Nelita True vs. Andrew Ball

[haarmonika]

Have you studied with Nelita True or Andrew Ball?
Please tell me what you think about them.
For now, my choice is to have a few lessons with True and a master class with Ball at a summer festival...hm...should I stick with this choice?

[thomj]

I had a masterclass in london with Andrew Ball in Nov 04, although I can't say I know anything of Nelita True to compare. He was very insightful and intelligent, and I found myself responding very positively to all of his comments. He understands music at a very deep level and is very astute. He talked a lot of orchestral colours and tone, and voices, and independence of voice. He's great for interpretation, lots of ideas and not unwilling to have a polite debate. I have heard, although- that he leaves technique aside somewhat. It is for this reason that I have chosen another teacher- I am desperately in need of better technique- so for the moment anyway, I have to focus on that. But if you were happy with your technique, then I have no problems recommending Andrew Ball as an outstanding teacher...

[Alde]

I have heard some great things about Nelita True.  Although her playing isn't the best.  She really knows how to teach.  She also has a great track record of producing world class pianists.

[earthward]

Well you should study w/ Nelita because you'll at least know that whatever she says is True 

I'm sorry. Really bad joke.  (somebody was bound to, might as well be me)

[thomj]

Well I don't know.... at least Andrew's always on the Ball!

(haha just trying to make you feel better...)