GREATEST EVER - Concertos

[brewtality]

Sorta related question. What do people think are the best concertos from the Hyperion Romantic Piano Concerto series?

Henselt, Bortkiewicz (an imaginary version not Coombs) Rubinstein 4th (Hofmann's not Hamelin's version), Paderewski. I'll think of more later.

[mikey6]

In no order coz I can't order them

Me like-
Mozart 22,23,15
Beethoven 4,5
Liszt 1
Ravel G
Schumann
Prokofiev 2
Brahms ....ahm...1
Rach Pag
Strauss burleske (coz I played it)
Saint-Saens 2,5
Respighi mixolydian mode

Me no like much-
Scriabin
Strauss paregon
Mozart 25
Shosta 1 not a huge fan of
cadenza from Tchaik 3

This is takin me ages so i'm gonna leave it there.

[mostlyclassical]

But it is a concerto. 

Is it, really? Not a set of variations for piano + orchestra?  (rach's paganini rhapsody)

[airasia]

I have no idea how we can produce an exhaustive list of the "greatest" anything in music. I mean what should the criteria be?

Exactly