Which Etude is more Difficult

[lavienrose16]

I am practicing both of these pieces at the same time yet noticed that the Scriabin etude(8+) had been given a higher difficulty rating according to this site. I thought that was questionable as the Chopin Etude( was certainly harder for me to play. Just wanted to hear your opinion on the matter.

[chopinlover01]

(INB4 everyone says "oh god not another Chopin etude question)
IMO the Scriabin is substantially more difficult, though it's hard to say as they are different technical challenges. The chopin has it's difficulties with the middle section but isn't nearly as troubling as Scriabin.

[pencilart3]

@chopinlover01 don't underrate the beginning/end. It is extremely hard to get it to sound just right.

[visitor]

bad op. double post is still double post even if worded differently
see
https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=58978.0

[pencilart3]

bad op. double post is still double post even if worded differently
see
https://www.pianostreet.com/smf/index.php?topic=58978.0

I noticed that too. I was listening to 10/3 when I started seeing all these posts about it... turns out they were the same OP.