Piano Style "This or That"

[tradge]

Pretty simplereally, I start by giving two choices, you say which you prefer, and give two different choices afterwards, e.g. I say:

Chopin or Liszt?

someone else replies with:

Chopin

Chopin 10, 5 or Chopin 25, 11?

-------------------------------------

Here we go:

Arthur Rubinstein or Sviatoslav Richter?

[ramseytheii]

-------------------------------------

Here we go:

Arthur Rubinstein or Sviatoslav Richter?

Incidentally, Rubinstein loved Richter.  He said about him, "Richter plays, and the piano responds.  It brings tears to my eye."  I don't know what feelings Richter had about Rubinstein, but I am sure they were mutually positive.

Walter Ramsey

[ihatepop]

Could you produce some simpler choices?

ihatepop

[tradge]

Fine! *sighs* honestly some of you are so difficult!! It's a choice of saying one answer and moving on!! Flippin' heck, there's some awkward people on here!

If it makes you happy:

Chopin Ballade, Op. 52  OR  Scriabin Op. 8, No. 12?

[gymnopedist]

Chopin Ballade. I've never liked the Scriabin.

Miroirs or Gaspard?

[tradge]

Chopin Ballade. I've never liked the Scriabin.

Miroirs or Gaspard?

Gaspard by a long shot

for rachmaninov...
Lugansky or Gilels?

[jlh]

Gaspard by a long shot

for rachmaninov...
Lugansky or Gilels?

Lugansky

For Beethoven:

Gilels or Goode

[mike_lang]

Gilels

For Chopin:

Pletnev or Argerich?

[tradge]

Gilels

For Chopin:

Pletnev or Argerich?

I think Argerich

Rach 3rd Concerto, or Chopin 2nd Concerto?

[ihatepop]

Chopin 2nd Concerto

Chopin etude op10 no1, or Chopin etude op25 No3?

ihatepop

[ramseytheii]

Isn't it possible to confine this weary topic to some dusty corner of pianoforum, like "Polls, etc." with an emphasis on the "etc."?  Or maybe we can create some new Sibera just for this, a subcategory of the subcategory "Polls, etc." called "Modified Polls - etc."

Walter Ramsey

[gymnopedist]

25/3 it is. Not that 10/1 isn't nice, i've just always been partial to the other.

Images book I or II?

[rach n bach]

I would say neither... but II if I had to pick. 

Chopin etudes op10 or op25?  (or trois... I guess...)

[ihatepop]

Op10

Beethoven Turkish March No4, or Beethoven Rondo A Capriccio 'Rage over a lost penny' Op129?

ihatepop