Carl Vine´s piano sonata

[sevencircles]

Listen to the last part (Leggiero) on this recording by Babayan.

https://www.amazon.com/Messiaen-Carl-Vine-Respighi-Ligeti/dp/B00000DMV0/ref=sr_11_1/104-0248593-3295149?ie=UTF8


Is it edited or can he really play as clean live?

[jre58591]

this recording is so damn fast in comparison to michael kieran harvey's or robert henry's (whose is a live rec). i wouldnt doubt that it was probably sped up or something.

[mike_lang]

I doubt it was edited - Joyce Yang's recording is about that tempo, live.

M

[thierry13]

Well it's fast, but i've seen way way worse things than that live, especially by Hamelin. So that is possible. Babadjanian's poem for piano, as a part wich is similar to this, and I heard it live at this speed.

[sevencircles]

Well it's fast, but i've seen way way worse things than that live, especially by Hamelin.

Like what?

[fnork]

Well, it's certainly fast, but the piece is also surprisingly pianistic. There are some tricky spots in the beginning of the 2nd movement, but in general, the sixteenthnotes are right there under your fingers. Most of the time.
Believe me, the first movement is not hard at all.

[jre58591]

what do you guys think of the second vine sonata? imo it makes this one look like child's play.

[soliloquy]

what do you guys think of the second vine sonata? imo it makes this one look like child's play.

Technically it lies a lot less comfortably, but it's just such a crappy piece of MUSIC compared to the first (although I don't know how fair that is because the first Sonata by Vine is just ridiculously awesome) that if you had to choose to learn one or the other, I don't really see how you could choose the second, or third for that matter.

[jre58591]

the third? i didnt even think it was published or recorded yet, at least not by tall poppies records.