of technical superpower teenagers; how did he win the thing??
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 17, 2015, 03:41:18 AM
yeah, that's what I was saying; I think Cho is "maturing" in terms of tastes, but it seems like you're interpreting the same thing as "losing inspiration." But everything is relative I guess.

you know who really wasn't great as a child? Eric Lu tbh.
I really thought nothing of him when he was younger i.e. in middle/high school. He played everything with so much tension during "those years," and wasn't particularly professional-sounding or anything... to me, he was just another piano playing kid on YouTube.
When he won E-piano though, I was like WHOA! Is this the same Eric Lu?

And listening to his Ettlingen performance right now from when he was 12- I'm pretty sure there were lots of technical superpower teenagers; how did he win the thing??


lol when I heard his Haydn I was like, "meh, hes only 150% better than George Li"
(Not that I can do any better, of course)

When I heard his Chopin Concerto #1, I was amazed, but still I was FAR more amazed by Seong-jin Cho (but his recording of him playing Chopin Concerto #1 at 13 is not very inspiring either :P )


I like Cho's Sonata a lot. Its awesome. His Funeral March's D flat Major part is clearly divine.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 17, 2015, 03:49:33 AM
lol when I heard his Haydn I was like, "meh, hes only 150% better than George Li"
(Not that I can do any better, of course)

When I heard his Chopin Concerto #1, I was amazed, but still I was FAR more amazed by Seong-jin Cho (but his recording of him playing Chopin Concerto #1 at 13 is not very inspiring either :P )


I like Cho's Sonata a lot. Its awesome. His Funeral March's D flat Major part is clearly divine.
He's CLEARLY been playing the op. 35 for a long time! I like it a lot too
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 17, 2015, 03:50:14 AM
I think saying " George Li sucked as a child " is going a bit too far :P. He most certainly did not suck. He's always been a talented kid.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 17, 2015, 03:57:24 AM
He's CLEARLY been playing the op. 35 for a long time! I like it a lot too

lol
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 17, 2015, 03:58:27 AM
I think saying " George Li sucked as a child " is going a bit too far :P. He most certainly did not suck. He's always been a talented kid.

I think saying " George Li sucked as a child " is going a bit too far :P. He most certainly did not suck. He's always been a talented kid.

Go. Watch. His. Videos.

I mean, he didn't suck, but compared to what he is now, he SUCKED
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 17, 2015, 04:03:37 AM
I think saying " George Li sucked as a child " is going a bit too far :P.

If he sucked, then gosh what am I LOL ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: ajlongspiano on October 17, 2015, 04:04:00 AM
Of course! That's just common sense.... Pianists don't really devolve... And no, Cho did NOT devolve
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 17, 2015, 04:10:37 AM
Of course! That's just common sense.... Pianists don't really devolve... And no, Cho did NOT devolve
Yundi Li devolved ;D

I agree, Cho did NOT devolve, it was just rubinsteinmad who was saying that
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 28, 2015, 11:15:41 PM
If anybody cares, here are Long-Thibaud-Crespin results.

1st- n/a
2nd-Julian Trevelyan, 16 (UK)
3rd- Kaoru Jitsukawa, 26 (Japan)
4th- Joo Hyeon Park, 27 (South Korea)
5th- Madoka Fukami, 27 (Japan)
6th- Daria Kiseleva, 26 (Russia)

Special Prizes:
Concerto Prize- Julian Trevelyan, 16 (UK)
Commisioned work Prize- Kaoru Jitsukawa, 26 (Japan)
Association of Friends of the Contest Prize- Kaory Jutsikawa, 26 (Japan)
Ravel Prize- Madoka Fukami, 27 (Japan)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 30, 2015, 01:18:11 AM
damn that dude must be good! I see why they didn't give him 1st... he's so young, that's why.
Why didn't they do that with Debargue? Not award a first place, give 2nd to Debargue, tie Li and Geniusas for 3rd?? :P
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 30, 2015, 02:47:48 AM
damn that dude must be good! I see why they didn't give him 1st... he's so young, that's why.
Why didn't they do that with Debargue? Not award a first place, give 2nd to Debargue, tie Li and Geniusas for 3rd?? :P

where? Chopin COmpetition? Thciakovsky Competition?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 30, 2015, 03:47:56 AM
where? Chopin COmpetition? Thciakovsky Competition?
Tchaikovsky you dumbass
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on October 30, 2015, 04:12:50 AM
Tchaikovsky you dumbass

You didn't make that very obvious, smart donkey.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 30, 2015, 04:57:55 AM
You didn't make that very obvious, smart donkey.
Salty huh :P

Debargue = Tchaikovsky
He's like famous
Another example: if I were talking about Yundi winning X competition, would it not be obvious that I'm talking about the Chopin? You'd be waaaaay overthinking if you'd been thinking about anything else :P
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 31, 2015, 03:44:04 AM
You guys probably don't know what the Santander COmpetiion is, but its pretty presitigious. It is one of the few competitions where if you get a prize, you are automatically accepted in the Chopin Comeptition.

