i need to choose two of these

[Skeptopotamus]

I finished Miroirs this morning (already had 3/4; just needed to do 1,2,5 which I had already worked on) which means i've got enough time open to do this now.


Here are 5 piano concerti and i need to choose two to learn.  please vote for the TWO you think would be best for me to learn.  If you dont know what some of these are then please go listen before making a decision.

[Skeptopotamus]

oh just wanted to say that that is not the Carter concerto.  carter is pann's first name.

[steinwayguy]

Mmmmm Ligeti.

[Skeptopotamus]

aww nobody is voting for pann -.-  I was kinda leaning towards that one.

[JCarey]

I know I already sent you a PM, but I, personally, would do the Ginastera and the Massenet.

[viking]

Yes same here.  Ginastera and Massenet.  However, are you learning both at the same time to full completion?  What are they for? Will you play them with orchestra?  In that case, the Ligeti would be awesome to play with the orchestra, but not with 2nd piano accompament.
SAM

[BoliverAllmon]

I enjoy the ligeti I would go for that one.

[Skeptopotamus]

I know I already sent you a PM, but I, personally, would do the Ginastera and the Massenet.

yes and i appreciated it very much =)


Well so far it looks like the Ginastera and Ligeti are the top contenders.  I'm not sure if I'd be using these for competitions; mostly just because I really love these concerti =)

[JCarey]

yes and i appreciated it very much =)


Well so far it looks like the Ginastera and Ligeti are the top contenders.  I'm not sure if I'd be using these for competitions; mostly just because I really love these concerti =)

Oh, I see. I thought they were specifically for a competition. Sorry. 

[BoliverAllmon]

yes and i appreciated it very much =)


Well so far it looks like the Ginastera and Ligeti are the top contenders.  I'm not sure if I'd be using these for competitions; mostly just because I really love these concerti =)

If these are just for fun, then I would learn them all. which order? you can choose a couple of ways.

1. in the order of you more likely getting to perform them

2. in order of your fav

or simply

3. alphabetical order.

boliver

[pianonut]

using some advanced psychology, i picked the first two as skeptotamus probably put his favorites first.  but, then again...they are in alphabetical order.  how about (like me) page count?

follow your heart.

[Bouter Boogie]

Is it weird that I don't know any of these?

[Skeptopotamus]

not really; they're all kind of obscure pieces.