Posthumous vs Original Chopin nocturne

[eyeballnick]

Is it me or do you think the post. chopin nocturnes are overplayed? and not as good as the original Nocturnes ?

[hyrst]

I love  the post-humous ones, especailly C# minor when played well.  However, the reason Chopin did not allow them to be published was his own dissatisfaction with them. 

Perhaps a certain matter of taste. 

We can get tired of hearing the same thing too much, very quickly when not played well, and over time even if soemthing is brilliant. 

[eyeballnick]

I love  the post-humous ones, especailly C# minor when played well.  However, the reason Chopin did not allow them to be published was his own dissatisfaction with them. 

Perhaps a certain matter of taste. 

We can get tired of hearing the same thing too much, very quickly when not played well, and over time even if soemthing is brilliant. 

Yes i agree fully, its not that the posthumous ones are not "as good" but i definatly think, especially since the film the pianist came out, that i have heard the C# minor and Eminor Nocturnes so much, becomes tiresome! Even though they are beautiful peices. I wonder why Chopin wasnt happy with them?