Yeh I can recognise everything, car horns, engine noise, glasses, sometimes when people shout at me, like teachers at school, I used to no what pitch they were shouting at.
But your theories of the violin is not perfect pitch at all. You no that the F should lie just into the E string, so you can search for it, but bearing in mind you have 4 solid references, the G, D,A and E. So it is all relative. I could pick up a violin and play any random part of it and name the pitch, I can do it on any instrument, or anything.
But shoenberg....You surely were born with that abilty? You then became aware of it, and used it? So you did not think one day...I'll learn perfect pitch. You already had a sense of it.
Aspects of perfect pitch cannot be leant, they are inborn. Shoenberg didn't learn it though in the sense you are on about. He had it, and the more he practiced piano the better it developed.
You also claim that your theory is correct based on the evidence of 1 person. Yet there are more people say it can't be learnt.
You don't even have perfect pitch, you have no idea what it actually is, you seem biiter against people born with abilty. You say that Mozart was taught. Obviosuly, but he clearly had talent. Why do you compare everything to science, you think so mechanically, you base your theories around scientific theories that are debatable by the best scientists in the world. Mozarts abilities were inborn, as were Beethoevns,m Bachs, etc....
You just can't face the fact that people have talent, you don't realise that science has annomalies, which have to be examed, and often have no explanations. 1 in 10 000 people have perfect pitch according to most tests, so clearly it is a strange thing, it is unexplained.
I was taught maths in the same class as my friend, he's npow at oxford doing it, why am I not? Because he found it easier.
Elevateme and franzliszt2, the indomitable duo, ever childish and dim-witted.
right... get a life