dynamics

[ada]

I an having a horrible time modulating dynamics properly, especially subtle nuances within a phrase. I suspect this may be because I'm playing in on a digital at the moment, but I'd be interested to  know if there are any exercises or methods for better expression of dynamics in a piece.

tks

[richy321]

As you are somewhat aware, your problem is that you are trying to develop dynamic control on an instrument that is by its very nature insensitive to the variable that controls dynamic response, namely, downward velocity of the key.  The difference between an acoustic piano and a digital in this respect is vast:  Whereas an acoustic is capable of responding in a strictly predictable way to an virtually infinite range of velocities, the digital is designed to  detect a mere handful, i.e., in a very gross manner.  It follows that any control developed on a digital will be equally crude.  As long as you play on a digital, this may be glossed over, but when you try to play an acoustic the lack of control will be very evident.  It can be developed only on an acoustic, and the finer the action, the better the potential results.

A digital may have some uses, such as learning to read music, fingering a new piece, or practicing without disturbing others, but the aquisition of the finer points of technique, including dynamic control, is not among them.

Rich Y   

[ingagroznaya]

I'm sure it would be very easy to explain on the Internet. Just watch my fingers and read my lips, Ada.

Don't listen to Richy. My digital Calvinova is more responsive, has bigger dynamics range then my acoustic upright Yamaha. Sure, the more expensive is the piano, the better it will respond. Richy is right about that. You can try getting a more expensive piano. IF it will not solve the problem you can then get a teacher to diagnose.

As always amused by questions posted here: My head hurts, could it be my kidney or my liver?

[ada]

Inga, thks, but what is your answer? As eccentric as you are, I suspect you are quite a good teacher, please share

I am glad my question amused you, but I truly regret it if I have caused you kidney failure.

BTW, I am about to inherit a Russian Etude piano. Perhaps you know of this make, although I am told it dates back to pre Stalin. Maybe that will solve my woes.

[ingagroznaya]

Ada, if you are smart enough to know fancy words like "modulating", you must be bright enough to get your self a teacher.

[ada]

Inga, I have a teacher. He is currently on extended leave because of a death in the family.

[ingagroznaya]

Extended leave because of a death in a family? Find another teacher or wait for him to return.

[ada]

Well yes, Inga. I just thought I might bounce my question off some of the people here, tis all   

[ingagroznaya]

Your question seems kinda "bouncy", that's all.