Black Grand Piano by Schylling Good or Bad start for a child?

[kundera]

Hi,
As a parent of very young children, I have noticed the keen interest of my 3 and 1/2 year old in piano. Like many other parent I want to encourage her but have a very limited budget and wish to be sure of her interest before we move to the next step financially. Can anyone tell me if a "Black Grand Piano by Schylling" which is more a toy, I know, than a piano is something good enough for her to start let's say for a few months until we can get her something better? Or she is better off with nothing at all until next year? Thank you for your input!

[quantum]

Best thing for your child at this time is a good teacher.  Get one that has knowledge teaching very young children (you don't teach a 3 1/2 yr old like an 8 yr old).  Teacher can advise you on purchase of an instrument. 


Since budget is an issue your $179 for that "Black Grand Piano by Schylling" could be put to something more beneficial for your child, and a lot more functional too.  I would go with full sized keys right away.  Consider a digital piano, and do not overlook second hand units.  Some good deals can be had. 

[mezzo piano]

You are absolutely right, the Black Grand Piano by Schylling is a toy and just a toy. But will the  Black Grand Piano be the optimal vehicle to encourage a three year old to want to learn music and continue into piano lessons? Quantum is right in that you can get much more for your money with a home digital piano. But you are dealing with a three year old here and it could be that this toy is better to capture and hold the child's attention.

[kundera]

Thank you both as you have perfectly summed up my dilemma. I have decided to invest in lessons rather than the "toy" and then follow the teacher's advice on a second hand instrument. Best to you.