Rebound students: Pro and cons for the ABRSM exams?

[bernadette60614]

I restarted piano lessons three years ago after a 25 year hiatus.  I began piano lessons again just with the intention of playing for recreation, but the more I play the more I realize that I need to know more to play well.

I've taken a look at the ABRSM exams, and I'm wondering if I should pursue that route.  It seems very systematic which seems to be a sound approach.

Thanks all!

[j_menz]

ABRSM, as well as any of the recognised exam routes, offers a structure around which to build your learning. This has a number of advantages. It also has some disadvantages - particularly if you use them as a "learn to pass exams" route - narrowing your focus and the pieces you learn, rather than ensuring they are broad and multifaceted (which is the intention).

It is possible to follow the structure without necessarily sitting the exams, so you should consider this as a third option. This also allows adaptation to fit your own needs and what you want to achieve and do. Which path you take is really a matter for you.

[faulty_damper]

Generally, I would not recommend the ABRSM curricula because of its extrinsic motivation.  Taking and passing exams gives a false sense of security in one's knowledge and abilities.  Once Grade 8 is passed, you may feel like you've accomplished all there is since that is the final grade when in reality, there is much more to be learned.

Almost every one of the students I knew who passed Grade 8 quit the piano, never to play again.  These were pretty talented individuals as well but they didn't seem to be in it for the music, just the certificates.