My Waltz

[johnnyb76]

What do you guys think? Any advice/criticism is welcome. Thank you.

P.S., forgive that it's a midi. I can't play it though it IS playable, and as pianistic as is possible.

[johnnyb76]

Forgot to add, it's not yet finished (about half way) Thanks.

[johnnyb76]

Nice to know that people here are helpful. All I wanted was an opinion, good or bad. Didn't matter. Yet I get 50-odd views, only 7 downloads.... and not even those people bother to say anything?

Come on

[Derek]

I wouldn't let it get to you too much. I've posted a bunch of improvs on this site. Sometimes, I get a lot of posts/responses. Other times, none. I'm not sure why that is. I think of my own behavior towards others posts, and sometimes I just download and listen. Other times I feel inclined to say something. In the end it doesn't really matter.  It actually is a very, very rare person who will generously respond to you and provide advice and praise and encouragement etc.  I wouldn't expect much from the average joe browsing these sites.  Try to find a few good friends with whom to discuss music and share creations...and rely on them. That's working well for me and I'm not finding myself wanting for encouragement/feeling like I've been sharing with others.

On another note, I liked your composition! For some reason it made me think of Tchaikovsky, I'm not sure why. I especially like the stuff near the end around 1:28 or so. Anyway very nice.