This year winnr are:
First Prize Juan Pérez Floristán
Second Prize David Jae-Weon Huh
Third Prize Jianing Kong
Canon Audience Prize: Juan Pérez Floristán
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 31, 2015, 03:52:04 PM
You guys probably don't know what the Santander COmpetiion is, but its pretty presitigious. It is one of the few competitions where if you get a prize, you are automatically accepted in the Chopin Comeptition.

This year winnr are:
First Prize Juan Pérez Floristán
Second Prize David Jae-Weon Huh
Third Prize Jianing Kong
Canon Audience Prize: Juan Pérez Floristán

damn; well good on them!
I didn't know this competition existed though :P NEVER MIND it's the Paloma O'Shea... I know that one... A couple of my classmates were in it, so I always thought it was "just" a junior competition. Now I know that they had huge ambitions ;D
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 31, 2015, 04:10:17 PM
Oh, and the Honens and the Clara Haskil ended in September.

The Honens gives 100,000 Canadian Dollars to the 1st prize winner.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: schumaniac on October 31, 2015, 05:16:59 PM
Oh, and the Honens and the Clara Haskil ended in September.

The Honens gives 100,000 Canadian Dollars to the 1st prize winner.
yeah, the "largest piano prize" in the world (well the largest prize EVER given was in the first [and last] Ivo Pogorelich Competition, $100,000 USD...? idk, CAD vs. USD...)

but even so, the Honens is not that popular... if I heard that a guy won the Honen's, I'd be like, "yeah, he's good, respect" but I wouldn't be crying tears of joy and shouting YASSSSSSS like I was when Cho won the Chopin competition

Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on October 31, 2015, 05:28:45 PM
yeah, the "largest piano prize" in the world (well the largest prize EVER given was in the first [and last] Ivo Pogorelich Competition, $100,000 USD...? idk, CAD vs. USD...)

but even so, the Honens is not that popular... if I heard that a guy won the Honen's, I'd be like, "yeah, he's good, respect" but I wouldn't be crying tears of joy and shouting YASSSSSSS like I was when Cho won the Chopin competition


He's Seong-jin Chopin
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 07, 2015, 06:01:12 PM

and yes Argerich should just leave the jury in disgust.

Well on this page, she looks like shes about to fling her purse at someone...

https://chopincompetition2015.com/news/2067eb4c-6556-4304-ac84-072a54ab58dc (https://chopincompetition2015.com/news/2067eb4c-6556-4304-ac84-072a54ab58dc)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 22, 2015, 01:49:41 AM
'kay, so Im listening to the Hammamatsu Competition right now.

Dario Martin's Beethoven Op. 109 is SO BEAUTIFUL  :o
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 22, 2015, 01:52:33 AM
But anyways, I LOVE the sound quality of the Hammamatsu Livestreams.

My favorite sound-quality is the Chopin Competition, with the Liszt and Hammamatsu close behind.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: outin on November 22, 2015, 06:52:25 AM
How refreshing, no etudes in the first round...and some interesting repertoire.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 22, 2015, 05:43:28 PM
How refreshing, no etudes in the first round...and some interesting repertoire.

Yeah, but I wish they allowed Clementi Sonatas.


Beethoven Sonatas are pretty enlightening, but the Haydn and Mozart Sonatas are not always very interesting...
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 23, 2015, 01:48:43 AM
Marcel Mok is amazing too.

His Haydn Sonata (especially in the 3rd movement), he brings up sounds that make it sound fuller, as if played by an orchestra. However, his nervousness in the 3rd movement made him not so flawless.

His Tombeau de Couperin was exquisite. I cant express in words how beautiful it was.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 23, 2015, 02:19:26 AM
Kato Daiki's performance was amazing as well.

The Mephisto Waltz inner sections were as exquisite as 'exquisite' can get.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 23, 2015, 02:53:57 AM
Daniel Hsu, hailinig from the USA, gave the most sincere performance of Chopin's Scherzo #3 that Ive ever heard.

Watch out, France and Russia! The USA is not far behind!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: zpianist on November 26, 2015, 06:18:38 AM
too bad I can't delete other people's quotes of my posts
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: zpianist on November 26, 2015, 06:19:56 AM
Daniel Hsu, hailinig from the USA, gave the most sincere performance of Chopin's Scherzo #3 that Ive ever heard.

