PS edition quality

[ajspiano]

Hi Nils/Op 111.

Below are two images taken from the 2 scores listed for chopin 10/1 on piano street. It appears that there is a note incorrect in the PS edition..  This is not the only example I am aware of, - there are many.

I wonder if you are doing anything to rectify these kinds of problems. The quality of the PS editions is great and I would like to be able to rely on them, but unfortunately can't and at this stage would not use one without cross referencing it against another edition for fear of wrong notes.

Scholtz edition


PS edition

[nilsjohan]

Yes, we are in the process of preparing, and will soon publish, a new updated version of the 24 Chopin Studies with improved layout and where the note you mention as well as a few other slips have been corrected.

[ajspiano]

Yes, we are in the process of preparing, and will soon publish, a new updated version of the 24 Chopin Studies with improved layout and where the note you mention as well as a few other slips have been corrected.

So its been in excess of 6 months and many of these small easily adjusted problems still haven't been fixed.

Today I'll note that there is an accidental missing from bar 7-8 chopin 25/6.

[lostinidlewonder]

There was also supposed to be a proper index of all recordings uploaded to the site and its been many years waiting lol.

[nilsjohan]

So its been in excess of 6 months and many of these small easily adjusted problems still haven't been fixed.

The editorial work is done but we had some unexpected compatibility issue when updating our old files in the new version of the notation software. The problem was solved recently and the new edition will be available in August.