Stevie, could you please post the other Tatum video for those of us who never saw it.
Didn't Rach say he was the greatest pianist 'of any style' he had ever heard. Can't find the quote anywhere.
There are some other good quotes, true or not, they reflect the mastery of Tatum over the piano and music:
Rachmaninov said that he understood what Tatum played, but was unable to do the same;
Toscanini said that he was the greatest piano player of all times;
When a young student in music, presumably in one of the Harlem clubs, asked Arthur Rubinstein,"What are you doing in such a place?", Rubinstein simply answered "Shhhh, I'm just listening to the greatest musician that ever was".
When Oscar Peterson first heard Tiger Rag, his response was, "Hm. Those guys are pretty good". Stéphan Grapelli heard the song in France in the year of its release and asked who the "pianists" were; the record dealer told him "Art" and "Tintin".
Buddy DeFranco was one of the few musicians with the virtuosity to truly interplay with Tatum. When asked what it was like to play with Tatum, Buddy answered with just one word: "Scary."
And Toscanini was once an hour late to his own performance in New York because he was stupefied listening to Tatum in a club.
Andy