Piano Forum

Pages: [1] Go Down

Topic: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ? (Read 5288 times)

m19834

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1627

JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ?

on: September 11, 2008, 02:59:31 PM

I am looking at measure 18 of the fugue in the alto voice, first note of that measure, E(b). This is the fourth note of a subject re-entry (the previous measure beginning it). I have been entering this fugue into a four part notation so I can isolate the voices better, and as I was listening to just this voice on the Sibelius playback, my ear wanted for that Eb to be an E-natural. I looked at the score I am using and it did not read E natural, so I looked into another edition of the music that I have here : "Kalmus" and in that edition there is a footnote indicating that in the "Gerber" edition, that note is in fact an E natural, not an Eb. So, I looked on the remaining PS editions, all of which also have an Eb. My ear badly wants an E natural and apparently in some other edition that I don't have, it is an E natural and not a flat.

Does anybody happen to have any information on this ?

Thanks

Logged

Petter

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1183

Re: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ?

Reply #1 on: September 11, 2008, 03:01:33 PM

You could play both just to make sure.

Logged

"A gentleman is someone who knows how to play an accordion, but doesn't." - Al Cohn

m19834

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1627

Re: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ?

Reply #2 on: September 11, 2008, 03:03:53 PM

haha ... well, somehow I don't think that would be any better

. I am tempted to just go with the E natural that my ear wants

...

Logged

pianogeek_cz

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 448

Re: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ?

Reply #3 on: September 11, 2008, 05:10:43 PM

No no no, on the last beat, resp. eighth of bar 17, there's B flat major 7th chord that needs resolution at beat 1 of bar 18. Which is an E flat major 6th chord. Plus, you'll be getting the right cadence from beat 4 of bar 17 to beat 3 of bar 18: beat by beat - tonic (B flat major), subdominant (E flat major), dominant (F major), tonic again with the high B on bar 3 wrapping it up nicely. There's no place for C major in there.

But, first of all, the resolution of the Bb7 has to be there. (At least in a baroque fugue like that. Well, maybe in a sequence you could do it. But that's not the case here.)

Logged

Be'ein Tachbulot Yipol Am Veteshua Berov Yoetz (Without cunning a nation shall fall, Salvation Come By Many Good Counsels)

m19834

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1627

Re: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ?

Reply #4 on: October 21, 2008, 09:48:08 PM

Quote from: pianogeek_cz on September 11, 2008, 05:10:43 PM

No no no, on the last beat, resp. eighth of bar 17, there's B flat major 7th chord that needs resolution at beat 1 of bar 18. Which is an E flat major 6th chord. Plus, you'll be getting the right cadence from beat 4 of bar 17 to beat 3 of bar 18: beat by beat - tonic (B flat major), subdominant (E flat major), dominant (F major), tonic again with the high B on bar 3 wrapping it up nicely. There's no place for C major in there.
But, first of all, the resolution of the Bb7 has to be there. (At least in a baroque fugue like that. Well, maybe in a sequence you could do it. But that's not the case here.)

Sorry to bump this thread, but I wanted to thank you for your response. Very helpful

. I guess it's important to remember to consider the whole harmonic picture and not just the individual voice parts !

Logged

Sign-up to post reply

Pages: [1] Go Up

For more information about this topic, click search below!

Piano Street Magazine:
The Complete Piano Works of 16 Composers

Piano Street’s digital sheet music library is constantly growing. With the additions made during the past months, we now offer the complete solo piano works by sixteen of the most famous Classical, Romantic and Impressionist composers in the web’s most pianist friendly user interface. Read more

Piano Forum

Topic: JS Bach, Prelude and Fugue in g minor, WTC bk I -- note question ? (Read 5288 times)

Piano Street Magazine:The Complete Piano Works of 16 Composers

Piano Street Magazine:
The Complete Piano Works of 16 Composers