Piano Forum

Piano Board => Repertoire => Topic started by: robatsch on August 05, 2015, 12:45:44 AM

Title: Which do you prefer?
Post by: robatsch on August 05, 2015, 12:45:44 AM

What, in your opinion, is the greater work and which do you enjoy listening to more- Liszt's Sonata in B minor or Schumann's Fantasy in C Major?

Title: Re: Which do you prefer?
Post by: josh93248 on August 05, 2015, 05:15:19 AM

Damn that's a hard question.

I'd say the Liszt is deeper and more profound but the Schubert is more fun and invigorating.

I have listened to the Schubert more but have more respect for the Liszt.

I can't really say, but that's my assessment of the pieces.

Title: Re: Which do you prefer?
Post by: chopinlover01 on August 06, 2015, 04:26:47 AM

He was referring to Schumann's Fantasy, which IMO compared to the sonata falls quite short. I don't hate it like many people here do (visitor, Thal, etc), but the Liszt sonata (which really isn't a sonata, just a theme cleverly stretched over half an hour) is of far more musical depth.

Title: Re: Which do you prefer?
Post by: ganymedger on August 06, 2015, 06:59:37 AM

I prefer Schumanns fantasy to the Liszt Sonata , which I dont like at all.

Title: Re: Which do you prefer?
Post by: josh93248 on August 06, 2015, 10:39:43 AM

Oops, my bad, all I saw was C Major Fantasy and a "Schu" So I assumed. Doh.

Anyway, in that case I'll go with the Liszt. I still like the Schumann though (don't hate me Thal)

Title: Re: Which do you prefer?
Post by: ewalker1 on August 06, 2015, 12:02:22 PM

I play the Liszt sonata and I know the Schumann Fantasie quite well.
Both great pieces and are highly contrasting, both present their individual difficulties.
Overall I'd say I prefer the Liszt sonata...probably because I know it much better