[...]So, it is always a good idea to find some piece that is worthwhile musically, and learn it before. This will allow you to acquire the technique necessary to tackle the more difficult piece and at the same time add – in usually a short time – a new piece to your repertory.So here are some options. Don’t feel that you have to learn all of these before embarking on Reverie. I am giving you choices since I don’t know your tastes or your actual difficulties. They are specific to each of the 8 difficulties above, and I have divide in five levels: level 1 a complete beginner can tackle. Level 5 is just below Reverie itself. [...]
Level 2: [/b]Scarlatti – “Sonata k382”
I could not listen more than 30 seconds to that freight-train race. How about this:In any case, what you wrote is beside the point.
I have played this piece and my point was that it is quite difficult to be called level 2 and reduce it into an arpeggio study.
. He also did not call the piece level 2 (whatever levels might mean) ...
He did exactly that and he also somehow explained what he means with levels, level one being easy enough that a "complete beginner can tackle". He posted his list as advice to a poster here, not as an explanation of his teaching strategy.
Since we cannot ask Bernhard how he used this list or adapted any of the repertoire, it would be almost impossible for a self learner to use this with any success
It is under the title "Facility to play arpeggios in the left hand". And it is linked to his teaching - how can it be otherwise? What bothers me is your quick judgment, and assumption that you know exactly what he meant (and judgment on the same). Again, it is also linked to what and how he teaches it, and it may not be at all how you approached or played it as a student. I think that a teacher would say "Can you tell me more?" rather than coming up instantly with judgments.
You don't need to, Bernhard has outlined his teaching methods in multiple posts; you're going to have to sniff out his post history for it. What Keypeg has said is pretty much on point.(and it works).
It seems to me you jumped into conclusions about "quick judgement" yourself.
This is not even the first time the difficulty of this sonata has come up.
Why you feel the need to jump into his defense without actual experience on that piece is beyond me.
If the aim is to play this piece decently and in a way that it was intended by the composer IM (somewhat educated)O it's in the wrong slot, that's all.
please look at the repertoire listed, can you honestly tell me that all of these are easier than Debussy Reverie? That is the hypothesis
Uh, yes? That includes the scarlatti too. Don't get what the big deal is, everything in that list is completely accessible to a beginner and they're totally capable of playing it decently.
That was amusing, lol
I did not conclude quick judgment. I observed it.Except that it is not about the difficulty of the sonata. It is about using the sonata for a particular skill.I did not "jump in". I posted. And it was not in defense of anyone.That may not have been the aim.
Using that sonata for that specific skill for a near beginner is exactly to reduce it into an exercise in LH arpeggios
Eh, no.