Beethoven Choral Fantasy - Tied Note

[warburtonj]

Isn't the note highlighted at the link below a tied note? If so why is there fingering markings saying it is to be played?

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/1n70z4l4401d5qqhwrk5b/20240823_220439.jpg?rlkey=z0211l9mo34qwiv0t7kxns1y6&st=jm7qnqfb&dl=0

[liszt-and-the-galops]

Isn't the note highlighted at the link below a tied note? If so why is there fingering markings saying it is to be played?

https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/1n70z4l4401d5qqhwrk5b/20240823_220439.jpg?rlkey=z0211l9mo34qwiv0t7kxns1y6&st=jm7qnqfb&dl=0

Perhaps he wants you to shift the note from the first finger to the second.
I'm honestly not sure, but that's the best I've got.

[sonata_5]

Basically when you want to shift from one hand position to the next on a tied not you have to shift fingers without changing the note.

[warburtonj]

I'm now wondering if my sheet music is incorrect because I looked at another online version and that note is not tied.  I am using Peters edition and some of the fingering also seems very unusual to me.  I might buy a different version to compare against.

[jamienc]

It is to be tied, but the fingering on the tie is irrelevant since the interpretation of the phrase ending would indicate that you would lift your hands and set a new fingering for the next chord. The chord on the downbeat is a resolution that is “let go” once you’ve arrived on beat 1. Lift and choose whatever fingering you want for the next chord.