No serious person goes to the internet when they have a rash... they see a doctor.
No serious person tries to get advice on the law from the internet, they get a lawyer.
No serious person should be trying to get advice on how to play the piano from the internet... that's why we have Piano teachers!!!
It makes me a little sad to read this. Like it's just something you
have to do and not something you
want to do... And why would I need to be
serious if all I want is to play? You know, for my personal enjoyment?
You didn't read what I said then... I said that piano lessons should not only be for those who take it seriously... piano lessons should be necessary for everybody who wants to learn the piano.
You make that sound like there was some danger* attached to playing the piano, like driving a car, so that everyone should have to get a license, take a test and pay some money for it.
Given your employment it's easy to see your motive. What I don't see is an airtight argument as to why you think this should be a requirement for
everyone.
*) Yes I kow, you could hurt your hands/fingers/back. All activities can be harmful but that doesn't mean there are teachers for everything.
You don't go to an art class and read books - you get advice from an experienced art teacher... even people who do it as a hobby go for classes instead of reading books.
You can't say that the skill of playing piano is any different can you? So I do NOT agree that piano lessons should only be for serious piano players.
So, how about doing all of that? It's not like "online" would mean there's nobody to ask or get advice from. It just means that person isn't sitting right next to you. (I does shift a lot of responsibility to the student though, so you could argue it's not the right method to teach kids and I'd agree.)
I'm learning from an online course (not the one linked above but I'm not going post a link in here) created by a piano teacher - a "real" one like you, who has given personal lessons for the last 20 years (and still does). From what I gather, her site was initially only meant as bonus material for her students. Apparently other people were interested too, and it became an online course.
Anyway, I'm quite glad I found that course, because I did have a real teacher when I was young and didn't learn a whole lot. Back then, I though
I'd lack the skill to play and quit, but now that I'm halfway through that online course, I'm convinced
he just lacked the skill to teach.
It's a little late (in years) to "get serious" for me, so I'll simply stick with my online lessons. It's not perfect, nothing is, but it's enough. It won't make me Mozart, but at this point, nothing would.
I'm sure there are lots of other people in a similar situation who just want to play a little for themselves or possibly the people they care about. For those and in my opinion, a good online course
can be an alternative.
Just to be clear: I'm not saying the OPs course is good/bad/anything. I didn't visit that site. I'm happy with the one I have. I merely disagree with the notion that an online course can never be "good" and that a teach is required, no matter what motivation you have for wanting to learn.