"The best" way to learn piano?

[ranjit]

Given how much the piano has been studied, by researchers, concert pianists and high level piano teachers, and millions of students over decades if not centuries, there surely must be people who have attempted to assimilate all of the pieces of advice/evidence into a theoretical "best way" to learn to play the piano in the shortest time possible. What, in your experience, or based on material that you have read or seen, constitute aspects of the ideal way to learn to play the piano?

[lelle]

Regular lessons with a really good teacher and doing the work. Plus a genuine desire to learn the piano and suitable temperament for working the way you need to work to get really good. (Not research based, just having met many pianists and/or listened to them talk about their work at this point).

[ranjit]

Is it really that simple, though?

[ronde_des_sylphes]

Almost certainly there is more single "best" way. Just for starters, what's going to be optimal for a situation where the pupil is someone who seems really talented and there are aspirations for a career (ie engrain theory and technical exercises early on) isn't going to be ideal for a pupil who just wants to be a hobbyist with basic competence. Imo.

[lostinidlewonder]

Well what is "best"? How about someone practicing piano 12 hours a day for 70 years? The nature of your question is flawed if it implies there is a single best way for everyone. Everyone has their own goals and their own brain and hands to contend with and also life situations.

Your question also implies there is an ending to one's piano studies to "learn the piano in the shortest time possible". Unless ones concept as to what constitutes learning the piano is encased within a limited set of skills learned at a specific standard (which is quite a narrow perspective), there is no end.

There are axioms which tend to be consistent with the best way to learn, such as guidance from someone more experienced, consistent effort, setting goals, maintaining motivation etc etc, but exactly how these work certainly comes with variation, thus a universal "best way" also becomes various. It is not only various but also can change over time with individuals, so there is no fixed "best" way too and it certainly is fluid and changing.

[lostinidlewonder]

The most effective way to learn piano is through structured piano lessons, consistent practice, and genuine passion ....that are well-structured and tailored to your skill level can greatly enhance your learning experience. When combined with regular practice and a love for playing, you can achieve great success in piano learning.
Formal Piano Lessons: Enrolling in formal piano lessons, whether with a private instructor or through a reputable music school, provides a structured learning environment. A skilled teacher can offer guidance, correct technique, and personalized feedback, accelerating the learning process.
Regular Practice: Consistent practice is crucial for mastering any musical instrument, including the piano. Establishing a practice routine helps build muscle memory, improve finger dexterity, and enhance overall proficiency. Quality practice, focusing on specific techniques or pieces, is often more beneficial than lengthy, unfocused sessions.
Use of Educational Resources: Take advantage of educational resources such as piano method books, online tutorials, and interactive apps. These tools can supplement formal lessons, providing additional practice materials, theory explanations, and exercises to reinforce learning.
Set Clear Goals: Define short-term and long-term goals to track progress and maintain motivation. Whether it's mastering a specific piece, achieving a certain level of proficiency, or even composing your music, having clear objectives can keep you focused and engaged.
Explore Various Genres: While classical music forms the foundation of piano education, exploring different genres can make learning more enjoyable. Experimenting with jazz, pop, or other styles broadens your musical understanding and keeps the learning experience dynamic.
Develop Ear Training: Ear training is essential for a well-rounded pianist. Work on recognizing melodies, chords, and intervals by ear. This skill enhances your ability to play by ear, improvise, and understand the nuances of music.
Join a Music Community: Engaging with a musical community, either locally or online, provides opportunities for collaboration, performance, and shared learning experiences. Connecting with fellow pianists can be motivating and inspiring.
Be Patient and Persistent: Learning the piano is a gradual process, and progress may not always be linear. Be patient with yourself, celebrate small victories, and persist through challenges. Developing a resilient mindset is crucial for long-term success.
Remember that the best approach varies for each individual, so it's essential to tailor your learning journey to your preferences and goals. Whether you're a beginner or an advanced player, a combination of these elements can contribute to a fulfilling and effective piano learning ...

Thank you ChatGPT