Thank you for posting your 2 other concerti! I certainly shall have a listen and see whether the others are right about it being a bit unsatisfactory. So far listening to your other concerti they are definitely wrong. Your concerti are good! BTW, How long does it take you to composer a concerto? and plz post some notes on your concerti, as you often do.
Depends of many of factors, like the inspiration to build the basic ideas,the estructural project and form used. The mood is very important too.So, in general, large-scale music like concertos demand much more time.Is not only about create the ideas, but also how to organize that ideasin a way that all sections interconnects to make the whole thing uniform.Then you have to find ways about how the orchestra "reacts" to the piano,creating Intros, dialogues, the "tutti" and between expositions and reexpositionsof the 2 themes + development section and codas - to build a "Sonata"In a concerto, [at least in my point of view] both, orchestra and piano, must share the themes, in a way that make sense in terms of the "whole unity" of thework.On the Concerto op.86 no.2, I try innovate, like put the development sectioninto the "cadenza".
Thank you Guilherme! may this advice serve as a stepping stone to composing concerti for wannabe composers on PS! I've certainly been noticing some conversations going on in your concerti. If you're working on your 6th, take your time and go over it over and over again and add some and take some away if it works in your concerto.
I'm pleased to hear that you went through tough periods when you faced bad ciritcism. Not only have you risen from the ashes to compose great works, but also perfected them. your Nocturnes are sounding great. I think the main highlights are really your concerti in my opinion. No matter how bad or good they are in people's opinions, composing a concerti is one enormous feat not for the faint hearted and you've certainly done a good job. Are there any compositions that have loud sections? if so, that would be great because some characteristics of romanticism are contrast in dynamics and mood, which you have achieved. Sorry if my comments are too harsh. Remember, you are a valuable asset to PS and there is always improvement in your compositions. There is no perfect composition.
"loud sections" you mean, some contrasts."This I explained before, look the old texts. The third and fourth Nocturne have no only a lot of "loud" parts like you say - but also creation of tensions and climax.The number 1 and 2 is monotematic, I did that way intentionally.But is not all the time "piano" , but the middle section have a lot of moments of tension too.