Piano Forum

Poll

Is it possible

Yes
4 (80%)
lol no
1 (20%)

Total Members Voted: 5



Enfant Terrible or Childishly Innocent? – Prokofiev’s Complete Piano Works Now on Piano Street
In our ongoing quest to provide you with a complete library of classical piano sheet music, the works of Sergey Prokofiev have been our most recent focus. As one of the most distinctive and original musical voices from the first half of the 20th century, Prokofiev has an obvious spot on the list of top piano composers. Welcome to the intense, humorous, and lyrical universe of his complete Sonatas, Concertos, character pieces, and transcriptions! Read more >>

Topic: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!  (Read 5078 times)

Offline mjames

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2553
Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
on: November 02, 2016, 05:33:54 PM
See the scribble?
You see the 4-5 cross?
At allegro?
Yeah, I don't think so.

EDIT: NVM, Chopin's bad a$$
Sign up for a Piano Street membership to download this piano score.
Sign up for FREE! >>

Offline chopinlover01

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2117
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #1 on: November 02, 2016, 05:43:00 PM
It's possible to do. That said, it's a bad idea and using 3 there would probably be a better idea.

Not every fingering in this etude is holy, contrary to what old Freddy might have said. The point is to encourage flexibility and ease of playing in fingers 3, 4, and 5, not to destroy your hand trying to follow this archaic piece of piano literature ;)

Are you intending on playing it? If so, good luck!

Offline mjames

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2553
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #2 on: November 02, 2016, 05:50:44 PM
It's possible to do. That said, it's a bad idea and using 3 there would probably be a better idea.

Not every fingering in this etude is holy, contrary to what old Freddy might have said. The point is to encourage flexibility and ease of playing in fingers 3, 4, and 5, not to destroy your hand trying to follow this archaic piece of piano literature ;)

Are you intending on playing it? If so, good luck!

Yeah that's pretty much the same advice I got IRL. Either ignore the legato for that specific part or change the fingering. There's a lot of awkward stuff in op. 10 no.2 but that spot is just bonkers, I don't see how it's possible.

And yeah sort of, it was assigned to me a week and half ago but notice how it isn't in my signature. I think I'll fail horribly lol.

Offline piulento

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 224
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #3 on: November 02, 2016, 07:59:55 PM
Don't expect anything about this etude to make sense... This is just the editor's way of saying - 'yeah, don't even bother... This piece is too hard anyway'

Offline chopinlover01

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2117
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #4 on: November 02, 2016, 08:03:42 PM
Good luck dude. For some (myself included) it isn't the most horrible etude possible, but it's still pretty tough, so good luck my friend!

Offline mjames

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2553
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #5 on: November 02, 2016, 08:16:18 PM
Don't expect anything about this etude to make sense... This is just the editor's way of saying - 'yeah, don't even bother... This piece is too hard anyway'

I borrowed the Mikuli edition from the library however I double checked with a few first editions and the urtext and the fingerings are entirely Chopin's, not Mikuli's.

I call it awkward because well it is, but once you get used to a few parts they start to make sense physically, my hand totally agrees with it so far, even during the "wait what, you want me to do what?" moments. However this is the one spot that I can't seem wrap my head around if I follow the score 100% (playing finger legato). I tried all sorts of things, asked my teacher and even she was flabbergasted and called that particular part idiotic (whereas the rest of the piece is fine). She said she changed the fingering (similar to Chopinlover's suggestion) when she used to play it. I just want more opinions on this particular part, and how doable/realistic it is to follow it precisely as Chopin tells us to. :-X



Can someone link a video of someone playing it exactly like this? Curious if its out there..

Offline anamnesis

  • PS Gold Member
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 274
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #6 on: November 03, 2016, 02:08:31 AM
I borrowed the Mikuli edition from the library however I double checked with a few first editions and the urtext and the fingerings are entirely Chopin's, not Mikuli's.

