Be careful with those words "exceptional talent."
And I bet the fact is they're more interested in filling up the spots in order to get the dough in, as opposed to finding "exceptional talent", whatever they really mean by it.
I applied to Princeton, which had the same wording. Basically they required a Bach Prelude an Fugue, a mvmt from a Beethoven Sonata, and something substantial from another time era. If you have a CD with these, that should be fine, but if anything less, I wouldn't send a CD as it might hurt you application.