Scriabin Alternate Version of Etudes

[Joseph_Hoffman]

Hello Everybody,

I am giving a recital of the complete op. 11 preludes and the complete op. 8 etudes of Scriabin.

In terms of an encore, I was thinking of playing the rare 2nd version of the D# minor, op. 8, no. 12, etude. It is really very different from the original version and it is really very beautiful.

I was wondering, is anybody else familiar with it or has played it?

I have a recording of it by Ponti if anybody is interested.
Give me an e-mail at alistairebowler@hotmail.com if you are interested.

Also, I believe that there is a Sofronitsky recording of it. Does anybody have this? I would LOVE a copy.

Cheers

[lenny]

https://www.chopinfiles.com/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=1571&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15

i wonder which is better, scriabin recorded only the 1st version

[krenske]

https://www.chopinfiles.com/modules.php?name=Forums&file=viewtopic&t=1571&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=15

i wonder which is better, scriabin recorded only the 1st version

No this is not true. I have a recording of the 2nd version. If you wish to buy, go to www.ebay.com

[lenny]

really?

so why is the 1st one so overwhelmingly more popular?

[dnephi]

In my opinion, the second is far superior.

Daniel

[jinfiesto]

Jo. I sent you an email, I've never heard this second version, and I'm extremely curious.

[jlh]

Hello Everybody,

I am giving a recital of the complete op. 11 preludes and the complete op. 8 etudes of Scriabin.

In terms of an encore, I was thinking of playing the rare 2nd version of the D# minor, op. 8, no. 12, etude. It is really very different from the original version and it is really very beautiful.

I was wondering, is anybody else familiar with it or has played it?

I have a recording of it by Ponti if anybody is interested.
Give me an e-mail at alistairebowler@hotmail.com if you are interested.

Also, I believe that there is a Sofronitsky recording of it. Does anybody have this? I would LOVE a copy.

Cheers

My hat's off to you for even considering doing both versions in the same recital!  Will you play both memorized?

I just looked at the score for the 2nd version -- I'd be interested in hearing a recording if you have one!

jhpianist at gmail dot com