Picking a piano concerto (update)

[spookyskeley]

Hello,
My earlier post talked about picking a piano concerto. I have since have an update. I have a remodified list.
I am interested in learning a piano concerto for a competition. The question is, which one? I have thought of a set list:
Saint-Saëns PC 5 2nd or 3rd mvt
Saint-Saëns African Fantasy
Liszt Totentanz
Mozart PC 20 1st mvt
Mozart PC 24 3rd mvt
Mendelssohn PC 1 3rd mvt
Beethoven PC 3 1st mvt
Rubinstein PC 4 1st or 3rd mvt

I really want to learn the Saint-Saëns 5, but I want to learn the 2nd mvt a little more than the 3rd. Is this a good selection?
Ps keep in mind the orchestra is not professnal but highly skilled.
Thanks!

[j_menz]

Other than taking out the two Liszt concerti and slagging off the orchestra, how is this a different question? Why does it need a new topic? Just post in the original!

[johnnybarkshop]

If I had to pick concertos from your list they would be: Mozart No.24, 3rd movement; Beethoven No.3, last movement.  I don't know Saint Saens 5th Concerto, but I would love to play Saint Saens No.2 Middle movement (Scherzo.)  Good luck.

[patrickd]

I would go with the Saint-Saens 5th concerto, it's an awesome piece.