Building repertoire

[mrudall]

I find myself just picking pieces here and there. My repertoire is a bit scattered. How do I build a solid repertoire?

[faulty_damper]

Why are you pecking at pieces instead of taking a large bite out of it?  This sounds like when I started learning piano.  I would put in a lot of effort on new pieces and then give up.  I could make it sound good but it required so much practice that the returns didn't justify the cost.