Piano Forum

Pages: [1] Go Down

Topic: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question (Read 11422 times)

orlandopiano

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 352

I've been teaching this piece for years now, and I still have not been able to give a definative answer to my students on what the chord in m.3 beat 4 is. Is it C major or C minor? I've seen both in different editions, and I've heard both on different recordings. Is there any way to know for sure?

Logged

dnephi

Sr. Member
Posts: 1859

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #1 on: September 29, 2006, 02:20:32 PM

E natural. All knowing ears will be cocked to know whether you play correctly e natural or the erroneous e-flat. (Paraphrased from Ernest Hutcheson)

Good luck.

Logged

For us musicians, the music of Beethoven is the pillar of fire and cloud of mist which guided the Israelites through the desert. (Roughly quoted, Franz Liszt.)

zheer

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 2794

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #2 on: September 29, 2006, 03:11:54 PM

well if we are thinking o the same chord i believe it will sound rather strange to go from c minor to c major in the same bar, but hay what ever blows your hair back.

Logged

" Nothing ends nicely, that's why it ends" - Tom Cruise -

desordre

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 388

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #3 on: September 29, 2006, 11:16:27 PM

Dear Orlando:
It's a C-minor chord. There no possible doubt about it. Analyze the harmonic progression you have each bar, and the whole harmonic structure of the first four bars and you will notice that. In measure 3, the chord on the second beat is a C7, i.e., a secondary dominant to the subdominant degree (which follows on third beat). So, there is no connection between the function of the C chords of the second and fourth beat: one is dominant, the other is tonic.
It becomes more clear if you make a schenkerian analysis, and notice that basically you have in the first four measures a simple progression of i - VI (- i) - V: the other chords just extend this.
Furthermore, you have an echo of this in the second group of bars (5-8), where in the same metric point you have a c-minor chord.
Best wishes!
P.S.: By the way, the Urtext shows a flat on this particular e.

Logged

Player of what?

orlandopiano

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 352

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #4 on: September 30, 2006, 03:06:38 AM

Quote from: dnephi on September 29, 2006, 02:20:32 PM

E natural. All knowing ears will be cocked to know whether you play correctly e natural or the erroneous e-flat. (Paraphrased from Ernest Hutcheson)

Then I guess the Paderewski edition is erroneous, as are Ivo Pogorelich, Daniel Barenboim, Adam Harasiewicz, Martha Argerich, Evgeny Kissin, Claudio Arrau, and Garrick Ohlsson to name a few.

Quote from: desordre on September 29, 2006, 11:16:27 PM

Dear Orlando:
It's a C-minor chord. There no possible doubt about it.

Alfred Cortot, Maurizio Pollini, and Artur Rubinstein (to name a few) would disagree.

For the record, I feel it should be a C minor chord, but this thread alone shows you why there is confusion about this note.

Logged

desordre

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 388

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #5 on: September 30, 2006, 03:29:39 AM

(EDIT: can't stop posting...you already wrote what I would)
Dear Orlando:
Just for the sake of curiosity, I did listen to all my recordings of this preludes, to refresh my ears. Interesting results:
- E natural: Rubinstein, Cortot, Pollini, Perlemuter;
- E flat: Argerich, Lugansky, Zaritzkaya, Biret, Ashkenazy, and the orchestral version made by the composer Jean Françaix.
So... Argerich versus Pollini ... Rubinstein versus Ashkenazy ...

What other versions do you know?
Best wishes!

Logged

Player of what?

zheer

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 2794

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #6 on: September 30, 2006, 07:13:39 AM

Quote from: desordre on September 30, 2006, 03:29:39 AM

:
- E natural: Rubinstein, Cortot, Pollini, Perlemuter;

Cortot is my favorite Chopin player, so you can emagin that i have him playing the preludes on a CD, am 100% sure he plays a C minor chord, anyway the chord that follwows the C minor chord is Aflat, hence it has e flat and a falt within the chord, now well all know that e falt and a flat make-up the C minor scale, so going from c major to a flat is strange, can anyone provide us with a Rubenstine or pollini recording please?

