I wouldn't mind paying for a tuning in exchange for getting to play on the piano a couple times...I am moving away anyways, so it's not like I am trying to practice on it every day or even every weekend! The pastor could have been nice and responded to me! Can you see what I am getting at? I was treated like crap! I am not an kid and I know how to treat a piano. I'm not gonna vandalize it or scratch it, even!
But I got permission before! They told me they were going to lock it because they keep the church open. No one complained. I even had a mini concert where people applauded me! Today the same person who gave me permission let me stay and play for the last time. He said I need to have a note from the pastor from now on. I don't want him or anyone else to get in trouble. So, I am gonna leave the piano alone. It's too bad. It wants to be played! Oh well.
I'm not welcome there! How could I even be a member of a church? They look at me as some kind of convict or something! Besides, I am Christian, not Catholic. Hey, maybe that's why!
So true! I definitely cannot change their mind! I'll never even have the chance to. Oh well. Bye, yamaha! I loved you...
My two cents: It's their piano, they get to choose who gets to play it. I take it you aren't a member of that church, and they aren't in the business of being a music practice room. Get over it.
I hope your piano breaks!
It doesn't respond to hope I'm afraid.As for travelling musicians, wandering minstrels and other assorted potential piano needers - do you let them in to play yours?
I'm just saying. You can see I was already upset. Telling someone to go and get over it is insensitive and plain rude. And it doesn't help my discussion.
You live in big Australia. I live in the country, in Texas. Big difference there, I'm afraid.
I didn't want to lose the resourse of a nice piano in town. You know? Like it was said earlier, some people even get to go and record at churches! But I do not have that available to me. If you do, jmenz, I doubt Texas is more crowded than where you are at.
My two cents: It's their piano, they get to choose who gets to play it. I take it you aren't a member of that church, and they aren't in the business of being a music practice room. Get over it.Quote from: chopin2015 on May 06, 2013, 02:44:06 AMI hope your piano breaks!
I don't do sympathy, I'm afraid.
No offense Chopin2015... but that was *** rude. From what you describe - it isn't your piano, and the church has no obligation to just let anyone touch it. Granted yes, you were able to play on it in the past, but I'm pretty sure you have a piano at home that you practice on? I saw your Chopin Ballade video posted a couple of weeks back. If you're getting bitchy because you didn't get to play on THEIR Grand piano,then I'm sorry but that's your fault. J_Menz was simply summarising the facts, most of which you already stated - your response to the summation of those facts was just rude... and childish.
I am very sorry I said that about his piano.
@jmenzYes, it is not a town resource. The church is a community, though. A small one. I do a lot of work in that town, for pleasure. I still have much patience in finding something I can be a part of, elsewhere. That is why I do not wish to bother the pastor any longer. But just fyi, I was the only person other than Bill and 1 more adult, who played that piano. They didn't say no, but they wanted me to get a written note from now on, which is impossible because the pastor does not wish to talk to me. Also because yes, they are within their rights to ask me to do so, no matter how ridiculous that may be!
I guess I shouldn't have played mephisto valse there, then...
Don't sweat it. It's had far worse threats. Mostly from me when it doesn't behave.I'm not defending their actions, but some churches are funny things. Accept it and move on. Ultimately, their lack of christian spirit is more their problem than yours.Hahahaha. Ya think?
It's a pretty piece though, and the story ends with Faust doing the right thing by making the ultimate decision, remember?
But you know what, you know who you are and YOU'RE NO DIFFERENT THAN THAT COLD PASTOR. So, I don't have to deal with you.
Indeed. Though I suspect the Pastor hasn't read any Goethe and may just go by the name. It was written just before Liszt took minor orders in the Catholic church - and the other three were written well after that, so I doubt the intention was in any way blasphemous.
You know what - Grow the *** UP!!! I'm not the one who denied you access to the piano, so how about you stop behaving like a spoilt little brat and get over it. I responded simply because I've seen plenty of forum users treat this forum like some gab-fest to pregnant dog about whatever trivial crap they feel like. You probably don't know J_Menz either, and his response didn't seem that cold. It was simply a summation of what was already stated. To respond with something like 'I hope your piano breaks' is pathetic at best, and as I said - childish. I'm not the bloody Pastor - it's them you have a problem with, so how about you stop bitching about it on these forums and talk to the Pastor - like an ADULT!!! I'm not the pastor, I'm not even close - and considering you don't know a DAMN THING about me, you don't have the right to state that I'm 'no different from the pastor'. Your right - you don't have to deal with me, yet you felt so eager to respond??? GROW UP!!!
Come on, this has nothing to do with "church people" in general. I talked to the organ player in charge at our church and she was fine with the idea that I come and use their piano - not a good one, but I think I want to play on an acoustic from time to time - when it is convenient.So, you happened to encounter one person who was not that cooperative. It is a personal thing. It has nothing to do with the church concept, or with religion. Please don't generalize. Bad luck, but nothing to do about it, as it is not your piano. Period.
A@jmenz They didn't say no, but they wanted me to get a written note from now on, which is impossible because the pastor does not wish to talk to me. @outin I carry god with me everywhere I go.
Will go update my post right now. Thanks! I definitely would be wrong to think and say all church people are. I have said earlier, I've had friendly arrangements...infact to mellow down the extreme stance, I want to say some of the best people I've had the pleasure of meeting were pastors and people from a church community.
They certainly do have every right to create any rules they wish, even if they do think I am a good pianist and a nice enough person. I am most concerned with how the pastor looks at me. She didn't have to write an email to respond. She could have set up a meeting where we could have met face to face and all that. I suspect it's the type of music I play, as well. It is dramatic. Stuff like ballade no 1, winter wind etude, mephisto valse, etc. Romantic/dramatic music. Does anyone think that the mood of those pieces is almost like listening to slayer in a church?