Opinions on Chopin op 25 n 6

[Souza]

What  sounds better in bar-42 Studie op. 25 n.6 - Chopin? #F ou #G ?


Some urtext editions have the  #G/#D...instead #F/#D as in majority editions.

             8a----- 

              _#♪_
              ____
________#♪___
_____________
_____________
_____________
_____________



Also in bars 7 and 8,  the majority  editions has in right hand's thirds an #A ...some others editions as Cortot, has an natural A. 

Pianists plays in both forms, but I guess predominates as in Cortot's.

Any opinion?  What sounds better?

Best Regards

Pedro

[allchopin]

I have always played F#, so to me it sounds more correct.  However, my theory is telling me it should probably be a G# because the left hand chord is B#, D#, implied G#, and A natural (just a 9-8 suspension).  This would make the chord a V9 of the current tonicization of c#-.  Can someone back me up on this?

I also play the A# - I have equal numbers of recordings of both ways.