Watch out, France and Russia! The USA is not far behind!

this isn't the Olympics
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: irrational on November 26, 2015, 08:30:53 AM
Aaaaah! I forgot about the Hammamatsu starting this past weekend!
I have to watch this evening!

Is the standard high this year?
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 27, 2015, 10:24:40 PM
"you're weird, sir..."

do you know where that's from?

Charlie Brown
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 27, 2015, 10:25:32 PM

Is the standard high this year?

REALLY REALLY high
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on November 28, 2015, 01:59:34 AM
'KAY, so for STAGE II:

Shen Lu makes so much sense out of the Alborada of Ravel. He manages to make it sound very tonal (unlike some other pianists).
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: irrational on December 01, 2015, 08:25:14 AM
Is anyone else absolutely struggling with the live streaming?
Even when I set down the quality to 180p its still very halting and hard to listen to. Its terrible.
Its such an interesting competition. 8(

That's even on a 10Mb bandwidth connection.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on December 06, 2015, 05:36:13 PM
Hamamatsu Results:

1st: Alexander Gadjiev
2nd: Roman Lopatynskyi
3rd (tied): Daniel Hsu
              Alexei Melkinov
              Alexia Mouza
4th/Chamber Music Prize: Florian Mitrea
Commisioned Work Prize: Igor Andreev
Diploma for Oustanding Merit: Miura Kenji
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on December 06, 2015, 05:38:47 PM
Anyways, the Telekom Beethoven COmpetition is going on
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on December 10, 2015, 08:53:37 PM
FYI, the 2nd Rounders of the Tchaikovsky Comeptition for Young Moosicians is:

Yongqiu Liu (China)
Rakhat-Bi Abdyssagin (Kazakhstan)
Ji Won Jung (Korea)
Arsenii Mun (Russia)
Anna Linkova (Russia)
Ido Zeev (Israel)
ChaeWon Kim (Korea)
Aleksandr Zakharov (Russia)
Yihsuan Chao (Taiwan)
Hyuk Lee (Korea)
Elizaveta Kliuchereva (Russia)
Su-Ah Ye (Korea)
Xuehong Chen (China)
Natasha Wu (Taiwan)
Roman Borisov (Russia)
Shuan Hern Lee (Australia)
Gleb-Iosif Romanchukevich (Russia)
 Mariia Klymenko (Ukraine)
Philipp Lynov (Russia)
Timofei Vladimirov (Russia)
Sofya Menshikova (Russia)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on December 12, 2015, 12:45:12 AM
Anyways, I'm rather disappointed by the Telekom Beethoven Competition; however, my opinion may change once I listen to the recordings.

The reason I'm disappointed is that the jury have eliminated most of the contestants that I've heard of in the past (Jianing Kong, Peter Friis Johansen, Jong Hai Park, etc.) However, perhaps I may find new pianists to listen to!

The finalists are:
 Moritz Winkelmann
Ben Cruchley
Filippo Gorini
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on January 02, 2016, 10:36:32 PM
Well actually, the Telekom Beethoven Competition, the contestants are all AMAZING!  :D
It must be very competitive.

Ben Cruchley's performance of the Paganini Variations were superb! Though contrasted from Wei Luo's stunning performance, it was equally amazing, if not better.  :o Also, he introduced me to Schumann's Op. 82, playing it better than I ever imagined Schumann could be.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: rubinsteinmad on January 02, 2016, 11:09:40 PM
BTW, Yeoul Eum Son just made 16 posts in a row on her Instagram Account
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: zpianist on January 02, 2016, 11:53:53 PM
FYI, the 2nd Rounders of the Tchaikovsky Comeptition for Young Moosicians is:

Yongqiu Liu (China)
Rakhat-Bi Abdyssagin (Kazakhstan)
Ji Won Jung (Korea)
Arsenii Mun (Russia)
Anna Linkova (Russia)
Ido Zeev (Israel)
ChaeWon Kim (Korea)
Aleksandr Zakharov (Russia)
Yihsuan Chao (Taiwan)
Hyuk Lee (Korea)
Elizaveta Kliuchereva (Russia)
Su-Ah Ye (Korea)
Xuehong Chen (China)
Natasha Wu (Taiwan)
Roman Borisov (Russia)
Shuan Hern Lee (Australia)
Gleb-Iosif Romanchukevich (Russia)
 Mariia Klymenko (Ukraine)
Philipp Lynov (Russia)
Timofei Vladimirov (Russia)
Sofya Menshikova (Russia)
Dang. I know 2 of the people in there. (Shuan is also pretty famous) Meanwhile, I'm wasting away on the Internet... edit: and Arsenii Mun is a beast

edit 2: wait shouldn't the results be out? this was from... last year.......
edit 3: yeah! they did! oh no... Arsenii......
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on January 03, 2016, 06:03:57 AM
Here's an upcoming piano competition.

