Perhaps you should try not clicking on religious topics. It works pretty well.
moan, moan, pregnant dog, pregnant dog .Ok I have made my views clear about this before. Can we please try and temper the religious rantings? Or at least keep god out of general discussion and have a dedicated board for religious matters?I do not believe in god. I do not come to PF to hear sermons or read slabs of text quoted from the bible. If I did I would go to church or pick up my own copy of the bible.I do not want to argue ad nauseum about the merits of christianity or whether god created the universe with a wave of his magic wand and I don't want to have to read these silly pointless discussions.It seems this stuff is slipping into the most innocuous threads. If I see a thread about creationism I can choose to ignore it . But why does "god this god that blah blah blah"crap have to creep into a thread about the US maintaining a presence in Iraq? Or about peoples' educational qualifications?I am not advocating censorship but I think it would be really good if we could have a dedicated "religious board" for the god enthusiasts to have their discussions without driving the less godly among us up the wall. It is actually quite offensive to have god stuffed down your throat all the time when you really want to read a discussion about US foreign policy, for example.It would be considerate of other members to appreciate that not everyone comes to PF for a sermon. Is it just me? Or does anyone else think we should keep religion out of general discussion?
I guess in short... Its free speech. You cant censor somebodys elses opinions because you disagree with them...
You're suggesting an appropriate place but this IS an appropriate place. Unless I'm much mistaken this section of the forum is called "Anything But Piano".
I think Ada's problem is god making her way into threads that are not inherently religious.
At the risk of appearing to speak for "Ada" out of turn, I agree with this. I think that "Ada"'s concern appears also to relate specifically to the sheer extent to which religious matter is introduced into individual posts on topics which are not, in and of themselves, inherent ly religious."Ada" has made a perfectly understandable and valid point. Turning off the computer is not the answer; nor, as "Ada" has indicated, is censorhip the answer. Skimming over such text as falls into the category concerned is the answer; this should avoids most of the irritation that reading it verbatim might otherwise bring about.Another problem which I suspect that "Ada" may perceive and which may increase the annoyance is that most if not all of the texts concerned are not merely "religiously" oriented but specifically biblical and Christian in content. There are, of course, other religious persuasions and, in any case, atheists are equally able to "preach sermons" supporting what they believe to be the importance of their cause. I imagine, therefore, that "Ada" dislikes this apparent lack of balance.I have no problems with people bringing in various applications of their beliefs into topics that may not be inherently religious, provided that what is written can reasonably be accepted - even by those who do not share those beliefs - as relevant to the topic. At the same time, however, I do think that, if religious pursuit is really to exert a positive influence on the conduct of those who do it, those of religious persuasions might do well to indulge some consideration towards those who do not share their beliefs by not writing too much of that kind of material in posts on non-inherently-religious topics.Lastly, let us remember that what "Ada" originally called for here was for attempts to be made to "temper" such writing...Best,Alistair
there's a blessing that goes with the keeping of the sabbath in isaiah 58:13 'if becuase of the sabbath you turn your foot from doing your own pleasure on My holy day, and call the sabbath a delight, the holy day of the Lord honorable, and shall honor it, desisting from your own ways, from seeking your own pleasure, and speaking your own word, then you will take delight in the Lord, and I will make you ride on the heights of the earth (rulership); and i will feed you with the heritage of jacob (grafts anyone in who listens) your father, for the mouth of the Lord has spoken.'
I agree, and would like to suggest that a more immediate issue that we find here is that of relevance to the topic. I often see these "rants", and they have absolutely nothing in common with the original topic. It is just as on the threads where people ask things such as "What is your favorite composer, your favorite piece by that composer, and why?", and the posters proceed to give a top ten list of composers and of the doctoral repertoire, without explanation. The problem is adherence to the original topic, and that of indulging digressions. It is alright, I would say, to have these "religious rants" on the non-piano board, but only if the thread is labeled as having that theme.On a separate note, it is inconsiderate to impose one's own religious beliefs (in this sermonic form) on a global forum where people hail from all different cultures, creeds, and religious practices.Best,ML
Another problem which I suspect that "Ada" may perceive and which may increase the annoyance is that most if not all of the texts concerned are not merely "religiously" oriented but specifically biblical and Christian in content. Best,Alistair
I don't want to make her a foeBut must say to "pianistimo"The things that you're li'bleTo read in the BibleIt ain't necessarily so...Best,Alistair
Legendary
or perhaps just a jolly good rodgering
It's clear you need Jesus
God is everywhere.
That is grossly misogynist highly offensive and most un-PC but I defend your right to say it Just don't preach at me
I thought that a jolly ro(d)ger was a flag...Best,Alistair
Maybe we should also have a Hanon board so all the Hanon lovers can rant about how great Hanon is.Also a thread for the dedication about where the muscles that move the fingers are actually located.maybe a board dedicated to DaSDC?maybe a board dedicated to genius and other forms of randomness? randomly speaking of course.the list could go on People have differences of opinions about alot of different things. to seperate them all is just stupid. I don't care what you say it is censorship. Now I am not just saying this because I am a Christian. I apply this to everyone. I think Howard Stern and all the other shock jocks should be given the same privileges and rights.
you shouldnt be offended, i am rather wonderful.
i am rather wonderful.
not sure about the flag, but i can provide the flag pole.
blows trumpet loudly.
disappears. (i am taking on split personality - ofm1469and others like bob).
when a christian attempts to tell people about God - they feel they failed if the person turns around and walks away disgruntled.
now, about leaving. how much will you pay me?
i've never gone door to door.
i've never sold the gospel like medicine.
only occasionally i'll argue with scripture because that 's my 'sword.' u know how music makes u feel all strong and powerful - like ur superman/woman when u learn something difficult. say the 'waldstein.' and, then u go around playing it for everyone. well, the gospel is similar
u suddenly find that u have 'peace that passes all understanding.' and, u want to share it because it's a more peaceful way of existing. it gives u fortitude and strength that u didn't have before.
$5000.Thal
I'll leave for $3,000.John
I can only afford to get rid of Pianistimo this month. Maybe next month.Gotta pay for me holiday this month.Thal
blows trumpet loudly. disappears. (i am taking on split personality - ofm1469and others like bob). ada, i thought about randomly leaving since you were so kind to do so a few months back. but, then, after you left i missed you . was actually quite glad you came back. u see, when a christian attempts to tell people about God - they feel they failed if the person turns around and walks away disgruntled. so, then - think - hmm. must be more discreet with ada. must say polite things and avoid discussion of bible and all with ada. so - p urposely i don't follow u around on threads and say 'hey, ada - can you spare a long paragraph?'now, about leaving. how much will you pay me?
ok. it's a deal. now u can bet i'll be harrassing u in november. and, alistair. you'll both be sorry.
How 'bout the budget plan? $50 for a week, $150 for a month, etc. John
thal's been thinking about this quite a bit. he's been quiet for hours. it's only $5000., thal. enough to complete a new wardrobe and still fly to london.