Piano Forum
Piano Board => Repertoire => Topic started by: adariation on October 25, 2022, 03:17:59 PM
-
I am planning on doing a competition
and need a concerto a for the grand final.
I have played many concertos with orchestra; Rach 2, Chopin 1, Tchaikovsky, Beethoven 3,4, 5.
This is an all-instruments concerto so I'd need to stand out in the grand final.
The previous piano winners played the following: Rach 2, Rach Paganini, and Saint Saens 2.
Even though the technique concerning most piano concertos isnt an issue, I want something that isn't overplayed. That's why I was going to perform Beethoven 3. Would this be seen as too easy?
-
Considering Beethoven 3 is standard concert rep, and many international competitions are won at least partially using it (Yuncham Lim just played it for the Cliburn for instance), then I think you're fine.
-
Why not Rach 3? Perfect virtuosity and expression for both pianist and orchestra
-
Rach 3 is too hard. I am only age of 14, will never be able to pull it off by the time i am 16.
+ I believe Yunchan Lim won that competition because of his beautiful Rach 3 and transcendental etudes, rather than Beethoven 3
What about performing Tchaikovsky, Scriabin or Ravel?
-
Rach 3 is too hard. I am only age of 14, will never be able to pull it off by the time i am 16.
+ I believe Yunchan Lim won that competition because of his beautiful Rach 3 and transcendental etudes, rather than Beethoven 3
What about performing Tchaikovsky, Scriabin or Ravel?
Even if his etudes and Rach 3 were the stars, the Beethoven was still a part of the final round and I think that's not something to forget.
The last international Chopin competition also began with a performance of Beethoven 3 by the previous winner (if I remember correctly).
-
That is quite true, Bruce Liu did play Beethoven 3, however they all played a major concerto alongside it,
which was what i think led them to win
-
Isn't it better to find a show case work that can show the candidate's best, instead of worrying too much on his/her choice being over played?
-
Very true, but one must consider that all past keyboard winners have played Rach 2.
I really like beethoven 3, however do not think that it is hard enough.