here me playing la campanella(my own version) in two parts

[fredericfrancoischopin]

much better than 1st try

[pianowolfi]

LOL Yeah I know this effect from some of my little students who play a five-note-piece with only one finger. If I tell them they need to use fingering, aka use all of their fingers, they say: Ohhh I just feel better doing it MY way. oh well........

Why don't you try to play "La campanella" with only one finger? I'm sure you will be the first pianist in history who does this and get into the hall of fame......

[fredericfrancoischopin]

why one finger???

i dont get it

Bernard

[pianowolfi]

Well, you write "my version" but this "my version" actually has nothing to do with a "version" but just with messing up a piece completely. So it reminded me of little kids doing their "own version" with no technique and no clue about how to play the piano....

[fredericfrancoischopin]

Well, you write "my version" but this "my version" actually has nothing to do with a "version" but just with messing up a piece completely. So it reminded me of little kids doing their "own version" with no technique and no clue about how to play the piano....

okay mr pianowolfi do your own la campanella and than come with this comments oky? loserrrrrrrrrrrrr

and you have no students,cuz you cant even play minuet from bach;)

booooooooooo

[pianowolfi]

okay mr pianowolfi do your own la campanella and than come with this comments oky? loserrrrrrrrrrrrr

and you have no students,cuz you cant even play minuet from bach;)

booooooooooo

Baaaaahhhhh!!!



 

Seriously, get a teacher. If you want to listen to something truly pianistic, go here, for instance:

https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php/topic,33034.msg385224.html#msg385224

Best wishes

[fredericfrancoischopin]

Baaaaahhhhh!!!



 

Seriously, get a teacher. If you want to listen to something truly pianistic, go here, for instance:

https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php/topic,33034.msg385224.html#msg385224

Best wishes

i had other pieces done with the teacher ,this i did without teacher

currently working on fantasie impromptu

any practise tips from you?

sorry about previous comment

and i love your improvisation


i already know
that i have to play piece

slowly and without mistakes and musically as well
and i also know that i must do hand separate

anything else  would be very helpful

thnx in forward

Bernard

[pianowolfi]

It would be for sure helpful to play some "easier" pieces before tackling Campa and FI. The longer I work the more I realize that there are not so many really "easy" pieces. Bach inventions would be a good possibility, as they are very educative and at the same time wonderful and challenging music.
Btw you are right, I don't play Campanella yet, I save this for later in my life....

[goldentone]

Mr. Chopin, Wolfi is a well-respected member of this forum, pianist and teacher.  The audition room is indeed a place to receive feedback from fellow pianists, but not in the state that you have presented La Campanella to us.  Find something more appropriate for your level.

[fredericfrancoischopin]

Mr. Chopin, Wolfi is a well-respected member of this forum, pianist and teacher.  The audition room is indeed a place to receive feedback from fellow pianists, but not in the state that you have presented La Campanella to us.  Find something more appropriate for your level.

so what ,he didnt show any qualities

booo:D

[scottmcc]

bernard, the problem you are having is that the audition room's standards are very, very high, especially for advanced music such as this.  the expectation is that all of the notes are correct, or at very most you make a few minor errors.  the primary type of suggestions that people are eliciting when they post in the audition room are about interpretation--nuances, not major structural issues.

you clearly have a long way to go before this piece is up to that standard.  it's hard music, and I won't claim that I can play it, because I can't.  the difference is, I know that I can't, but you seem to think that you can. 

I'm not trying to be mean here; rather, I want you to understand why others have been so negative when you post.  good luck.

[tds]

i must say that the introduction is world class!

but the rest is a toothache and total constipation. sorry..

[cherub_rocker1979]

[olga_janina]

This is a joke, right?  You don't actually think this is good.  I can play it better and I REALLY suck!

[fredericfrancoischopin]

This is a joke, right?  You don't actually think this is good.  I can play it better and I REALLY suck!

record better version and i will congratiolate to you ,now i can only say you cant even play minuet from Bach

[fredericfrancoischopin]

i must say that the introduction is world class!

but the rest is a toothache and total constipation. sorry..

thnx tds ,i aprricate your comments ,i will work on this la campanella alot more:)

[fredericfrancoischopin]

bernard, the problem you are having is that the audition room's standards are very, very high, especially for advanced music such as this.  the expectation is that all of the notes are correct, or at very most you make a few minor errors.  the primary type of suggestions that people are eliciting when they post in the audition room are about interpretation--nuances, not major structural issues.

you clearly have a long way to go before this piece is up to that standard.  it's hard music, and I won't claim that I can play it, because I can't.  the difference is, I know that I can't, but you seem to think that you can. 

I'm not trying to be mean here; rather, I want you to understand why others have been so negative when you post.  good luck.

and thnx scott for explaining to me some things ithat i didnt realized before

best wishes

Bernard

[olga_janina]

it's hard music, and I won't claim that I can play it, because I can't.  the difference is, I know that I can't, but you seem to think that you can.

Yes, I think the OP is winding us all up tbh.  Nobody is that delusional, surely.