Prokofiev Sonatas Complete edition

[kaiwin]

Which edition should I buy that has enough fingerings for the the third Sonata?

Thanks!

[jre58591]

id hate to tell you, but if you need the fingerings written out for you, you probably arent ready to play the piece.

[pianiststrongbad]

Hi, gotta agree with jre58591 on this.  I am using the edition edited by Gyorgy Sandor (it has some fingerings), though I believe it is out of print. 

[kaiwin]

id hate to tell you, but if you need the fingerings written out for you, you probably arent ready to play the piece.

No fingerings written out like a lot like the whole page is filled with numbers and stuff, "I mean like some fingerings that would clarify some hand positions". I use to have a whole score with no fingering whatsoever... It was confusing at first and took a while to finger it. But actually the one from piano.ru is the one I'm looking for, I forgot about that site.
Thanks!

But what is the best edition?

[kitty on the keys]

i use the "International" edition for the complete. For the fingering----i sit down and work it out or call a fellow pianist who has played the Sonata and ask their advice.

Kitty

[melengi]

boosey and hawkes is fine for prokofiev sonatas, fingering where needed.

[quantum]

Has Dover done a edition?

[franz_]

May be off topic, but:

Which sonata is harder:

1st or 3rd ?

[troglodyte]

I have both the Boosey & Hawkes and the Kalmus. I have not yet seen a single fingering.

[melengi]

I was sure there was in boosey and hawkes but you're right. Not really necessary anyway.

[kaiwin]

I personally think 3rd cuz its more fun 
Lets scare the audience