I call it awkward because well it is, but once you get used to a few parts they start to make sense physically, my hand totally agrees with it so far, even during the "wait what, you want me to do what?" moments. However this is the one spot that I can't seem wrap my head around if I follow the score 100% (playing finger legato). I tried all sorts of things, asked my teacher and even she was flabbergasted and called that particular part idiotic (whereas the rest of the piece is fine). She said she changed the fingering (similar to Chopinlover's suggestion) when she used to play it. I just want more opinions on this particular part, and how doable/realistic it is to follow it precisely as Chopin tells us to. :-X



Can someone link a video of someone playing it exactly like this? Curious if its out there..

Legato isn't simply about holding the keys with the fingers one right after the other.  It's about the timing of the keys and hammers to produce the illusion of continuity. You can play with connected fingers and still not sound legato as well as sound legato without playing completely connected with just the fingers at all times.  Open up a piano and do a glissando and watch how the "eveness" of the hammers.  Finger connection does not at all guarantee that you can get this smoothness when played in time.  

Offline mjames

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2553
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #7 on: November 03, 2016, 02:36:25 AM
I should have been a little more specific, but yeah that was already suggested to me. By the "ignore legato" I mentioned on my previous posts I was specifically talking about strict finger legato, I already know how to fake or create the illusion of legato or whatever you call it. If I didn't I wouldn't be learning this..

So I'm guessing from your post that you don't suggest finger legato on that particular cross as well?

Offline adodd81802

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1114
Re: Sempre legato?! REALLY?!
Reply #8 on: November 03, 2016, 09:33:37 AM
I imagine if your hands were faced to the right enough, this would be possible? Maybe not comfortable by any means.

Also probably easier with longer fingers / small palms, then short fingers / big palms (seems like Chopins physiology)

I've taken a look at this piece, I can play around 80 tempo (Nothing honestly, but just thought i'd check it out)

Actually the bits I struggle on most is hitting C/E/A wherever it arrives on the way down, for example bar 2 at the end Bb with the 3rd then 4th on the A whilst hitting C/E below. Yeah my fingers are too short for this flexibility I think. I can only reach a 9th as it is.
"England is a country of pianos, they are everywhere."

Offline mjames

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 2553
RE: Nevermind, Chopin's a genius
Reply #9 on: November 10, 2016, 02:54:41 AM
I agree with you Addod, but after a little bit more practice (using the fake legato thing) idk what happened but all of a sudden my fifth finger can connect to it pretty nicely. Like I mean, finger legato type of connecting. I don't even know what happened, I don't know what I did, it doesn't feel awkward anymore and it actually feels quite natural. I don't think I'll have a hard time playing that at tempo now.

Damn, I don't know why I ever doubted my main boy's genius. He wasn't so nuts after all! ;D
Now, I'm going to go cry about the middle section.

Offline adodd81802

  • PS Silver Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 1114
Re: RE: Nevermind, Chopin's a genius
Reply #10 on: November 10, 2016, 09:22:28 AM
I agree with you Addod, but after a little bit more practice (using the fake legato thing) idk what happened but all of a sudden my fifth finger can connect to it pretty nicely. Like I mean, finger legato type of connecting. I don't even know what happened, I don't know what I did, it doesn't feel awkward anymore and it actually feels quite natural. I don't think I'll have a hard time playing that at tempo now.

Damn, I don't know why I ever doubted my main boy's genius. He wasn't so nuts after all! ;D
Now, I'm going to go cry about the middle section.

Lol yes even genius is an understatement. There are other master composers in their own right, but only with Chopin could I hear a random composition (of his) for the first time and know it was his. He made the piano his singing pregnant dog. **EDIT** Hilariously, I did not type pregnant dog, however it converted the word B-I-TCH into that. Well played PStreet.

That aside, good luck with the piece, I will return to it, I think I play too flat fingered so maybe this was my initial struggles. I see some pianists play this more with the tips of their fingers in a walking style. Probably increases the distance you can place between the fingers.

I completed Op 10-5. I may post one day, if ever I could get a perfect performance in one take... (yeah right)
"England is a country of pianos, they are everywhere."
For more information about this topic, click search below!
 

Logo light pianostreet.com - the website for classical pianists, piano teachers, students and piano music enthusiasts.

Subscribe for unlimited access

Sign up

Follow us

Piano Street Digicert