1st Scherzo

[thesuineg]

Recommend you're favorite recordings of Chopin's 1st Scherzo. Possibly a link accessable in china (no youtube ):  )   
thanks..

[p2u_]

This is not the right section of the forum for this kind of requests!
Still, I hope this one works for you in China:
Sviatoslav Richter Plays Chopin Scherzo No. 1 In B Minor.

Paul

[thesuineg]

o.0 sorry, how do you move then?
also it didn't work :/
china sux

[p2u_]

o.0 sorry, how do you move then?

I'm afraid I don't understand your question. Do a search for Sviatoslav Richter with the Scherzo No 1 through the Chinese search engines. Good luck!

Paul

[the89thkey]

I have a bunch of good versions (Richter is not one of them) but I don't know if they are available without purchasing MP3's or using Youtube.

[j_menz]

I have a bunch of good versions (Richter is not one of them) but I don't know if they are available without purchasing MP3's or using Youtube.

**** wonders if that is the least useful answer ever 

Perhaps you could at least mention who they are by?

[the89thkey]

**** wonders if that is the least useful answer ever 

Perhaps you could at least mention who they are by?

Probably wasn't very useful, my apologies. The best ones are by Rubinstein and Horowitz.

[thesuineg]

I have both of those. I don't like horowitzes too much. its super sudden and exaggerated for a piece thats already rather exaggerated in terms of volume often.
ill keep listening to rubinsteins then..

[the89thkey]

I have both of those. I don't like horowitzes too much. its super sudden and exaggerated for a piece thats already rather exaggerated in terms of volume often.
ill keep listening to rubinsteins then..

Horowitz's doesn't seem exaggerated to me, but everyone is entitled to their own opinion...