of all books of technical exercises, why has hanon's the most popular?i have seen all of the most popular exercise books, and this looks to be the least useful of all..why?!?!
my point is - why specifically is HANON the most popular exercise method?
how can so many people be so gullible and naive?
low blow man. horowitz also played Hanon, scales, and arpeggios.
despite frequest wrong notes in his later life - he did have a SUPERB technique, his command of earth shattering sonority is just phenomenal.
Quote from: julie391 on November 20, 2004, 10:29:57 PMdespite frequest wrong notes in his later life - he did have a SUPERB technique, his command of earth shattering sonority is just phenomenal.The purpose of Hanon's exercises aren't to develop earth-shattering sonority. He developed that of his own accord.
Quote from: BoliverAllmon on November 20, 2004, 09:22:31 PMlow blow man. horowitz also played Hanon, scales, and arpeggios.Coincidentally, Horowitz also had really shitty technique.
I really don't think Hanon deserves the bad rap it's getting from some. As they say in medicine: "First do no harm". Will playing Hanon exercises harm you in any way?
I know this girl in my class who is a beginner and the teacher gave her the hanon book she won't stop playing warm ups everyday in class on the grand and it is annoying!! and I don't think her playing has improved maybe even decreased I dont think she practices anything BUT HANON WUTEVER
Quote from: bunbuns on November 22, 2004, 05:32:01 PMI know this girl in my class who is a beginner and the teacher gave her the hanon book she won't stop playing warm ups everyday in class on the grand and it is annoying!! and I don't think her playing has improved maybe even decreased I dont think she practices anything BUT HANON WUTEVERlol, you should educate her then
Quote from: jazzyprof on November 22, 2004, 07:43:33 PMI really don't think Hanon deserves the bad rap it's getting from some. As they say in medicine: "First do no harm". Will playing Hanon exercises harm you in any way?Yes, it can hurt your musicality a lotI've friend whose musicality they had while playing was something marvelous, and now after working with Hanon they play all pieces mechanically withou emotion, like robotsOn the other hand Hanon deserves all the bad rep and critique just for the fact that he made absurd misleading claims Had he been less presumptuos his book would have been just another technical exercises book that one can like or not, but after all that unrealistic promises plus the fact that he had his book pushed in accademies through interested donations(in fact there were a time in the 1930 in which a teacher could not choose not to use it, they were not allowed to crticized it now they can have their voice heard in accademies) his book is an example of dishonesty and possibly dangerousDaniel