Kabalevsky Sonata No. 3 error? misprint?

[jlh]

I'm looking at the 3rd movement... is there an error in the last part of this?  11 measures from the end there is written an A and an E and I'm guessing based on recordings it's supposed to be a C and a G...

Anyone notice this b4?

Josh

[birba]

I've played this sonata but I don't have my music out here.  And Kabalevsky doesn't figure in IMSLP.  Do you think you could show the music in question?  Don't ask me how it's done.  OH, I know.  Take a picture and download it and put it here. (Thanks Littletune!)

[stevebob]

It's a C and G here:



My guess is that there's an engraving error in the edition you're using.

[richard black]

No, Stevebob, it's the same misprint in the one you posted. And it certainly is a misprint.

[stevebob]

I'm missing something here, then.

The fifth bar on the top system in the picture is the 11th from the end of the piece.  The quarter note dyad on the first beat is a C and G.

Where are the misprinted A and E located?

[birba]

Missprint (or Ms. Print).  It's G C.

[kelly_kelly]

I'm missing something here, then.

The fifth bar on the top system in the picture is the 11th from the end of the piece.  The quarter note dyad on the first beat is a C and G.

Where are the misprinted A and E located?

As far as I can see, your picture has an A and E in the spot you are talking about... not to state the obvious, but are you sure you didn't miss the change to treble clef at the end of the first bar in the top system? And I agree that the actual notes should be G and C.

[stevebob]

D'oh!  The change to treble clef was exactly what I missed.  Thanks for pointing that out.

I guess it's time for an eye exam ... or something.

[lostinidlewonder]

Maybe some reading practice?

[stevebob]

Nah, I don't think so; I read just fine.  But thanks all the same for your concern!

[jlh]

Thanks guys.  I found that Peters Ed  had this misprint and was looking for a Russian Ed to compare but could not find one.  Cheers!

Josh