If it's not open for discussion, why is it posted in a discussion forum? Members should have the right to discuss the ideas as they see fit, and it may even be beneficial to the OP - who knows?
lol...seems Yadeehoo's obsession with the piano has waned a bit... he was all over the forum a while back. wonder where he's been... he was funny.
I am positive he is at his piano practicing op 10 no 1
I remember all the back and forth between the op and others about the right way to go about learning etudes and higher level compositions. Then I checked out his video on his play of revolutionary etude and I chuckled. He has no semantically abled understanding of how to go about learning or playing that piece. It was totally obvious from the first ten seconds.
So what you're saying is; If you want to think you're progressing, when actually you're wasting your time and have to double your work just because at the time it was "fun" that's what you should aim for as a hobby pianist, rather than listen to the advice of others, more experienced, assuming that's the reason someone joins a piano forum in the first place?Ridiculous is an understatement of what you've said. There are so many things wrong with that statement I refuse to address them.
A comment saying don't worry about doing it wrong as long as you enjoy it, does not correct anything and does not help progression.
I would consider your response, had it not been the fact that this example relates to somebody that did join a piano forum and was quite rude with their "advice" to other users. It would be fair to assume no matter what level you're trying to obtain, the only reason you would be on a forum like this would be to seek advice to either correct your practice or for progression.