My muscles on the pinky side of the hand and the one surrounding my thumb are far more developed than any normal person I have the occasion to compare with, and definately more developed than me before playing piano. The strength isn't in the fingers, but in the hand muscles that make them move.
Yeah. And what did you find to be "nightmarish" about this? The fact that your extremely limited knowledge didn't allow you to get you very far in trying to "one-up" me? I'm not like anybody else, son. Everything I post about playing piano can be taken as gospel. I'm the real McCoy, and you know it, and therin lies the problem of your frustrated consternation and inabilty to elaborate on your negative comments directed towards me.
The fastest playing is possible by playing at the surface of the key, eliminating any exaggerated motions.
Wich gives you a crappy sound. Yay.
If you want to opinion of more esteemed pianists, I suggest dropping by here.
More esteemed pianists?How can that place have any credibility ... just read at the naive descriptionsI would be proud of being banned from such forumsSounds like as if opus10no2 created it
I just looked in. What banter are they speaking over there? I saw one thread that was comprised of all 1 word posts or smileys. What is it? All kids?
That's not the problem-the problem is that you seem like a complete phony. Your recordings sound like they were made on a sped-up honky tonk. Can you provide anything more concrete? Honestly. If you want to opinion of more esteemed pianists, I suggest dropping by here. Let me know how many posts you get before you get banned.Regards,Dan
Don't insult Kids are more mature than thatIf you look at the idiots in forums they are almost never kids
Semms like they talk a whole lot about "b***h slappin" and Liszt over there. Fitting. Liszt would b***h-slap the lot of them, with his "black hand" side.
......and the fingers "walking" the hand along the keyboard laterally, instead of the hand taking the fingers to the next location. Like a typewriter carriage carrying the strikers across the paper.
Sounds like as if opus10no2 created it
wow, you really hit the nail on the head.
All hail the great piano prophet, the REAL McCOY! (not the fake one).
Your hands must look like claws when you try to play rapid passages.
Sidebar: Is this the type of forum you people want? You have two people here that know what they're talking about on this thread. You should be learning from this. You should be at the piano while reading these posts by elf and myself, not quibbling like young school girls. This is some atmosphere here on this forum.
If this is indicative of the type of mindset in classical training, no wonder almost no advancements have been made in the past 30 years.
And yours must look rather relaxed...not very taxing to play a computerized file, is it?On the contrary. It speaks to the quality of this forum that so many members possess the ear to be able to tell that the files you posted as your own playing were fabrications. I would be worried if we weren't fooled by that rubbish.Yeah, but why would it be "indicative of the type of mindest in classical training"? What are you even talking about?
Like I said before you ran from the Chat room, you and I, in a room, with a piano. Any piano, any room. You sit down and play and I will duplicate anything you play, bar by bar, in whatever key you pick, only faster.
Indeed, this is getting out of hand. If you wish to continue via private messaging I'm ready, "virtuoso1".
You should save your energy for breathing instead of pontificating.
And you should save your energy by stopping to write all that crap about how good you are, and how anyone else doesent have a clue what you are talking about. Instead, make a geniune recording of yourself playing a piece on the piano, this empty talk and threats you bring on sure dont scare anyone. And about this "Any speed-any key" crap, who cares? Surely you must have learned something else then backwards czerny etudes and chromatic scales?
nice tech!And I gotta say, great repotire range from hattoizing a scale to constant rapid nagging of ur relationship with Habermann.Good job indeed
THIS, from someone with a weak heart and the pulse rate of a nervous rabbit! Weak heart = weak body and mind, but you already know that. Your hands must look like claws when you try to play rapid passages. Ultimately, it's all about ejection fraction, or the lack of it. You should save your energy for breathing instead of pontificating.
What is left is the conclusion that speed, control and accuracy are all extra-physiological aspects of piano playing. The proof of the pudding is that if you take a pianist who lacks control of the 4th and 5th finger, who lack speed and who lacks accuracy and observe his physiology and then observe him again after 6 months when he has gained lot of control of the "weak" fingers, accuracy and speed ... no kind of physiological difference will ever be observed. Unlike a sport athlete which will show physiological differences from a stage to another
your technical advice wasn't offending people, it was your recordings. your advice was good in many ways, your technique may well be very good or excellent even, but the technique that you showed us was purely digital technology.
Whatever - dear virtuosic1, i tried your advice now and there is a little confusion. If i understood you correctly, i will have to "roll" my hand from the first over to the last note of each 4 note groups ?! But if i do so, where would my wrist reach the highest point, in the middle or at the end of the 4 notes ? Now it feels comfotable to drop the hands into the first note and then to contract it towards the fourth note with the wrist high at this point - is that correct or did i get it completely wrong ? Daniel
Sorry, Daniel. Can't comment further on this. Certain forum members will not allow me to assist you in a civil manner, and if I post about anything technical, will keep continuing to turn the thread into a lynch party with more accusations of fakery. I'm sure that with all the consummate, world class experts on every subject under the sun you have hooting and hollering in this thread, they'll have you squared away on this in short order. I'll just listen in.
Are you seriously 50 years old? Cause you're acting like an angry teenager. Get a grip man.
While you are correct, he did found it, you will find among our prestigious members Koji Attwood, Jeffrey Lee, and the Canadian.
Daniel,It is hard to say, as I don't know your hands and did not see what are you doing there. I am always for one who follows the most natural and economical ways of piano playing, so... let's start from the beginning.Two main and usual mistakes people do in this etude: 1) Too impatient to play too fast right away and 2) Practice/play too loud.The 2) is the main source of tension and also stands on the way of right musical execution. By the last I mean, there is a creschendo on the top of the passages and diminuendo when you go down--that's acoustical principals of the instrument and rational/clever use of dynamics.In other words, you play bass forte, then R.H. very lightly, making a cresch. only on the last 4 notes on the top, and then going down very light. THis way you will get right musical image, right overall dynamics, and ensure your hands stay free and relaxed, without getting stuck in the keys because of unnecessary pressure.Practice slowly. 1) Put your fingers on the keys absolutely relaxed. Very important point--you fingers should be always on the keys, as indicator they are relaxed. If something "jumps up" in the air, it means there is tension there. Put your attention there.2) Very lightly but very actively depress the key, feeling how your finger tip meets the key bed, immediately stopping pressure. It is like a light dart piercing a board and then all the energy gets immediately released. You hand should feel calm and relaxed at all times.Practice very slowly. DON"T EVEN THINK OF PLAYING FASTER. At this point the main thing is to get used to the new feelings of calmness and touch in your hands and fingers, and patience is of utmost importance.It is very hard to put on paper (well, on the screen ), so if something unclear please ask.Best regards, M
What are you going to do when I post videos, profess that those are altered too?