out of curiosity, how long have you been playing, and do you know any other Chopin etudes?
Keep practising and dont hurry, you'll be able to play it faster and faster It is good that you play it at a speed at wich you hardly make any mistakes, playing it too fast will screw the piece up.good luck,gyzzzmo
You're welcome. Just out of curiosity, how long have you been playing, and do you know any other Chopin etudes? I just got my Cortot-editions of the etudes (got carried away when ordering the preludes, lol), and it is soo tempting to try one out. I will, however, wait a little longer. The day I can play just one of these, I will be a happy man. I'm looking forward to your updates, good luck!
Thanks for the guide gyzzzmo! This forum surely contains lots of wisdom. Anyway, I gave the two first measures a shot. I can't understand how anyone can play this at 176 bpm, which is the metronome-mark at the start of my score. I guess I have some more practising to do. I'm uploading this only to show that I'm a man of my word, I do not intend to hijack your tread violinist!
Those are excellent principles! I liked your point 13, this piece is really tiring the hand. And yes, as my technique is so far away from this piece, I must use all the tricks I can think of while learning this. I seem to have some trouble executing the descending arpeggios. My thumb gets stiff and in the way, sort of. I hope your next video captures your hands!
After watching your second video, I agree, exercise 1 probably isn't going to help you much! Maybe you won't need any of them, but I can still post the rest if you'd like. Wow, that was really good. Are you practising with a metronome? That had to be like 130 bpm+Watching your hands was really useful, your technique makes this look so effortless, I tensed up like crazy playing those 2 measures. Seems like this etude is not about stretching the thumb and pinky, but rather about moving the entire arm. Your technique seems to be more composed and on a level above mine, how much did you struggle with this in the start? Maybe I'll just learn four more measures and do a video myself. Again, excellent job, this is really inspiring me!
UPDATE (MARCH 1, 2008)I included a video that now shows my hands (I suspended the camera on my violin music stand). And now I can play it a bit faster and the end isn't as messed up.(this is try #2 of Chopin Etude Op. 10, No. 1 recorded 10pm March 1, 2008). Comments?
What an improvement!!!Your playing is very relaxed and natural. Sometimes (only sometimes!) the highest note of the arpeggio is a bit too direct (too loud, too strict in time) for my taste. Perhaps you heard Pollini, who does this to the extreme
About the metronome speed, I calculated your bpm average to be 119. You did deaccelerate a little bit, so the start is at least really close to 130 bpm! Thank you for writing those details on arm motion, they proved useful this morning. Then I tried the same thing I did on my first session, setting the metronome to 180 and playing the whole broken chord. Believe it or not, i actually managed to play ECGce at 180 bpm! It was akward and tense, yes, but it was still a fourth of a measure of this piece 'above' final tempo! I could not link two of those together. However, this has made me realize two things:1) I am physically cabable of playing this.2) When I learn to relax and integrate all the needed motions, I will be able to play it too.Of course, point #2 is really what playing the piano is all about. Tomorrow I will try two more measures!
I left my recorder on while practising this morning, so here's a couple more attempts at the first two measures!