rate these out of ten! 10 being gaspard/ rach 3 and 1 being chopsticks

[classicalnhiphop]

La campanella
Hungarian Rhapsody 2
Islamey
Gargoyles mov 4
schumann tocatta
prokofiev tocatta

if you're going to say something annoying, don't say it.  Just rate em outta 10

[j_menz]

if you're going to say something annoying, don't say it. 

Sir, yes sir!

What exactly are we supposed to be rating them on, btw? Length? Likeability? How friendly their key signatures are?

[classicalnhiphop]

difficulty overall

[perprocrastinate]

inb4 people deliberately saying something annoying just to piss off the OP

[j_menz]

inb4 people deliberately saying something annoying just to piss off the OP

Who would do such a thing. 

@OP - They're all a nine, give or take one.

[classicalnhiphop]

even gargoyles? its not that hard lol

[j_menz]

even gargoyles? its not that hard lol

Hence the give or take.

[qpalqpal]

Islamey is awesome! 

[lisztomania]

La campanella: 8.5
HR2: 7.5
Islamey: 9.5
Gargoyles Movement 4: 7
Schumann toccata: 8.5-9.0
Prokofiev toccata: 7.5-8.0

all quite difficult pieces except for the lieberman really

[pianoman53]

I don't like that grading system...

I grade in my own way if you don't mind, I'll explain:


La campanella             2
Hungarian Rhapsody 2 4.8
Islamey                      11
Gargoyles mov 4         11
schumann tocatta        9
prokofiev tocatta         23

1=difficult, 10=easy, 7=average, 4=finger breaker, 3=sigh reading, 3.5=Don't touch it, 13 being=major difficulty.

[cometear]

I don't like that grading system...

I grade in my own way if you don't mind, I'll explain:


La campanella             2
Hungarian Rhapsody 2 4.8
Islamey                      11
Gargoyles mov 4         11
schumann tocatta        9
prokofiev tocatta         23

1=difficult, 10=easy, 7=average, 4=finger breaker, 3=sigh reading, 3.5=Don't touch it, 13 being=major difficulty.

That's stupid.

[theholygideons]

Having played islamey, i would say it's easy than la campanella.
It feels quite natural under the hands

[david456103]

la campanella: 8.5
HR2: 7
Islamey: 10
Gargoyles Mvmt. 4: 8.5  Rest of Gargoyles: 5
Schumann Toccata: not sure
Prok toccata: 7
 

[chicoscalco]

Hence the give or take.

I don't know why, but I laughed so much at this 

[cometear]

I don't know why, but I laughed so much at this 

Lol I agree it is pretty funny.

[illusionary]

La campanella - 8.5
Hungarian Rhapsody 2 - 9
Islamey dunno
Gargoyles mov 4 dunno
schumann tocatta - 8.5
prokofiev tocatta - 8