Logged

" Nothing ends nicely, that's why it ends" - Tom Cruise -

nicco

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1191

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #7 on: September 30, 2006, 07:51:11 AM

This is quite interesting. Ive heard both versions now, and the e natural sounds very wrong to me in this type of progression. The melodic line gets totally messed up:

g - ab - g - (f - eb)
eb - f - eb - (d - c)
d - e - g - (f - e vs eb)
d - g - h - (a - g)

As you can see, all the phrases ends with a whole step, so if the f would go to e natural, it would mess up this system.

Btw what follows this chord is surely not an a-flat, but a D7 chord.

Logged

"Without music, life would be a mistake." - Friedrich Nietzsche

zheer

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 2794

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #8 on: September 30, 2006, 08:28:44 AM

Quote from: nicco on September 30, 2006, 07:51:11 AM

Btw what follows this chord is surely not an a-flat, but a D7 chord.

We have an a flat octave followed by an a flat chord in the RH with an e flat playd with the thumb, so possibly a flat second inversion, anyway the chord that follows this is D flat. So we have C minor - Aflat major - Dflat major. Unless you have a good explenation my blood pressure is going to go up.

Logged

" Nothing ends nicely, that's why it ends" - Tom Cruise -

nicco

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1191

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #9 on: September 30, 2006, 08:34:36 AM

Quote from: zheer on September 30, 2006, 08:28:44 AM

We have an a flat octave followed by an a flat chord in the RH with an e flat playd with the thumb, so possibly a flat second inversion, anyway the chord that follows this is D flat. So we have C minor - Aflat major - Dflat major. Unless you have a good explenation my blood pressure is going to go up.

For the record, the chords discussed is in the 3rd-4th measure, 4th-1st beat.

The chord you are describing is the 1st beat of the 2nd measure. Get your facts right.

Logged

"Without music, life would be a mistake." - Friedrich Nietzsche

zheer

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 2794

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #10 on: September 30, 2006, 08:55:58 AM

Quote from: nicco on September 30, 2006, 08:34:36 AM

The chord you are describing is the 1st beat of the 2nd measure. Get your facts right.

Well you know i just had to play through prelude again, and yes further on the prelude we do have a D7 chord, and funy enough a C major chord does not sound too alien, though c minor sound more appropraite. Anyway i was about to jump of a tall building , i wont know we have the facts right.

Logged

" Nothing ends nicely, that's why it ends" - Tom Cruise -

zheer

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 2794

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #11 on: September 30, 2006, 09:01:19 AM

WAW, just heard the Cortot interpretation, and he plays C major, F**ck . Looking at the score we have a C mjor chord indeed. I think i will go and jump of a tall building.

Logged

" Nothing ends nicely, that's why it ends" - Tom Cruise -

desordre

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 388

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #12 on: October 01, 2006, 12:39:19 AM

Quote from: zheer on September 30, 2006, 07:13:39 AM

Cortot is my favorite Chopin player, so you can emagin that i have him playing the preludes on a CD, am 100% sure he plays a C minor chord (...)
(...) can anyone provide us with a Rubenstine or pollini recording please?

Quote from: zheer on September 30, 2006, 09:01:19 AM

WAW, just heard the Cortot interpretation, and he plays C major (...)
(...) I think i will go and jump of a tall building.

Dear Zheer:
Don't do that! Just be more careful with your posts next time...
By the way, do you think yet that we need a correction of Rubinstein and Pollini?

Best wishes!

Logged

Player of what?

jre58591

PS Silver Member
Sr. Member
Posts: 1770

Re: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question

Reply #13 on: October 01, 2006, 03:32:46 AM

in busoni's variations on this prelide, there is an e natural written everywhere that part shows up.

Logged

Please Visit: https://www.pianochat.co.nr
My YouTube Videos: https://www.youtube.com/profile_videos?user=jre58591

Sign-up to post reply

Pages: [1] Go Up

For more information about this topic, click search below!

Piano Street Magazine:
Josef Hofmann – The Pianist Inventor

Many know Josef Hofmann as an exceptional pianist, but how many are aware that he was also a prolific inventor? He was a brilliant mind who found fulfillment not only at the piano but also through numerous patents, channeling his immense passion for mechanics and technology across a variety of fields. But who was Josef Hofmann? Read more

Piano Forum

Topic: Chopin Prelude 28/20 question (Read 11422 times)

Piano Street Magazine:Josef Hofmann – The Pianist Inventor

Piano Street Magazine:
Josef Hofmann – The Pianist Inventor