It is in the same part of the brain. This part is like all what's math and science related. The scientifical part of music, is analised by this part of the mind. And how you play what your brain as analised, is reffered by your emotional brain-side.
how you play what your brain as analised, is reffered by your emotional brain-side.
There is a theory that men are better analysts
'females need to practice longer and harder to get the same level of technique, due to their smaller brain'
hamlin [sic] like playing would probably be achieved and possibly surpassed.
Unlikely.
who's the best female pianist? alicia delarrochia, imo.
I totallya gree. Alicia is a MUSICIAN, something that's hard to find these days.
So unless someone can play a Chopin-Godowsky etude, they're a bad pianist? That's pretty sad. Your mind isn't stern, it's limited and unimaginative. (Sry, that was mean, but think of all the great pianists you're insulting)
no, but notice that no females have entered this new arena of UBERVIRTUOSITYyes there are female virtuosos, but no female UBERVIRTUOSOSby this i mean both the difficulty of the music they play and the physical demands of the music, i have NEVER witnessed any female with a technique comparable to hamelin, libetta etc.
Now if Piano was a sports where you got price for playing the fastest that would be all and well,
So unless someone can play a Chopin-Godowsky etude, they're a bad pianist? That's pretty sad. Your mind isn't stern, it's limited and unimaginative.
(Sry, that was mean, but think of all the great pianists you're insulting)
this is pretty much the biggest factor in assesing the greatness of a technique, so yes - no female can play as fast as some males.
Here's some food for thought: First, females have smaller hands than males, so a reasonable comparison could only be made if smaller-keyboard pianos were widely available.
also, for rimv2, what woman is going to waste her time trying to do you in or do anything to you? women are too smart for that kind of revenge. they probably would reason that time spent practicing on the piano is better. you know - point A to point B. then, when you wake up from sleeping, they're like 3 hours ahead of you. (even if they sleep in later).
A misinterpretation on this level seemed only possible by a woman. I now stand corrected - unless you be one . Ah said liszt a female who can play the godowsky chopin etudes. I said not that one was a bad pianist for not being able to play them as there would be only a few good pianist in the world. However, I will say that any woman who can play them will have earned mah utmost respect Still waiting though
I beleive females have smaller hands .But the way, how can you explain why there are so many females piano teacher around?
So, you ask why there are so many female piano teacher around? Because they can't be performers
This fact is linked to another fact. There are much more male performers than female performers.So, you ask why there are so many female piano teacher around? Because they can't be performers
Dude...there are as many female pianists as male pianists, probably more because there are more women in the world than men. Your assertion that teachers cannot perform is idiotic. In fact nowadays it is almost immpossible to have an exclusively performing piano career, unless you are Richard Clayderman or Yanni and play **** like that. Soon Hamelin and Berezovsky will be teaching somewhere if they aren't already.And you will be running for your life, because m1469 is angry and she has sharp teeth and bites...
First, maybe I'm weird but I know many many more mens than women ONLY performers. You only backed me up by stating it is very very hard to make a living JUST by performing, and that's why I meant teachers teach because they can't make a living just performing. You understood me a bit wrong since you said basically the same thing than me.
I am not backing you up, and you are weird! What you are saying is that women pianists are inferior to male pianists, which is bull****. Oh and would you tell your teacher what you wrote here? I think not. If we are misunderstanding you need to improve your use of the language...
Someone said how do you explain there are so much female teachers ( pointing out that females were better). I pointed out that IF the fact there was so much female teachers prooves something, it is that they are less good. Remember well the "if".
First of all, I am most mad at myself for even responding in this stupid thread still. That in itself is P***** me off. But secondly, what makes me mad, thierry, is that I don't think you even believe the things you are saying. I think you are belligerently representing some ignorant thought-model out there and I think you are just saying these things because you have some hidden agenda. Thirdly, yoshiki was not saying whether female pianists or teachers are better or worse, s/he indicated nothing of the sort. If anything, s/he perfectly set up the opportunity for you to say what you said (a month later). Which is why I had stepped in when I did, to try to de-rail the train (so you waited).Anyway, what exactly is your point here ? What are you trying to prove and what are you actually proving ? How is this conversation helping you or anyone ?
He has no hidden agenda, he is in the 9th grade or so. I am angry too, this is a stupid unconstructive waste of time. But mrchops has told the truth.
A couple of years ago I turned on the radio, heard one 2-second passage, and said immediately "That's Argerich playing Chopin." I was right. Her fingers were so remarkably even, such strength and poise in that one passage, it was impossible to mistake for anyone else. This idea of "ubervirtuosity" is a sad reflection of the whole "grade" idea I see all the time in the Student's Corner, this nonsense that technical/musical difficulty fits into a rigid spectrum. The key to a great technique is not what reportoire you play but how well you've played it. I've mentioned elsewhere on this forum that Glenn Gould ought to be considered in any serious discussions of great techniques. Martha Argerich is distinguished no matter what reportoire she plays; excellence, both musical and technical, always speaks loud and clear.
off the top of my head there are a few that stick outrebecca penneys - for her chopin etudesvalentina lisitsa - for her random videosmartha argerich - for many things, espcially liszt sonata, funerailles, etc
A young woman by the name of Claire Huangci (whom I delicately deflowered recently)...
Well opus10no2,Men with dignity don't publically name names in such delicate matters. It is just so low...
What the hell has size of the brain got to do with it??? Or having two different sides to me playing comes from the soul not the brain. Since there is an obvious handicap which I feel is unecessary comes down hand size. Women do generally have smaller hands but why should they be disadvantaged by it. There is a new piano that is made to suit the hands of the player rather than one size fits all. Piano started in a time when males dominated society particularly in the arts. I have heard plenty of female pianists that have equal technique to males that I have heard. Strength, I don't think that if your able to pummel out a FFFFFFF x 1000 that makes you a better pianist, once again though I have heard plenty of female pianists that have obtained what I feel to be a great strength coupled with emotion and technical ability. It's the training, maybe females have to try harder but as usual men have the advantage of larger hands and strength whereas woman (as they do usually have smaller more nimble hands) are also at an advantage. It all depends on what your outlook is.And what I read earlier about men being more obsessive about piano that's just BULL I'm totally completely obsessed. I think males are too, there's no difference in that respect. Anyway I hate comparisons of women against men it annoys me.
She didn't seem to apply the same 'dignity' you'd require when she was boldly crying my name out in extasy through the window, during the act.
Joyce Hatto has been playing the chopin godowsky etudes since she was 13. she recorded the complete set earlier this year on the concertartist label, at the age of 75. i have a few tracks from this recording and guess what, she is faster than hamelin in many of them (including the 10/2 for lefthand alone and the 10/5 tarantella). instead of waiting, your time would have been better spent doing some research.
F**********************************!!!!!!!!DA TICKLAH FEELZ DA ZHAME!!!!!F************************* UNLEGENDARY!!!!