MTNA AND I'M LEAVING IN 4 DAYS AHHHHHHHHHH HELP
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: kawai_cs on January 03, 2016, 07:12:35 PM
Here's an upcoming piano competition.

MTNA AND I'M LEAVING IN 4 DAYS AHHHHHHHHHH HELP

You will do great, I am sure :) It is another great opportunity to perform and make new experiences, so enjoy it!  
We will cross fingers for you.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on January 04, 2016, 02:27:47 PM
You will do great, I am sure :) It is another great opportunity to perform and make new experiences, so enjoy it!  
We will cross fingers for you.


Thanks Kawai. I sure hope so :)
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: themeandvariation on January 05, 2016, 05:37:23 AM
Good Luck Noah!  I'm rooting got you!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: pencilart3 on January 05, 2016, 05:52:43 AM
Good Luck Noah!  I'm rooting got you!

Why Theme! It's great to "see" you :) thank you so much!!!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: irrational on January 26, 2016, 03:16:42 PM
UNISA international piano competition started yesterday in South Africa with an opening concert I did not attend.
Off to the 1st round Jazz piano tonight (Classical starts tomorrow). It should prove quite entertaining.
I don't think they stream for watching though.

A lot of Russian/Korean pianists in classical this year. I am hoping for fascinating repertoires!
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: irrational on February 08, 2016, 12:43:38 PM
Well it was an interesting compeition.
My views:

Classical suffered a bit from adding Jazz in the sense that I feel the competition was significantly easier than before. There is no more Mozart Concerto round for instance, which I think is very demanding round.

The pianists, being restricted to 13 Jazz and 13 Classical, meant less variety of players (although it was easier to watch with fewer repetitions of works). Also, there were far fewer spectators than the past. Bad advertising? Or uncertainty about the mixed styles?

Jazz was interesting and most enjoyable. But its always such a huge "brain switch" from Jazz to classical. That said, this time around the Classical player's technique was clearly far harder, more interesting and spectacular than the Jazz. Its not often you can do such a clear comparison.

The pianists:
The classical winner, Daniel Ciobanu was very interesting to watch! He has great technique and colours, although I felt sometimes speed overtook musicality. He's certainly superbly capable. I am looking forward to some winners recitals. His final Paganini Variations were riveting from start to finish. I am also glad I got to see Silvestri's Bacanale. Different, but very virtuoso piece.

I also enjoyed Kana Ito's playing. She was my favourite for a while. Her Totentanz was spectacular. I was a bit disappointed she did not make the finals. Perhaps her Haydn was not as good as it should have been. I thought few players got the classical sonatas right. Except the Korean Seomseung Lee, who made Haydn actually sound like Haydn.

Philipp Scheucher also played very well although I felt I missed a little fire.

For the Jazz, Addison Frei was most entertaining and a deserving winner, but I really enjoyed Sebastiaan van Bavel as well. He had a very intense improvisation session in the finals that were a pleasure to watch.

I can't help hoping that they will expand the competition a little and raise the standard again. After all, the first winner of the competition was Marc-Andre Hamelin and there were other very famous pianists in the past. I would hate to lose the possible participation of the world's top players.
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: tinyking12345 on February 24, 2016, 11:31:49 AM
Competitors for the Junior and Young Artists Gina Bachauer piano competition announced...
It will Take place in Salt Lake City in June

https://www.bachauer.com/announcements/2016-official-competitors.html

some of the prize winners in previous years are:
Aimi Kobayashi
Lukas Geniusas
Yundi li
Tony Yike Yang
George Li
etc
Title: Re: Upcoming Piano Competitions- and discussion
Post by: andreslr6 on March 11, 2016, 09:40:47 AM
Competitors for the Junior and Young Artists Gina Bachauer piano competition announced...
It will Take place in Salt Lake City in June

https://www.bachauer.com/announcements/2016-official-competitors.html

some of the prize winners in previous years are:
Aimi Kobayashi
Lukas Geniusas
Yundi li
Tony Yike Yang
George Li
etc

I'm waiting for the International category! hopefully I can make it.

Also, is anyone here going to the "Rosario Marciano" Piano Competition? it takes place in August in Viena pianists.at