if i were you id listen to the prok 3 a bit more... i used to prefer the 2nd for it's blazing cadenzas in movt. 1 and 4, but now i think i prefer 3 as a whole concerto...
Tom
I understand exactly what you mean! It's just... Prokofiev's second concerto speaks to me more than any other of his works (that I have heard.) The first movement suggests to me the deep darkness deep within the earth, then the concerto slowly works it's way up to the surface, then in the final movement, I feel like there is a furious god-like force falling from the sky.... or somthing like that. I also love how if you take the two themes from the first and last movements, it's like the soul of the peice has completly shifted from a haunting, ethereal narrante theme a much more personal, dramatic human theme.
That, and I heard the second first so... even if the third is a better peice put together, I still think there was more deep, dramatic, soul-wrenching material then the third. Which isn't bad, by any means. The third concerto isn't as heavy... actually, not heavy at all. Quite refreshing. Just a big change.
My favorite part of the third concerto is the last 2 or so minutes, you know, with all of the double glissandos and whatnot. Does that make me shallow?
By the way... I've seen the score and how in the name of Oprah do you finger those? (double glissandos?)