Because Bach helps you to develop your ear's ability to hear and follow multiple voices concurrently, to differentiate, and to bring subtle balance of volume there.. sometimes controlling 2 or three voices in One hand… not to mention appreciating an incredible economy of compositional thinking. There is no fat on these structures: every note is necessary.Chopin is not usually perceived as one who deals in polyphony much at all - though, there is some counterpoint there - (however light).
Anyways, I find Bach very difficult. You can't make a wrong note. You must bring out all the voices without interrupting the melodic line. Bach does help your technique
Chopin is not usually perceived as one who deals in polyphony much at all - though, there is some counterpoint there - (however light).
Studying Bach tends to improve all styles of piano playing and especially reading skills, he really is the most useful composer to study in all my years of piano playing (and i hated most of Bachs works when I was young). Most modern pieces are constructed "melody vs support (chords, arpeggios, scales etc). Part writing where there are a combination of "voices/melodies" or parts creating a polyphony of sound is more challenging for our fingers than simple melody vs support writing. It is also more challenging for our listening, coordination and fingering. If you can read/play part writing with ease other styles become somewhat more easily understandable. So for me reading complicated part writing is the most difficult music to deal with, I notice after doing difficult part writing works then going to other styles, it feels a lot easier. It is like the baseball player who warms up with a weighted bat before playing the game with a normal one. Being aware of multiple voices moving individually but working as one is a great skill to improve upon it makes you much more aware of your playing, listening and reading.
No, because there aren't many who look beyond the surface. Here's Oscar Bei in 1898:'...But the peculiar charm of his technique begins only in the parallel application of three voices ...in the laying alongside of three motivated systems, three musical thoughts, three principal paths.'Indeed it sounds as if he's talking about Bach!
Hey Mr. Hardy, you mention "No, because there aren't many who look beyond the surface. Here's Oscar Bei in 1898:'...But the peculiar charm of his technique begins only in the parallel application of three voices ...in the laying alongside of three motivated systems, three musical thoughts, three principal paths.'What material is this quote referring to? Or better yet, what material have You discovered that reflect Mr. Bei's findings?
LIIW -Yes,as you mention "not like the Baroque" but i would add - or like Beethoven, Brahms, etc.